Software
Houzz Logo Print
keysfins

Which rug for Florida home

12 years ago
Dilemma: we found two very different rugs that we like. Rug store allowed us to take them home to see how they look in the space we will use the rug. (We have not yet decided on sizing.)
First one is a "safe", very typical, soft floral rug. The second is much brighter and bold.

Our consultant, Jill at Chic on the Cheap, gave us some home color ideas a couple of weeks ago. The area for the rug is the first thing guests see upon entering our home, so she recommended a bold, big rug.

Which would you choose, and why?
The softer blue rug
The brighter, bolder rug
Find something else!

Comments (30)

  • 12 years ago
    The second rug is rather limiting in color choices and looks more like a hooked Colonial rug to me. I prefer the first.
    keysfins thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    #1 large tropical
    keysfins thanked pjlhome
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks, Nancy. That's what we plan to do, this is a 5x8 that they let us take home.
  • 12 years ago
    Ok, a couple of other possibilities, photos attached.
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Left is by Waverly, and is 100% polyester. On the right is a similar rug as the first, tropical, but has more colors, 100%wool.

    And just for fun, a photo of the "bright" rug at the rug shop, in good lighting, showing some of the colors. Zoom to see the detail. There are teals, periwinkle, black, white and navy. It is very plush, as much as the tropical ones we picked out.

    I still like this because it has a grey field, not white or ivory. With our walls to be BjM Wickham Gray, this one would tie in with the walls. Not that the others would clash, of course.
  • 12 years ago
    You just answered your own question! Rug number two in the poll!
    It has a darker background and will not show dirt as quickly.
    keysfins thanked nasmijati
  • 12 years ago
    I sense that you like #2 the best, and that's what you should choose, other opinions aside.
    keysfins thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks, I admit that I really do like the second one, but it is quite busy. The first one is nice, it's something that I would expect to see in other homes here. Besides the large scale, there isn't anything that makes me go "Wow!" We may run and get the other floral rug (#4) to try in the space, it has more colors that pop in it compared to #1. We may even use the bright, busy rug in another spot in the house, just not the entry. Thoughts?
  • 12 years ago
    Number 3 (the Waverly) is by far my favorite. Number 2 is my second favorite, then number 1 and I don't like number 4.
    keysfins thanked Ann
  • 12 years ago
    The first rug has beige in it. It blends with the floor. The second rug just really stands out. Wow
    keysfins thanked newman1958
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Your sofas and wainscot are feeling a bit more traditional or transitional. Are you aiming for a FL look or just a comfortable room? Have you considered a large I/O rug?If you have a pool and people will be in and out the doors, it might be a good choice while you continue to look for the one that makes your heart speed up. Just rinse it off when needed. These are all from homedecorators.com
    keysfins thanked decoenthusiaste
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I like the big bold rug because something about it just grabbed my attention. It's prettier and the colors are lighter.
    keysfins thanked SERreal Designs
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks! Newman1958, I think you hit it spot on that #1 is just sort of there, looking like a very presentable and very "Florida" rug, on the beige tiling, it sort of disappears, in a way.

    Ann, I really like the Waverly, as well. That may be a contender for a hall in the Master.

    Decoenthusiaste, yes, those I/O rugs are definitely an option, we've used them in our previous home. Our basic style is relaxed and comfortable, definitely NOT traditional or fussy. Thanks for the source on those.

    Shannon Redwine, that's what happened to me when I saw a larger version hanging. It DID make me go, "Wow!"

    I don't want to over-do the blues, especially at the entry of the home. But I do like that bright one, perhaps because it is a bit unexpected.
  • 12 years ago
    I like the floral but in a bigger size.
    keysfins thanked Brown Dog
  • 12 years ago
    Since you added the other choices I like the multicolor with the bamboo and hibiscus flowers. I like it because it's 100% wool which wears well and will last a long time and if you ever get tired of the blues you can change your paint and other accent colors without replacing the rug.
    keysfins thanked pjlhome
  • 12 years ago
    The first one with bigger print. It makes a statement. And looks like Florida. Good job.
    keysfins thanked Nancy Travisinteriors
  • 12 years ago
    Pjlhome, if it matters, rugs #1 and #2 are also 100% wool. #3 is the only synthetic (polyester).
  • 12 years ago
    Ok, another wool version that I brought home, along with the second floral with the bamboo. I'll call these #5 and #6:
  • 12 years ago
    Sorry, these are just the rugs hanging, not in the space yet.
  • 12 years ago
    #6 is pretty high impact, I like the addition of the blue greens and it looks like it would compliment your floor. It's kind of Florida with a twist.
    keysfins thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    I like #6. Go Bold or go home!! :) #5 is nice too & very tropical.
    keysfins thanked pjlhome
  • 12 years ago
    I kind of like 6. It is high impact, but pretty!
    keysfins thanked Ann
  • 12 years ago
    Drumroll...... We chose #6! The lighting in the photo does not do it justice. Once the edge of the rug was under the front legs of the sofa, it transformed the rug and brought out the blues and greens.
    And who knew? I learned there is a light side and a dark side on this type of rug. It looks completely different if turned 180 degrees. Now we wait patiently until the larger size comes in to the shop.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I definitely recommend the first rug with both green and blue. Blue is my favorite color too, but too much if any color in a room isn't always a good thing. You can bring accents of green possibly swapping out the solid blue pillows with green pillows.
    keysfins thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    Keepsake Design, we chose a similar rug to #1, actually. We chose #6. I'll post a better photo of it. It has more colors to work with than even #1. The current pillows came with the sofas, and we will be replacing them.
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Our walls will be Wickham Gray. It is hard to believe that the image above is the same rug as #6 that I posted, but it is. I should have had the rug laid out for my previous photo.

    Touch the image to see a bigger, "full size" rug
  • 12 years ago
    Nice bold colors .. it will look good!
    keysfins thanked indianpatti
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks! It was very much worth the time to look at and try many different options.

    Kudos to Rugs As Art in Sarasota for encouraging us to take rugs home to try in our space. We brought two at a time, kept them for a few days, and had a chance to "live" with them in the space. I actually brought #6 home twice! (I still love #2, and maybe it will have a smaller role somewhere in the home.)

    Rugs As Art is an amazing and inspiring place. It IS an art gallery. Huge variety in so many styles and types, including gorgeous custom work. And the customer service is top notch.
  • 12 years ago
    Great choice!! That rug seems to be everything you were looking for.
    keysfins thanked User