not really fond of either one - sorry.

Probably the first the other is a little too busy - maybe something similar to 2 if you really wanted crystal.

I'm open to suggestions as well if there's something else you think would work better. Thanks!!

I actually like the 2nd one. It depends on what you are going for though. The first one seems to match perfectly (a little too perfectly for me.) I like the unexpectedness of having the crystal in the fixture. Very rustic glam.

Love that one Margo, exactly what's needed, a long fixture. :)

love the crystal look wow factor!

Thanks everyone! Originally I was leaning towards #2 just to help bring some sparkle into the room. (Eventually the mirrored wall will come down). I like the juxtaposition of rustic furniture with some modern shine. I would consider the Clarissa fixture from PB but seems a bit antique/traditional for my taste. Any other options you find would be appreciated. Oval shape seems to work nicely. I love all the input!!