Software
Houzz Logo Print
ssprague

1970s dark stained rough beams need facelift

12 years ago
Please help me and offer suggestions for my hearth. I am considering painting out the horizontal (as well as ceiling) and vertical beams to a neutral white. I've always thought of white as beachy - but this house is definitely more Pacific Northwest with lots of evergreen surrounding the house. Don't know if I should start saving to have them professionally sanded down to unstained naked wood. And I definitely would love a mantel, but can't make any decisions until I figure out what to do with these rough beams. Thanks!

Comments (37)

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Hi ssprague!

    Can we see other views of the room?

    ~Lyvonne
  • 12 years ago
    Long wall opposite the hearth. Wood floor is the dining room.
  • 12 years ago
    Dining area.
  • 12 years ago
    We would eventually like to remove carpet and put in the same hardwood as in the dining room. This house needs quite a bit of updating, but I'm stumped for wall color until I make a decision on those rustic, shaggy beams. Any input is welcome!
  • 12 years ago
    Be aware that any light colour will stand out against your fire surround.
  • 12 years ago
    The lines of your ceiling speak mid-century modern to me. Do you like this style? It would be a big, permanant step (you'd want to be certain you like this) but you could go modern transitional by painting the beams and trim and stone all a light color like a white (walls to match), but leave the hearth with the grey modern looking stone. Then you'd want to find all mid-century furniture pieces, and a sofa with strait/modern lines, maybe in a wool fabric. I know this is totally different from the traditional pieces you have, so you may not be comfortable with this idea. Use warm light woods and clean lines. I'll try to find a picture I'm thinking of...
  • 12 years ago
    http://www.houzz.com/projects/77683/Brush-Prairie-House
    Not sure if this internal link will work...but this is a house of a friend of a friend (I was there for a baby shower)...so fun to see it on this site! But I know it was a 70s vintage redone, which makes me think of your space. And this is what's possible. Of course, we're talking a total redo including furnishings...but if you have a good local craigslist, all things are possible even with modest budgets.
  • 12 years ago
    Another view of living room.
  • 12 years ago
    I like the way your fireplace in framed out. I would remove the mirror, and I think a mantel would look nice. If you do paint, primer over the wood first, at least two coats, and then paint them. You probably don't need to sand unless the paint is chipping. Good luck! :)
  • 12 years ago
    The beams will probably not look good painted white because it will still be rough looking only white. If you don't like the roughness deal with that first before you paint it. The room would look good with natural looking beams as you suggested. Also consider the color of the stone before painting the horizontal parts white because the white against the stone may look out of place. A cream color may look better or look at this remodel.

    Palo Alto Eichler Major Remodel · More Info
  • 12 years ago
    Cut a few pieces of foamcore into L shapes that are the width of the fireplace beams. Paint each with a different warm white. Prop them up exactly over the fireplace beams. It'll be much easier to tel what goes well and what is too white.

    If you have to sand, use an electric sander and be prepared for a mess. It will be hard work to hold a sander up.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    It looks like a beautiful space. Are you keeping the stone on the fireplace? If you are, are you going to keep the beams to match or contrast the colors in the stones?
  • 12 years ago
    I like the stone, but it is pretty dark. Maybe if we cleaned it (moved in a year ago and have only done mild dusting), it might brighten the space!
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Give a corner a discreet scrub with warm slightly soapy water - you might be surprised! A gentle go with plain old bleach is also pretty effective, but again, try a spot you can hide first.

    It's easy enough to sand the wood yourself, if you're fairly handy, by the way. Or plane it - make sure you go the same direction as the grain. We just cleaned up some filthy 200yo barn timbers to use as decorative rafters, and they've gone from almost black to looking like brand new pine. Done with a planer, so we lost the adze marks in parts. :(

    I don't know your taste, however if that were my place I'd be tempted to paint all that stone and the timbers white, so it has that white-washed barn look, which I love in real barns, and I think it'd look super in your house. But - that's a one-way ticket, unfortunately, unless you want to be back here asking how to strip paint from stone and timber. ;)
  • 12 years ago
    Rather than sanding or planing, you might want to look into sand-blasting, which will highlight the grain, as well as lightening the colour.
  • 12 years ago
    I think you would like these beams much more if they weren't against a white ceiling. I'd pick a warm, light neutral and do walls/ceiling all the same. A spray bottle of warm water and Dawn dish soap, a little hand scrub brush, some beach towels on the hearth to catch drips, and a follow up water rinse for the fireplace. You might be really surprised.
  • 12 years ago
    I think also the shelves beside the fireplace contrast too much. The shelves themselves look too flimsy beside the trim on the fireplace. I would try the cleaning of stone. I don't mind the beams or fireplace, matches the area you are in with the large trees.
    I'm not an expert, but would everything have to be sanded if you wanted to whitewash instead to lighten them? I've seen pictures where fireplaces were whitewashed, so maybe someone else has some input on this.
  • 12 years ago
    Look at this link to see what was done with a 40yr old home:
    http://renovations.myhousedesignbuild.com/gallery-preview/whole-house-renovations-0
    This is an example of whitewashed stone:
    http://sweethomecharlotte.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/dsc03056.jpg
  • 10 years ago

    Hi there, just wondering if this post still active? I was curious as to what the final verdict was and how came out? I also live in Pac Northwest (Kirkland) and have same (worse problem)! Our house built in '56. Dark (redwood color) cedar slate ceiling with dark stained support beams....which makes for REALLY dark ambiance. After 13 years here I've grown really tired of the dark and am really tempted just to go get paint sprayer and just cover everything with white! But I love my rustic wood....in dilemma! Uuugh! Dark vs rustic. My wish is to keep wood but make raw/lighter? I really liked how previous post recovered beams, they look great! Looks like from what I'm reading...sanding down rough and stain might be impossible (unreasonable). I have yet to see or hear of anyone actually has done it??? Eeek! Curious to see what you decided to do?

  • 10 years ago
    This post has been inactive because I've given up on redoing this room for a while and tackling other projects like stripping wallpaper and priming the wood paneling in my entry and tv room. We also undertook a renovation of the guest bathroom downstairs which ate up our budget. I did however contact a designer who discouraged me from sandblasting the beams to remove the stain and smooth their roughness. She had done it in her house and felt the time and expense (and mess!) were not worth it.
    We will probably not touch the beams, though we would like to redo our fireplace completely- take off the old rock and put up Sheetrock above the mantle/crossbeam and put in newer, lighter stone below and add a new hearth (which is currently a Lego play zone for my son).
    I would love to see what others have done or are thinking of doing. Thanks!
  • 10 years ago

    I think your room with the ceilings look great!!!! We have the opposite problem as we want to remove the white paint from our tongue and beams (from former owner) and restore to original look like yours. Make sure you want to paint it as it is a horrendous job to remove if you change your mind or don't like. Anyway, you have a lovely home. Enjoy!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    personally I like the dark beams,,but I would paint out everything else trim doors, window casements,,except fireplace trim..in a soft white,,BENJAMIN MOORE BALLET WHITE is a beautiful chalky white ,walls flat or eggshell and trim semigloss,,then large abstract art with a natural subject,,see artist Steve Nederveen,,he is brilliant and affordable..the A window wall needs something, like a low long console,great for storage and the 2 large pieces of art above, don't overlook the importance of a great vintage style chandelier in your vault..good luck..and always check kijji!!!!1

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    ps maybe paint out white book case in fireplace cubby,pick a colour close to your trim..and add some colourful glass pottery in shelves..either real or homesense doesn't matter as long as you love the shape and colour..not everything has to match if your collecting,

    as long as it doesn't clash..

  • 9 years ago

    I see this link is old but I googled what to do with my dark beams and this thread came up. I just bought a house and I have the same problem. 1979 house with rough espresso beams. My taste is more light rustic natural and I'm not sure if I should paint them white or even try sanding them. The idea of getting them covered with more wood seems costly and counterproductive. Maybe someone can make a suggestion

    keep in mind this is all the old owners photos and nothing has been done yet. I also have to tackle what I want to do with the paneling.

  • 8 years ago


    I have this same issue in a home I am purchasing. We are closing soon. I am going to plane and sand down to the woods natural finish. I refuse to allow these beams to dictate the rest of the wood I will use and how it is finished, like the mantle I have planned. I’ll let you know how it turns out since everybody else is too scared to work this hard. Just kidding. See ya in a few months.

  • 8 years ago
    With the shelves where they are, a mantel would not be a good idea.
  • 7 years ago

    Has anyone done this yet? I just moved into a house from 1974 with dark espresso-looking beams. Mine are painted, though, not stained. I would love them to be natural wood - looking and am looking for suggestions for the easiest and cheapest way to do this.

  • 7 years ago

    My extremely determined husband initially tried to sand off the white paint on the beams, as well as on the tongue and groove. Then he purchased Citristrip which allowed him to scrape off a lot of the paint. (A messy job.) However, the problem is, you don't get all the paint off that way. We were then told to try and faux paint the beams so they would look like wood (with some wood grain paint kit you can buy). That said, if you have a lot of time, patience, along with a strong neck (looking up can kill the muscles and joints), I imagine any of these techniques will work. As for us, we decided to embrace the white tongue and groove and painted the beams a dark brownish color from Dunn Edwards after my husband only had two beams done in four months! Then I found out through a book that the architect, William Krisel, used this same color in his mid century modern homes in the past. So we are happy. Regarding all the photos here, I think all the ceilings with the dark beams are quite stunning. Good luck to everyone and take care of your necks in the process so you don't have to spend extra bucks on a chiropractor.

  • 7 years ago

    ro25ah, do you have a photo? Just curious: Kristen and Nick, did you end up changing your beams?

  • 7 years ago



    @sdsunn Not the greatest picture, and it keeps flipping sideways, but you get the idea. Maybe if they were stained instead of painted it wouldn't bother me as much? I am just going for a more natural look. I also heard about painting it to look like wood which seems like the easiest option especially since they're already a shade of brown. My sister is trying to convince me that I can unscrew them, take them down and do whatever I want to them but I haven't looked into that yet.

  • 7 years ago

    @ro25ah, I don't know how it looks in real life, but I think it looks great in the photos. Congrats on your new home!

  • 7 years ago
    Sdsunn. I have come so far. It’s been over a year since we bought the house. Here are some new pics. As you can see in the last picture I painted some beans around the opening to kitchen. It was difficult because the stain kept bleeding through. We used 3 coats of kilz primer and one coat of Benjamin Moore advance latex paint. But it’s pretty even with it being rough wood. We definitely plan on doing the rest. We just always busy.
  • 7 years ago

    Kristen Swann, you did a great job with your room; it's evident that you know what you're doing. In my opinion, everything in the room works colorwise and you know how/where to place things. Thanks for sharing your photos and have a wonderful holiday season.

  • 3 years ago

    Hi Shelby, I'm going to be starting a project much like yours, what did you decide to do?

  • 2 years ago

    To the OP: I would do hardwood floors throughout to match the dining room, paint inbetween the beams a color to match or just a shade lighter than the new floors, take out the white bookshelf next to the fireplace, replace with stacked firewood, and remove the mirror. Put a mantel up in the darker wood or put a large brass wall sculpture over the fireplace, like a Jere, for example. I see you have a lot of traditional furniture and color palette, which can be hard to make work in this type of home.

  • 2 years ago

    guys, this thread is *10 years old*! the OP has figured something out! start a new thread!

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals