I like the second choice

Cream!

The lighter color.

I prefer the white one myself....it sounds stupid but the red one is dark and it makes taking a shower a little darker! Now to achieve this in the dining room!

Lighter, especially with the mirror frame color.

Another vote for the second one;)

Thank you all for the input! I like the white too!

White

white!

cream

The light cream. It makes the room feel more open and fresh.

Thank you all the white one stays! Now on to the living/dining area!

I think the second one!

The white one--and to really jazz things up, make sure it's tucked inside the tub. It makes such a difference to put it inside the tub instead of having it hang outside. Looks more finished that way I think. Place the rod as high up as it can go without allowing water to spray out from under the curtain.

white, no contest!

second one!

Well...if you need a reason to keep both :o) the white one for Spring and Summer...the other for Autumn and Winter...