Software
Houzz Logo Print
pgjacob

Demolish or rebuild?

12 years ago
I currently have no access to by back yard and park on the street. Acquiring a lot behind me may solve this issue (currently awaiting the real estate agents call...). I can now build a garage in the back and add on a master bath. But now with this access, should I just start over? House is 125 years old, downtown, great location to see the Christmas parade and July 4t fireworks. Primary lot is 50 feet X 200 feet (new lot, if acquired, will be 80X100). Can I begin construction on a garage that is livable, and move in and then demolish? Pros and cons?

Comments (23)

  • 12 years ago
    Is the house historically significant? If you are in a neighborhood of historic homes, you may be limited as to what you can do. Once a 125-year-old house is gone, it's gone.
  • 12 years ago
    Check out the permitting requirements for your town. In ours if you leave a certain amount of the original house, sometimes just a wall, your permit is less, and your property taxes are less because it is considered a renovation. Also in our city if you add a bedroom your school tax will increase because they assume that you are adding a child (ludicrous). Do you have children and pets? We lived in our garage, one bedroom/bath for nine months. It took its toll and we do not have kids. The contractor was great in that he would keep my washer/dryer hooked up for most of the project, even if it meant moving them in and out. Not having a washer/dryer could be a deal breaker. Our renovation was from March to October so we used our barbecue and camp stove. We turned the garage into a great room w/ tv, fridge, eating area, and small kitchen set up w/ microwave and toaster oven. Our hot water heater helped with dishes or I would take them to the neighbor's house. It got pretty lonely sometimes and we had to leave for tenting and drywall.
    Melissa J. thanked Maria Smith
  • 12 years ago
    My in-laws lived in a 26' travel trail for the 7 months it took to build their home. It wasn't fun, but they did it! Hope you get your project completed!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    How does your neighbor prevent you from accessing your own back yard?
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    We renovated a 100 yr. old house and I would do it again. I love taking something old and giving it new life. We are now doing a 50's rancher and we are having fun. Just to mention in the house in the pics we lived in 1 room in the basement for 8 months, got to know each other very well. We did all the work ourselves so a much longer process. I also think if you have the opportunity to buy land in the city do it, always going to give huge payback.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks to all the comments. very helpful. Nice pictures as well! Good to know that it is not unknown to rough it in a garage, etc. for a while. It is just me and my dog... so good to know about the property taxes regarding assuming children. I will check on historical homes. House is old, but i don't consider it historical...

    Neighbor to my left has driveway that runs along the side of my house (in pic, my house on right). My survey says I have a sliver of the driveway, but neighbor disagrees. the only way to get to the back of my house is to use driveway, and even though he owns the majority of the driveway, he is not neighborly, his right unfortunately. He has since built a chainlink fence (partly on my property) along said driveway which serves no purpose other than to make it difficult to maneuver on that side, so no construction, etc (fence connects to nothing, just a 150ft long fence along border). With the potential to purchase the lot in the back, I will be able to enter that way. I have since learned crazy neighbor has made offer on same lot. I hope at least I can win this "Battle of the Lot".

    New to Houzz, looks like it will be a good resource should I continue on the mission to remodel, etc. Nice to have people providing their real experiences.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    After you purchase the lot behind your lot, erect a fence on your left property line per your surveyor's determination.
  • 12 years ago
    I would check to see if you have legal recourse here. Rules about easements can be pretty liberal and practical, and if your neighbor is denying you access just to be mean, the city may have something to say.

    I live in a historic district and the lots were all oddly cut. However, someone had the foresight to add a deeded strip to my middle lot so I have access behind my neighbor's house.

    If you can get the lot behind you, that would be ideal. But I would consider carefully before I demolished a 100+-year-old house. Good luck.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    There is always a jerk in every neighourhood too bad yours in next store. Good luck with getting the plot. I am pretty sure what ever you decide will be the right thing for you.I would go to the city and find out exactly where that property line is, mark it on the driveway with orange paint and let him deal. Most cities have easement criteria between houses so my guess is that part of that drive is your property.
  • Melissa J. thanked sunnydrew
  • 12 years ago
    There is some history of legal action, and I don't understand alot of it, but there is a "Complaint to remove or cancel cloud on title and for injunctive relief" by the neighbor with a previous owner of my house. I think it was ruled in the neighbor's favor. I realize alot of time and money would be needed to research the deeds, etc., and I have gone to lawyers (one of which told me that my security cameras - which I put up because my neighbor was vandalizing my property and I have him on camera doing it - were upsetting the neighbor and I should remove them). Small town, small town politics, and they seem to coddle the neighbor. I am a newbie here while the neighbor's family has been here for donkey's years.

    Hopefully it is a moot point except for the property line dispute along the driveway may come into play during remodeling process. This neighbor has caused alot of stress, and from what I hear, good fences build good neighbors, but what where do i build the fence? Hopefully I can get a definitive answer from the city and do some creative fencework to arrange the boards into the letters HAHAHAHA.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Most cities do NOT have the definitive answer on property lines. A licensed surveyor does and once done it holds up in court. Most surveys can be done under $1,000. Then you can involve the city to enforce the property.

    Typical zoning laws will allow existing conditions (as long as the property line is established) to continue: ie the driveway likely will remain where it is and your house will be allowed to stay where it is despite a 5' or 10' setback that is likely in force today. On a 50' lot, If you tear the house down, you may have to build one that is only 30 or less feet wide.

    To build on my 40' city lot, I had to partner with my neighbor to share a driveway or live in what amounted to a double-wide mobile home design. By creating that agreement to share (which doesn't sound possible with your neighbor), my house ended up looking like it was built 75 years ago with the rest of the neighborhood.

    As you can tell, the city code is really important to your decision. The rest depends on your patience, budget and fortitude for "adventure". (personally, I love the challenges of fixing up an old home!). It sounds like purchasing that rear access through the back lot is your best solution and creates the possibility for some nice designs.
    Melissa J. thanked Artisan Builders & Consultants
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    The question of whether to renovate or demolish and start fresh is something we have wrestled with on many projects. It is not answerable without making some design studies of the possible renovation solutions. We always start with the goal of renovating, since re-using existing structures is good common sense and inherently sustainable. If the design studies reveal too many problems with the existing structure, then take a look at a new house design and compare. This process usually takes several months.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    To answer your first question from my perspective:

    If I had money to buy the back lot and money to build, I would tear the original house down and start fresh. If your city will give you an occupancy permit to live in a room over a garage while building the new house, that is great. Then, you can position both the house and the garage exactly where you want them.

    Then my opinion which agrees with the above recommendations:

    Have your local (and most favored by the city) engineering firm mark your boundaries. I would not spend one cent on anything until that was finalized. Do it anyway, regardless of your decision.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    If, and before, you decide to tear down the existing, check setback requirements and other zoning restrictions that will impact the design that may convince you to remodel the existing.
  • 12 years ago
    interesting about the historical setbacks going away upon demolition. I have alot of homework to do! thank you for all the comments.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I agree with Bischak. Check with your local planning department and perform a quick zoning analysis. The major zoning form givers on any project are setbacks, height limits and lot coverage. You may find that your current structure allows for greater use of your yard than new regulations.
  • 12 years ago
    Melissa, your home is "grandfathered" in because it was already there when the zoning ordinances were enacted. If you have a copy of your Title Policy it should say if there are any easements held by others. Most of the time the lender will require that a survey be done. There should be a copy of it in your closing papers. If you want to build or use the property in a way that violates current zoning you may be able to apply for a "variance" to the zoning ordinance. You must advertise that you are seeking a variance and the public has a right to challenge your request. Your city council will determine whether the variance will be granted. If you do not have copies of your closing papers, contact your lender and request copies. Contact a different lawyer and take your closing papers with you when you go your meeting. Having a complete set of your closing papers will save you and you attorney time and money. I would not contact anyone with the city until I met with my lawyer. If your town "practices small town politics" and believe me, I know that does go on, you don't want to start kicking up dust until you have to. Hope it works out in your favor!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Your home may be grandfathered, but if you tear it down, grandfather may go away and you play by the current rules. Contact an architect that has experience with the local zoning code and the way it is applied.
  • 12 years ago
    Contact a lawyer who specializes in real estate law first. Lawyers are the only people legally allowed to dispense legal advice :)
  • 12 years ago
    Melissa J: We used to live in a Victorian (1894), in a preserved historic downtown neighborhood. I could have written your story, word for word, myself as it was EXACTLY the same scenario with the neighbor from hell, the driveway and his easement rights, and no access to our back yard, basically. We were parking on the street.. We'd already spent way too much (sweat equity included) on restoring and maintaining this old house. So between the bad neighbor, the historic preservation society, the bad schools, parking on the street-- we finally chose to move-- but it was mainly the bad neighbor that was the catalyst.

    My suggestion is-- unless the neighbor has one foot in the grave-- there is no way in hell I'd sink a bunch of money into a house like that-- and you are STILL stuck with the bad neighbor who, it sounds like, is always going to be giving you grief. Put it on the market, and move. I can't tell you what a good decision that was for us. We moved only 2 miles away, still downtown, in a state-recognized historically preserved neighborhood (without the local preservation silliness), in a 1927 house (so so much better built!)-- and we love it. Great neighbors, beautiful house with tons more charm than the Victorian-- and amazing schools. Oh-- and my studio is in my back yard (which I can actually access!), and we have vegetable and flower gardens back there, too. Best decision we ever made. Our bad neighbor, who was old at the time, died only a few years ago-- so we would have been stuck with that nonsense for a long long time before he ever kicked the bucket.
    Melissa J. thanked dbh
  • 12 years ago
    surveyor. give them all pertinent documents including any decisions against the prev owners of gour place.
Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio