I thought about a round mirror, but there is a chesterfield sofa and a lot of other round elements in the room. The candles in picture probably wont be used, I was just trying to better visualize the space. The omni mirror has a frame while the other Z Gallerie mirror has no frame.. thanks for your help! I appreciate any further input/suggestions.

Since it will be a pretty great focal piece of the room, have you considered something with a more dramatic border? Best wishes!

http://st.houzz.com/simgs/e441e0c302b11720_4-7506/contemporary-mirrors.jpg

http://www.zgallerie.com/p-12469-sienna-mirror.aspx

I don't know how much money you want to spend, but I think you could find a much more interesting looking mirror, possibly for the same amount of money or maybe a little more-- on Etsy, or Ruby Lane-- a mirror that would be beautiful and also function like a piece of artwork itself. Maybe it's just me, but the mirrors you posted seem really uninspired. Your room and fireplace look so interesting, and these mirrors don't seem to mesh all that well with what you show, plus they seem more like bathroom mirrors to me.

If the mirror will double the ceiling fan, why would you want to do that? ART!!!

I think the mirror can be slightly tilted the right way so that it doesn't reflect the ceiling fan. Perhaps there's a great piece of artwork on the opposite wall, so that it will reflect that.

Thanks for the advice. I clearly need a lot of help! Across the room I have the furniture pictured below ( black chair, gray couch, light gray chair), a steel coffee table and a 24*36 picture. I was trying to find something discrete, as I wasn't sure what would go with everything else going on If anyone has any links to something that would work well, its much appreciated:)

Smaller one better mirrors the firebox...think it also fits the rest of the furnishings nicely.

Here are mock ups of the two mirrors you mentioned as well as an oval one and a round one. Of the four I like the second one which is Reflection Wall Mirror you talked about.

Your furniture is gorgeous! I think it would be prettier with art though! A Family portrait would be nice or just one family member. Maybe you should think about getting in touch with a portrait artist in your area. It would beautiful and elegant.

I have to agree with Dianahb.

Hello. A rectangle shape with a larger frame to add detail and interest above the fireplace. Best of luck

Well, it's so hard to tell with the furniture and not seeing the whole room-- but these are just ideas-- staying within that same price range. It might take you a while to find something, but anyway-- take a look at these.

https://www.etsy.com/listing/173198192/a-large-vintage-american-art-deco-period?ref=sr_gallery_23&ga_search_query=large+art+deco+mirror&ga_view_type=gallery&ga_ship_to=US&ga_order=price_desc&ga_page=0&ga_search_type=all

http://www.rubylane.com/item/1089590-47/Antique-Empire-mirror-original-mirror

http://www.rubylane.com/item/482733-GFx2e1910/Vintage-American-French-Revival-Gilt

You could actually go with either, so go with the one you like the best.

Also check One Kings Lane; they're having a sale on wall mirrors right now. You may find something there, too, in the size you need at a reasonable price.

I love your living space! If you want a mirror, I'd also suggest a round to break up the rectangles at the FP and also relate to the curves of your sofa, and coffee table. A wood one would relate to the floors and FP as well. How about this one? Or the beautiful hammered copper one?

You may at first think WHAT? But, this mirror (hung horizontally) would look awesome. An unexpected traditional baroque...

You need art. You have mirrored cabinet next to FP.

I agree that art would be more suitable. Especially considering the height of the fireplace as the mirror would only be good for reflecting light as it is too tall to functionally act as a mirror. In addition, art has the ability to soften a space or add a great deal of drama to a space so sky is the limit when it comes to the mood that you would want to set.

I really like the painting you already have. Is it too small for that space?

Art or a mirror-- anything but a TV.

Thanks everyone for your input! Now, I am in search of art- as many of you suggested that is a better option. I like the idea of a map,

I found this one, and it would cover the complete space height wise, leaving a little room for accents on either side. Might this be a good choice? Or does anyone have any map or art links?

Thanks again, this is so helpful!!

http://www.zgallerie.com/p-14174-golden-world-map.aspx

Hi klfmay85, Marie here. I like the idea of art, but I also like the idea of layering. Your forgetting the aesthetic and style of the mantle - which feels craftsman to me. Not sure if all your furnishings are more craftsman - but the mirror definitely needs to reflect your style (no pun intended).
If you are going towards artwork - make a statement with that artwork - and tie-in the colour into your space - go minimalist, or layer thoughtfully with items that compliment each other - always has a more modern feeling. Most importantly, make the items you are displaying things you love and have collected over time - after all, they are being displayed in a place of honour! Good Luck to you.

Yes-- what Marie said. :)

Hi klfmay85, marie here. If you have a metal coffee table - then bring that same metal up into an art piece over the mantle. Make sure proportionately it can stand on its own with the fireplace - and don't copy the exact same pattern as the coffee table - that looks to matchy matchy - something like this perhaps, or, if you want it to feel more current and chic - go to a burnished gold sculptural-textural mirror

Hi again klfmay85, I've composed a quick compilation utilizing gold - not sure if you really love this or not, but whatever you do - start slow. Find one item, then keep adding and subtracting until you get it just right. I'm always changing up my mantle - depends on my mood!

Why put a mirror when you can have art. There is glass right next to the fireplace . I would not repeat glass over the fireplace. The eye prefers to see a variety of materials and textures. The diversity of materials adds interest to a room. Also, regarding mirrors over the fireplace, they are too high to reflect anything positive. They usually reflect a ceiling fan, which I see you have in your room. This is a pet peeve of mine. It's a rare occasion that I hang a mirror over a fireplace.