Software
Houzz Logo Print
reilly5472

Which combo do you like better?

12 years ago
Trying to decide between these two combos for my kitchen remodel. The floors and cabinets have already been purchased, so can't change those. Thanks for any feedback.

Comments (41)

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    What shape is your kitchen? The first granite would look fab on an island all by it self. If you have a U- shaped kitchen then the veins will get interrupted at the seams, the second granite would be better for a U shaped kitchen. Either one works for an L shaped kitchen. Many fabricators have the ability to take your floor plan and lay the slab on it so you can actually see where the veins/seams will go in a computer rendering. Inquire with your fabricator if they can do this for you.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I happen to like the second one better as the cabinet doors are solid color and the floors look to not have much movement/activity. I like the pop of color and movement the second selection will bring to the room.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I much prefer the first photo. The second is too dark. Thats only my personal choice though.

    The second reminds me of when I get vegemite on the bench while i spreading it on my toast in the morning hehe
  • 12 years ago
    Love the combo of the first...with gray fog glass back splash.
  • 12 years ago
    I"ll have one "L shaped counter and an Island. The wall on the other side of the island will be all cabinets
  • 12 years ago
    Do you think the raj mahal fits in a traditional style home with a pretty small floor plan? My kitchen is open to the dining room, front hall entryway, and dining room. Is Taj Mahal too modern looking for a traditional space?
  • 12 years ago
    They are both beautiful, I like the second one. The wood floor and second granite pull out the warm golds and browns from each other. Warm and inviting, on a cold winter day, IMO, will pull you in to bake cookies, or a nice beef barley soup.

    The first I could see in a master bath/home spa, very soothing.
  • 12 years ago
    Does anyone have backsplash ideas if I went with the Taj? It has a lovely understated rust vein running through it. Also any ideas on backsplash above range and under hood?
  • 12 years ago
    I like the first one .. not liking the floors on the 2nd
  • 12 years ago
    The floors are already bought, can not change them!
  • 12 years ago
    Copper pendants would look nice ... ivory glass tile backsplash would look nice with the Taj and not compete.
  • 12 years ago
    Pendants have been chosen. They are bell shaped clear crackled glass with bronze colored chain.
  • 12 years ago
    Do you want Honed or Polished? It makes a big difference.
  • 12 years ago
    @Ivstotrvl

    polished
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I really like the first one. It's a subtle contrast but I really like the simplicity of the gray.
  • 12 years ago
    These would work nicely for splash
  • 12 years ago
    the first, the taj mahal.
    with a green-grey glass subway backsplash.
  • 12 years ago
    I like the Taj Mahal with the backsplash dclostboy posted. Not too modern, just an elegant look that will not date. The veining gives a subtle nod to the floor and everything flows together.
  • 12 years ago
    I like the second one better, hands down. It makes more of a statement. I don't like how vague the veining is on the first one.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    The second granite is a safe choice you can find in a million homes. Go with the first and be unique.

    For tile, you might select two options that are in stock (aka readily available) and wait to select after granite installed. Have a large sample of each and leave them up to see throughout the day in different light.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    You should be aware that the Taj Mahal is a quartzite and NOT a granite. Some quartzites can etch on the surface and dull the finish. Care should be used in the kitchen when using these materials.
  • 12 years ago
    I like the subtlety of the first one, it will let you have the liberty of changing colors in the room in the future. I second catieb for the backsplash choice, wait till the counter is installed, it will dictate your choice much more easily when you place a sample against it. Good luck
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    The first one! sooo pretty, and more unique :)
  • 12 years ago
    My personal choice would be the second one. I love the warm tones in it and you stated in your previous thread that you wanted to bring warmth into your kitchen. But, forget what anyone else says and choose the one that makes you smile the biggest :)
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Second pictures with browns for the granite has much more interest & contrast. It pulls the wood floor in much more than the first picture.
  • 12 years ago
    I'm starting to think I'll love the second one better. Here are other pics of that one
  • 12 years ago
    You should get what YOU love. I happen to love the first one, but either will look great.
  • 12 years ago
    What does your husband say? The second one. From the picture you posted about an hour ago, has a different colors you could pick up with the back splash. Pictures don't always show true colors, looks like a blue gray in there, several different browns, some gold.
    When cooking, it will hide more spills and splatters than the first one.
    You said you have bronze pendants, hold them up to the the granite, see how they look with each one.
    I agree with feeny, you should get the one you love.
  • 12 years ago
    my husband finally admitted he didn't like the Taj Mahal after telling me to pick what I like. He prefers the Colonial Gold. Yeah, pictures aren't 100% true to form. there is no blue is the slab. and I love the idea of hiding spills - especially with my kids' habits in the kitchen.
  • 12 years ago
    Definitely get the one you love.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Great selections! They are both beautiful. My vote is for the first one. It is more neutral, as the other counter has the brown in it. The color is very faint in the first one and makes the slightest contrast with the floors, its a subtle beauty.
  • 12 years ago
    I like the ones with the darker coloring in them. It brings vibrance to the wood.
  • 12 years ago
    I think I'm going with the Colonial Gold - its so exciting to be making a decision finally! Floors are being installed Monday, and cabinets soon after that hopefully...and then the granite! I think I'll keep the Taj Mahal in mind for my master bath that needs a redo too.
  • 12 years ago
    Yes, the Taj Mahal will look great in master bath, it's soft coloring I find very soothing.
  • 12 years ago
    Such a personal choice because they are so different. I like the first choice because of the simplicity of it.
  • 12 years ago
    Give up on granite altogether! As designer Maria Killlam says, granite is bossy and busy! This is part of why you are having so much trouble finding one that works, and when you do settle on one, you will find that it dictates your design choices forever, or until you can afford to replace it. Go with quartz in a tighter matrix or a near solid tone, and you retain flexibility in decor choices and a nice, clean look.
  • 12 years ago
    YogaJulie, if you listen to designers, you will go crazy. Every time you turn around designers seem to change "what people should do with the rooms in their homes". One year it is an accent wall, the next designer said"No that is dated" . Some of make overs I have seen, are usually so cluttered, colors that are "IN" now, but will be out next season. The color combinations can give me nightmares. One says do neutral, but what is neutral, this year seems to be gray, others times it is beige, or taupe, or earth tones, what exactly are earth tones?
    People should do and use what they like, they are the ones who have to live with it, not the designer.
    If Elizabeth and her husband want to use granite, they should use granite. It is their home, in all probability what they want is to be able to walk in to their kitchen, smile and say I love this room, I love what WE did with it.
    I for one, wish them good luck and much happiness in their new kitchen.
  • 12 years ago
    berinlist, I agree with much of what you say and also wish them a great kitchen. Design is like fashion and things go in and out of style all the time and that is what keeps the money flowing into the industries. And also, having just gone through this same agonizing decision process in my kitchen, I found that the granite choice, for me, was incredibly challenging due to the irregularity of patterns (natural, so, of course). And when counters are such a big part of a kitchen re-do budget, which many of us will live with for years (decades?), my choice has been to go simple and neutral and add color from accessories and window coverings, which are cheaper and easier to change with greater frequency when I tire of colors or styles. Trying to find a granite seems also to have been/be a challenge for the poster, hence, my suggestion. And for me, when I added in matching a backsplash to crazy-patterned (but beautiful) granite, well, it was all too busy and too limiting. So, to each her own, and yes, listening to designers can make you crazy, but so can listening to readers! :)
  • 12 years ago
    Coincidentally my husband and I went through a similar selection process when we went to our stone supplier three days ago. I think they are both beautiful and cannot make up my mind LOL
  • 12 years ago
    Old post. Go with what YOU love.