Software
Houzz Logo Print
kcarty1

Prefinished or Site sand/finish hard woods? Are oak floors out of date

12 years ago
I will be installing wood floors in approx 2600 sq feet of my existing home . People are leading me toward engineered, plank (5-7 inch wide) prefinished floors with a beveled edge. I seem to be drawn to photos with white or red oak with a Jacobean, 75/25 Jacobean/Ebony, or Medium Brown/Ebony mix stain, sand and finish on site to avoid the lines of the beveled edges. Everyone telling me that OAK Floors are outdated and that I should choose one of the new prefinished floors.
I am willing to go thru the hassle of site finishing if it is the right move.

Would love to hear comments regarding:
- straight edge vs beveled
- prefinished vs site finished (poly on top)
- Oak vs other wood species.

My home is a mix of traditional with a British Classics look. Comfy, not formal. I live in Florida.
Thank you!

Comments (56)

  • 12 years ago
    Oak is NOT outdated. Don't listen to that.

    I also believe in not going too dark with hardwood flooring period, unless you can actually afford stuff like wenge or ebony (hahaha, I know...) Too light looks worn out, too dark shows everything. I don't like any sort of grooving where you can catch dirt in it, so bevel edges are OUT as is 'hand scraped'.

    Me personally just did the whole house but I had to go with laminate (and odd lot, aka in the bargain bin) as that's what the budget could afford. I'd love to go solid and sand/finish in place, but.
    Karen thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    My friend renovated her kitchen/den and pulled out her oak flooring. She went with pre finished at her contractor's suggestion. She walks around barefoot a lot, and says that she can feel the grooves where the planks are attached to each other now ( she couldn't with her old floor). She finds it disconcerting.
    Karen thanked sbrustein
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Oak floors will never go out of date. I know thats a big claim, but I really think thats a fact. How they are finished however does make a big difference. Here are some recent shots of our oiled oak floors. Let me know if you have any other flooring questions. joel@oakandbroad.com
    Karen thanked Oak & Broad
  • 12 years ago
    Rachel H- were your floors solid or engineered? I was thinking that solid warped at 6 inch width. Cannot see photo well. Do you mind emailing to me ? Klcarty@yahoo. Com. Thx'
  • 12 years ago
    Finished on site, white oak, grade 1, stained with minwax Special Walnut are currently being installed in the house we are moving into at the end of the month. It was a no brainer for me- I hate the bevel and short-piece look of pre-finished. Oak is classic, especially if white not red.
    Karen thanked Opal
  • 12 years ago
    Unstained 4 inch white oak.
    Karen thanked Opal
  • 12 years ago
    Jena and Rachel . Thank you for the details and photos! I agree, I'm all for a flat smooth surface which comes with site finishing.

    Now the dilemma. I have red oak in a 400 sq ft family room which touches kitchen and is visible from foyer. Am adding wood to foyer dining living den and bedrooms about 2600 more new floor. Hate to rip out. 8 yr old solid red oak floor but want white oak to avoid red in floor. Also can't put solid in kitchen due to height restrictions w dishwashers and built in fridge. So at least in kitchen have to put engineered unfinished wood or tile. Should i just rip out solid red oak and put in engineered 5/8 in unfinished white oak throughout to avoid height step down and change to white oak. (. prob 5 inch wide) Or b stick w red oak everywhere? I'm horrible at decisions.
  • 12 years ago
    Forgot. Also adding wood to kitchen if i can find a stain color which will work with my cabinets. cher's song "if i could turn back time'. I would definitely do things differently and put in white /cream cabinets to avoid this whole decision.

    And everyone your floors are beautiful.
  • 12 years ago
    If tile in kitchen is pulled out, are there still height restrictions?

    What type of wood are your cabinets?
  • 12 years ago
    Cabinets are maple. I plan to remove tile. But the solid w 3/4 in plywood wont fit under appliances. We are in Florida and have concrete under tile. There is room for glue down engineered under appliances just not the added plywood.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I wonder if standard 5/8ths inch engineered would fit under the cabinets. I bet it would, plus its engineered to resist the moisture movement associated with FLA climate.
    Karen thanked Oak & Broad
  • 12 years ago
    Yes, it would fit.
  • 12 years ago
    Hmmm...given the concrete floor, I would go with engineered. There are so many options and you can have a cohesive look that way.
  • 12 years ago
    Your cabinets appear to be maple or cherry stained brown. I would find a very close match colored floor in white oak. I think you would like the cohesive look. When I have done wood floors with stained wood cabinets, I always go for a match. Looks better to me.
    Karen thanked Opal
  • 11 years ago

    We are just in the process of installing unfinished Ash flooring. It was a good price point, and I wanted to have a specific color so this works best for me personally. At another location we will put in locally milled raw oak, and again finish in place.
    (Sidebar: BTW who's the jerk who told you oak is dated?! WTF? They probably LOVE their laminate flooring!)
    I've wish I had a better closeup picture of the grain on this stuff, cause its Fabulous.
    Best of luck!



  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    PS I forgot to mention to do lots of color tests too. We are using 2 different colors to create the right depth on this job.

  • 11 years ago

    Woops..Old thread, my bad.


  • 11 years ago
    Recently had white oak floors sanded and finished in a darker than medium brown/ebony finish.
    Contractors still in and out and every footprint shows. How am I going to resolve this? Will I spend my life running around with Bona and a mop?
  • 11 years ago

    Take a deep breath and relax:). You are going to love them! The amount of traffic and dirt right now far exceeds what you will experience on a normal basis. I installed dark floors (sort of a dark walnut color, but hickory wood with contrast) and thought the same thing at first. Once all the gunk (adhesive in my case) was finally cleaned up and the dust/dirt removed (took a few weeks at my house), I loved the floors. If you find that it's a problem later, you can always tell people you're adopting the asian way of life...leave your shoes at the front door. We wear shoes in the house and only mop the floors once every 2 weeks, maybe more often in the kitchen. Best wishes!


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    The type of wood flooring that is best suited for your home is also dictated by the kind of sub-floor you have. In Florida, where we have concrete slabs, there is also a lot of moisture vapor that peculates up and of course you have high moisture in the air. Most all solid flooring is 3/4" thick and a plywood sub floor would need to be put down. The advantage of a prefinished engineered wood floor, you are getting a factory finish in a controlled environment, you are able to get wider planks that are constructed to be more stable, you will have more choices in types of wood species and finishes and you can do that with a 1/2 thickness with no additional sub floor required. Also in most cases, a prefinished engineered wood floor is more economical than a solid sand and finish product. There are many floors on the market, and I would not say the "oak" is a dated look, it is the most common wood floor used. But what is dated is a more narrow strip look instead of a wider plank. Best of luck with your project!

  • 11 years ago

    Oak floors are classic, timeless and beautiful. The "dated" quality comes from staining a mid-tone. Some grains pick up the stain more than others, creating a busy pattern. The darker you go, the less this matters, but dark floors are tough to keep clean looking. Natural avoids both issues. Natural oak -- the kind you see in old New England homes, mid-century beauties, and contemporary architecture -- never goes out of style. I disagree that narrow strip is dated. Narrow strip is stable and says "this floor is real." Check out what Edythe and Eli Broad have in their house (Architectural Digest from a few months ago)!

  • 11 years ago

    I'm trying to make this decision right now too. We are building a new house on the beach. I'm considering a white oak character grade wood floor by The Woods Company, engineered, but no bevels, and would like to finish it in a Rubio Monocoat 5% Smoke finish. I like that I can put radiant floors under this product, however, I'm concerned that I may not be able to refinish it, given the amount of sand we will be living with. I know it will be less thick than non-engineered, but since it comes unfinished, shouldn't I be able to refinish it least once, if needed?

  • 10 years ago

    Stephanie Hogenson, how did the unfinished engineered wood flooring with the Rubio Monocoat finish work out? This is what I want to do, but am having trouble finding unfinished engineered flooring locally. I am a little hesitant to purchase this kind of thing over the internet. Especially not knowing wear layers for refinishing.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    American made Engineered flooring should have at least a 4mm wear layer.

    Educational Plank Flooring Examples · More Info

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Engineered comes in 4-6mm for the quality stuff. Lots of mfg's make this type of product.Where are you located? Finished on site is always better than factory finished due to a) floors are truly flat c) floors are sealed across the entire surface c) you can choose and specie and stain combination d) you can choose such a variety of finishes on the market today. Tons of good ones Any decent contractor runs dustless equip so the days of big messes are long gone. Factory finished gives limited choices and usually the installers are much less experienced in the field as a whole over the certified installers/sand and finishers out there. With all of the above things I mentioned why wouldn't you go for site finished? Good luck in your choices I wish you well!
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    1.
    Natural Red Oak is a timeless
    hardwood flooring option, it never goes out of style..
    Site finished hardwood looks –
    Anyone can see the difference and you will know. So do it once and do it right..

  • 10 years ago
    We decided to go with prefinished in the end. Site finished looks gorgeous but the maintenance (recoating every few years) and needing to refinish every 10 years just seemed like such a hassle. Plus the VOC issue with children didn't seem worth it. We've always had prefinished and have never had to refinish - they definitely last longer (good quality ones that is). Although they do scratch too they've never scratches threw to the wood.
  • 9 years ago

    Laims may I ask the manufacturer you went with for your floors? We are in the process of looking for prefinished flooring, thank you so much.

  • 9 years ago
    Hi Shannon, our builder uses Mercier Flooring (Canadian) which has a very good reputation. I've heard Vintage and Lauzon are also good (also Canadian).
  • PRO
    9 years ago
    Prefinished is such a limited choice. Someone mentioned earlier about dust and recoats? That's false info btw probably supplied by a floor store that amped up the prefinished sale. Recoating after a few years? That's not correct at all.
  • 9 years ago

    how does a prefinished red oak select floor look next to site finished red oak select floor? One will be perpendicular the other. Is it noticeable?

  • 9 years ago
    I think it will be noticeably different. The prefinished will have bevels and the sheen/colour likely won't be an exact match.
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    @Stephen Pierson...you could get a GREAT match with minimal appearance difference or you could get the WORST "match" in the history of mis-matched floors.

    It all comes down to what you CHOOSE. And without photos of what you have + what you are thinking of IN the space it is a crap shoot.

    What you might want to remember is that as much as 30% of the male population have some sort of colour blindness. Whereas colour blindness in women is quite rare. That means you MIGHT want to have a woman in the space looking at the sample (it MUST be viewed IN your home...in all 5 types of lighting situations) to get a true perspective as to whether or not your CHOICE of factory finished red oak is going to work up against the original hardwood.

    Personally, knowing that red oak is the easiest, most affordable solid hardwood available on the market today, I would work with solid hardwood and deal with the sanding/refinishing now so that later I'm not kicking myself for going the "easy" route when the "best" route was on a snick more expensive/difficult to deal with.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I had this same issue and even when having my floors color matched with the exact same flooring they could not match it perfectly and I can see the difference. You will never get a perfect match if you go with prefinished verses site finished. The process and color options are so different and even micro bevel flooring will be quite noticeable next to your straight edge site finished floor. I suggest going with site finished flooring it will look a lot better than having two different types of flooring. You still won't get an exact match but it will be quite close and appear to be the same flooring, not a remodel job.

  • 9 years ago
    laims Do you mind sharing which colour you went with? We are looking at Mercier flooring now and are torn on colours.
  • 9 years ago
    Nicky we went with arabica in a wire brushed finish. Not sure how it look yet as we haven't yet moved in. Smoky brown was another top contender.
  • 9 years ago

    Rachel H: Do you remember where you bought your floors from? They are exactly what I'm looking for!

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    Someone mentioned prefinished has a thicker wear layer than sitefinished. That is incorrect totally. All prefinished starts out as unfinished and gets sanded multiple times. The bevels are there to hide the 'overwood'. Site finished wear layers are usually 5/16" and prefinished are just under 1/4" if it's a solid product. Site finished will always be a better floor in the hands of a craftsman. Always.
  • 9 years ago

    Totally agree. Plus, if any water gets into bevels of pre-finished wood, it sits there and makes the surface bubble up and peel. (i.e. Ice cubes, etc. ). I never had that in my site finished floors.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    Yes finish failure is very high. My site finished kitchen floor has cupped many x and returned to normal without mad damage to the finish (dishwasher/fridge)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I recently moved moved into a home w prefinished solid Brazilian Tigerwood floors. They are in great condition but I am not a fan of the bevel and also feel like the prefinished oil based polyurethane finish attracts a lot of dirt and shows everything ( especially in the kitchen). Thinking about having them refinished just to get rid of the bevel and also put a water base satin finish on. It's a huge hassle and expense and can't decide if it's worth it. Any thoughts ??? Will the water base finish be easier to clean ?? I have two small doggies :))) Thanks.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    Do it!! Although I feel waterborne finishes mute the color of exotics. Try using a hardwax oil instead. They make the colors pop!!
  • 9 years ago

    Hi there, I had my entire upstairs, most recently the kitchen, done with on-site laid and sanded red oak, finished in Jacobean. We absolutely love the finish and the durabilty. Most of the upstairs has been installed for 1.5 years now. We also have a cat, no kids. Let me see if I can find a good picture.....

    Here's the kitchen with the barnd new, one week old floor. Its just beautiful. Please excuse the kitchen-in-progress!

  • 9 years ago

    Honestly I would rather mute the colors. It's just not my style. It's the way the dirt adheres to the current finish that bothers me and I don't know if a water base satin finish will make any difference or if it's just the darker color of the wood that shows all !!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hey, also, for what its worth---- when we bought our house, the hallway and stairs were existing red oak, HIGHLY shiney and yellow looking. We paid to have the carpets removed from the rest of the upstairs, red oak installed, and the whole kit and kaboodle sanded and stained in the minwax Jacobean. a week ago we pulled out the super outdated white vinyl floor in the kitchen and had the same red oak with jacobean laid. The finish is matte- not shiney. The combo. of the natural grain of the oak and the jacobean finish resulted in a mid-dark color floor, but the grain is slightly darker- it looks great. It is a dark and rainy day in Oregon, but I'll post pics later with lights on. All three areas- the original red oaks, the new red oaks floors in living/dining/bedrooms that are 1.5 years old, and my one week old kitchen floor are seamless and you can't see the difference. My thought is that if you go with the solid wood sanded on site, be sure you check references on the installer, and ask if they've maybe done a floor in that combo in the past. They may have an idea of the outcome.

  • 9 years ago

    Hi Eileen--your floors sound beautiful. Can you post the outcome? I am a fellow rainy NWesterner located in Seattle and am leaning semi-dark oak floors in our new house.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    i want to go with a wide Engineered (character grade) European white Oak floor i live on the water. I need 2300 sq ft of it and cant find a flooring store with a variety of engineered wide floors. Is it better to buy on line? If so can you suggest a reputable on line co to order a large amount from? I live in DC area.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Susan Davis, have you looked through our line up? We ship floors to your area all the time. :-)

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Susan where do you live? We have a big selection to choose from and we are in Jacksonville FL.