Software
Houzz Logo Print
chelsey_smithxo

Which do you like best? Or any other colour suggestions?

12 days ago

I actually want to avoid the traditional modern farmhouse look and to with something traditional and timeless but still modern. Any ideas?

Comments (29)

  • 12 days ago

    1 or 2 for me, though I’d do a nice med brown wooden garage and front door….adds warmth

  • 12 days ago

    See the other post you made that I commeted on. This starting to show you why you do not make 2 posts on the same subject......................

  • PRO
    12 days ago
    last modified: 12 days ago

    Change the garage door's style.

  • 12 days ago

    Mark Bischak, what are you thinking in terms of garage door style change?

  • 12 days ago

    The garage door stands out too much on the first picture, but, I do like the darker house. On the white paint, the garage door looks like a giant black hole, and I dont like that at all.

  • 12 days ago
    last modified: 12 days ago

    The garage door style does not suit the house. The very first thing I noticed. The windows on the right side of the door just feel wrong.

    The contrasting color of the garage door is wrong too. Either paint it to match the siding or get a nice wood door.

  • PRO
    12 days ago

    Something that resembles the front door.

  • 11 days ago

    #2 and #3 look pretty run-of-the-mill modern farmhouse, but maybe that's what you mean by "traditional modern farmhouse," which frankly, is an oxymoron. Dark houses look awful in real life, most of the time. Often, as shown in the bottom picture, windows are dark, not lit golden as in your AI pic #1. The result is just a dark, depressing blob. If you do go in that direction, the white of the garage door is too stark a contrast.


    If you wanted to do something that still reads as "traditional, timeless and modern," but not as generic, I might do #2 with a dark navy for the trim and garage door and a medium blue for the front door.

  • PRO
    11 days ago




  • PRO
    11 days ago

    If you want a farmhouse then do a traditional farmhouse. This obsession with “modern farmhouse “ with the black windows and trim is a trend that never should have caught on. Bev’s photo is a nice look.

  • 11 days ago

    Diana , I dont want the modern farmhouse. Id like to choose something timeless.

  • 11 days ago

    Echoing another poster: Black houses look awful in real life. They're also subject to fading, and they absorb heat /raise your summer cooling bills. Finally, they are super-trendy, which means they'll be on the way "out" soon. Anything but black.


    I agree with others above: The garage door reads Mid-Century Modern. Changing it should be nothing.


    If you go with this same house in blue, green or gray ... then add Craftsman posts and a Craftsman front door, the Modern Farmhouse will disappear. What really screams "Modern Farmhouse" is the black and white color scheme.

  • 11 days ago

    Mrs pete , Thank you!!! Do you have any traditional colour recommendations for the home?

  • PRO
    11 days ago

    Who designed this house? If you want a farmhouse tell your architect. Or find a plan by searching “farmhouse designs “

  • 11 days ago

    I do not want a farmhouse .

  • 11 days ago
    last modified: 11 days ago

    Yes, OP has stated at the start that she does not want farmhouse.

    Would you consider a cladding other than vertical siding? sometimes choices, even such cocepts as what is timeless, are guided or informed by the site, the neighborhood, geographical location.

  • 11 days ago

    Hi bpath! Thanks for understanding what im looking for lol. Do you have any pictures as cladding? I'm not aware of that term!!!

  • PRO
    11 days ago
    last modified: 11 days ago

    "Modern" is a design style from the mid-century. You should be asking for "contemporary" (in the moment) that are timeless traditional.



  • 11 days ago

    I had fun with chatgbt... first is a cream and second is white. Thoughts????

  • 11 days ago

  • PRO
    11 days ago
    last modified: 11 days ago

    Either one looks like a ranch house re-do, with an oversized front facing garage.

    Consider a higher pitch to the roof.



  • PRO
    11 days ago
    last modified: 11 days ago

    I just looked at your first post. You should have included the picture of the house as it is now. Better yet, you should have stayed with the original post. I was under the impression this was a new build.



    The large, front facing garage is what needs to be addressed to make it look more "timeless". The paint the siding something like B.M. White OC-151.




  • 11 days ago

    Are you building the above house and are looking for ways to get away from a ”modern farmhouse” look? Is this an existing plan a builder is offering? Can you even make changes? Are you limited by the builder to color selections?

    Cladding is what the average Joe would call siding. The white vertical siding in the above photos is very modern farmhouse looking for the last 5-10 years. Black framed windows intensifies that look.

    The garage door shown seems more Mid Century Modern (because of the windows and their placement), and is at odds with the modern farmhouse look of the siding and windows. I understand you are trying to avoid farmhouse but it will take more than a different style garage door.

    More experienced people might be able to help if they knew the limitations of the cladding, window, and color choices.

    Good luck.


  • 11 days ago

    I like the cream picture, but I'll note that AI changed the proportions of your garage.


    That said, I think your house as is is crying out for more and better landscaping, not a new paint job. You'll notice that all of the AI pictures fixed the brown spot on the lawn, either gave you a defined path to the door or removed it, and most gave you some foundation plantings.

  • 11 days ago

    Mrs pete , Thank you!!! Do you have any traditional colour recommendations for the home?

    I'll say again:

    If you go with this same house in blue, green or gray ... then add Craftsman posts and a Craftsman front door, the Modern Farmhouse will disappear. What really screams "Modern Farmhouse" is the black and white color scheme.


  • 11 days ago

    I thought you were building new, not your current house. Landscape!

  • PRO
    11 days ago

    Oh geez, I thought this was a new build too. If you were more articulate about what you want you might get better advice.

  • 11 days ago

    How abpout a sage green. Certainly timeless.

  • 11 days ago

    The front porch needs a post at the left end. The modern garage door should go, replace with paneled white, or blue, or wood. Can the driveway be changed, so that it isn’t leading straight to the garage door, but rather approaching from the left? Don’t make the garage the first (or only) thing you see as you approach. If you can, there could even be a row of shrubbery, or a gated fence, separating the garage from the left side.