if they were on opposite sides of the bed they'd be fine. or anywhere where there was a furniture barrier between them. side-by-side i wouldn't like them so much. my problem with them isn't color, it's depth and type of weave.

I think they work nicely together. eighpondfazrm has a point. Maybe put a thin carpet pad under the thinnest one for the same "plushness".

I also think the rugs are too different in texture. Prefer to see another flat weave.

Yes.

Thanks! The difference in weaves is exactly my hesitation. Problem is that the rug I have under the dining table now has a medium pile so the chairs make little pock marks every time they are moved and it drives me crazy (It's also ruining the rug). Guess I need to look for something thicker that is woven but not necessarily flat. Appreciate the responses.