i think White

Here is a close up of a similar style door, different color

I agree with the above suggestions but would like to add, replacing the lanterns with ones that are larger to also fit in size.. the garage seem pretty large.

Thanks so much this is great!
Here is a photo of the style of my front door. Would any of you change anything about your comments seeing this? Also all the window trim will be painted white in spring. the facia and sofit are a lighter sandtone. (i actually really love the dark charchole of the house above) with all that in mind what style and color would you suggest for the garage door. thanks so much for your help ...trying to order a door today....i was looking at ranch raised panel and plain windows...or carrage house ...im all over the place..dont want to spend a fuortune

What about a wood look carriage style gallery by clopay. Affordable and no maintenance like real wood.

The door atrice mentioned above are insulated steel doors with a low-maintenance woodgrain paint finish. They look great against stone. Many styles are available. Check out the Clopay Gallery Collection and the Cypress Collection at www.clopaydoor.com. You could also go very modern with an aluminum and glass garage door - The Avante Collection. A bronze frame with frosted glass panels would look amazing. Clopay has a design tool called the Door Imagination System on its website. Upload a photo of your home and try on different door styles to see which one looks best. That way you know you'll be happy with the results.