The one with wooden legs.

Metal legs for me...

and keep the table...

Thanks for your comments. Curious to know why you would choose either. Personal preference? Goes best with our design likes. One has more longevity? Thanks.

In the image with all he elements as is, that would be the one I picked, I like the play between the contemporary and traditional with the chandelier, mirror frame. I actually don't think the new table will work as well..

I agree with Sustainable. I like either of these better for your space:

I like the metal leg chair with the roomandboard table and the wooden leg chair with the westelm. I don't like either with the current table.

Hi! I think that you can go modern and clean with your chairs in a different way, because to me, the backs of those chairs are too short. Here are a few options for you:

http://deciture.com/shop/furniture/world-market/marine-addison-dining-chairs-set-of-2/

http://deciture.com/shop/furniture/world-market/stone-addison-dining-chairs-set-of-2/

http://deciture.com/shop/furniture/world-market/gunmetal-cargo-chairs-set-of-2/

Hope this helps!

A shot of reality, get two upholstered chairs on each end, then wood chairs in a simple design for the sides.

I love your table and chandelier! I'm not crazy about your chair choices, here are some that I think would look really nice. I also would recommend a larger buffet.

Thanks for all your thoughts. The table is much more traditional for us, which is why we are getting a new one. We are looking for a more modern, family-centered, inviting look. I can see how the chandelier may look better with more formal chairs but I think it also works with the more modern ones; just not sure whether to go with the wood legs or the metal ones. I'm going for something more like this: http://www.elledecor.com/celebrity-style/keri-russell-at-home-69262-4#slide-4

Thanks, again!

I think the tufted woodleg chairs that Arranged To Sell, LLC reccommended would look better with your table

I believe they are both too modern for the table and chandelier. Some good options above. It would be much more sophisticated. The chairs you have chosen are more kitchen chairs and do not speak dining room.

Neither. A[tufted chair [(https://www.houzz.com/products/gdf-studio-prince-upholstered-dining-chairs-set-of-2-prvw-vr~7619648)would go great with the space. :)