Software
Houzz Logo Print
stephmal

Kitchen cabinet refresh -stain (darker) or paint?

12 years ago
My light maple cabinets have yellowed. The faces and frames are real wood, but the end caps are vinyl wrap (ugly - but does not yellow, creating two toned cabs). I have received quotes to professionally paint ($3500); reface, replacing doors, drawers & endcaps ($15,000) or color shift with darker stain or paint, through nHance wood renewal ($7,000). I am leaning toward nHance because the price includes replacing crown with taller (5'' v 3'') and adding wood panels to ends & around island. Hubby wants to stain, because if we ever tire of it, we can do it again. Paint on the other hand can only be repainted, not returned to wood finish (I am told). I was thinking white cabs & stained island. Have attached pics of kitchen, and other areas of house to get a feel for our style. All appliances will be replaced with SS (micro already has been since these pics). Also will get new hardware. Counters, backsplash, floor are staying. Looking for opinions!!!! Paint a shade of white or stain darker?

Comments (27)

  • 12 years ago
    Maybe this will help:
  • 12 years ago
    groveraxle could you please change my kitchen pic with a dark stain and white paint? Sorry if this is not appropriate to ask.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks groveraxle! I always love your mock-ups! What do you think? I almost like what I already have better now that I see the options in print....maybe neither really works with my floor and counters?
  • 12 years ago
    Maybe change your island color to a distressed black and stainless new appliances will be a start.
  • 12 years ago
    I actually like the white cabinets. I wouldn't do dark with your counter and floors.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks groveraxle. I appreciate your input, help and opinion!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I vote for painted cabinets. A stained island would be a nice compliment to the painted cabs.
  • 12 years ago
    What is the paint color in living room pic, and stairway pic? I'm painting mine....a lot you can do with a basic white kitchen. Do the island a espresso or black.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks all...appreciate opinion! Melanie, hall is shaker beige (Benjamin Moore) and living room is BM 985 - can't remember creative name.
  • 12 years ago
    Great colors! Please post pics of kitchen redo
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    I vote white, but not too white. Although, I do love stained cabinets.....the paint just seems to fit your style better.
  • 12 years ago
    What color white do you recommend Crew of Two?
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    What is your back splash? It looks like a tumbled stone tile.......
    Benjamin Moore Swiss Coffee · More Info
  • 12 years ago
    Great job groveraxle. I'm feeling the white one more. Looks more regal!
  • 12 years ago
    By the way Steph, you have a beautiful home. I didn't even notice the other pictures yesterday. You didn't ask, but I might remove the stuff on top of the cabinets, the Faith sign and the vertical group of three pictures in the entry. I think those changes would be more in keeping with the overall tidy, uncluttered look of your home. The three vertical pictures aren't cluttered but the low height just feels "off" to me. A round hall table might be very nice in that hall spot with two of the pictures above it - moved up a bit.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks Ann! Good suggestions!
    Crew of two, yes tumbled stone on backsplash. Is the color you show an idea for the cabinets? I like it!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Hope this helps.
    stephmal thanked Smartwood Cabinets
  • 12 years ago
    Cabinets definitely needs to be white because of the countertops. Beautiful kitchen!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    If you have any questions with remodeling your kitchen/kitchen cabinets we would love to be there to help you every step of the way! Call us today!
  • 12 years ago
    Our kitchen had similar tones and we painted the cabinets a soft grey and kept the black countertops (hate them but couldn't afford to replace) and black appliances (again, not in the budget to replace). It took a bit of trial and error to get the right grey because our kitchen has a lot of natural light and grey can give tricky lilac undertones, but we're happy with the result. I don't know that white or wood tones are your only options. Good luck!
    stephmal thanked Heather Dyer
  • 12 years ago
    Hi- I have a very similar kitchen. Dark granite counters and off white stone tile backsplash. My maple cabinets have also yellowed and they closely match my wood floors! I have finish failure esp around the knobs. I think they just put a clear coat over the maple cabinets when installed 10 years ago? and it's not very durable.I haven't gotten any quotes but I think I will stain them slightly darker and use a chocolate glaze?? Did you get quotes for re staining? My wood floors will also be redone. I'll be watching answers to your question. I agree with your husband once you paint you can't go back. Your house is pretty and either choice would look great.
    stephmal thanked pitbulls
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    That is a very high price for a reface on that kitchen, I would consider shopping around a bit more on that.
    stephmal thanked Circle Goods Reclaimed
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Great mockup groveraxle as usual. I like the white. If you use N-Hance can you post your experience because I am thinking about using them but I want an unbiased opinion. Thanks.
  • 12 years ago
    Circle Goods, there's also a desk area not shown. I have a total of 27 doors and 17 drawers The reface cost included all new of both. Also, our builder did not put real wood on the ends (it's vinyl wrap which does not fade, and thus why the yellowing stands out so much). The reface quote includes end panels and taller crown. That said, I was having a hard time finding re-facers - Only found 2 and both were similar quotes.

    Pitbulls- yes, I did get a quote to stain, plus add wood panels at ends and taller crown. $7,000.
  • 12 years ago
    Tennisanyone - yes, I will let you know how it goes with N-Hance if I go that route. I have been happy so far with the responsiveness to provide quote, answer questions, offer suggestions.
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Thank you stephmal. My kitchen cabinets are basically in good shape and quality but some are worn after l9 years plus I would like to change the color. I did have NHance give me a quote three years ago but I wasn't ready yet. Good luck to you and post pictures when you are done.