From the photo, it appears acceptable. Slate tile is the only tile I'll space @ 1/4" (extremely inconsistent ) I'm confidant that 1/8" would have worked. Yes, I believe that you are partly to blame. If the tile install looks good with the exception of the grout line width, and you want to change it, its my opinion that you will be responsible for the majority of the cost.

Its water under the bridge, but, the installer should have told you that he was going to space the tile @ 1/4" and a explanation of why. Even laying a few tiles out for you representing the spacing. At that point, you decide yes or no. If not acceptable, and you request a grout line less then 1/4", the installer can then explain why he or she feels that its not a wise choice, but will do as you wish.

Yea... something like that ;)

I don't think it is worth the expense and mess to redo, and I would seal the grout well. At least it is a small space, so if you really can't stand it, it won't cost a fortune.

Actually what bothers me more is the size of the tile. That is very large for an old building and I would be concerned about any cracking as the building settles and whatnot, plus it is a rather large scale for such a small space, even with leveler and such. Do you have an isolation mat underneath it to absorb some of the shock and prevent cracking?

I installed 4" glazed high skid resistant porcelain tile in a bathroom 6 years ago and have been very happy with it so far. I would have preferred traditional white unglazed porcelain mosaic tile, but it is a rental and it was twice as expensive or more, especially for the good-quality stuff.

Settling is typically a issue and concern in newer structures. I wouldn't be concerned. Larger tiles obviously equals less grout joints to maintain. I think the scale is fine and less maintenance is always a good thing ;)

Just maybe something helpful... but.. they make a caulk that has a grout texture and comes in the same colors as grout.. It's a band aid for your situation..

I think it looks fine as is. Very pretty tile.

Thank you, everyone!

I think it looks beautiful.

I think it looks really good. I just bought a new construction home that was a spec and they used non rectified porcelain planks throughout with wider grout line. Almost didn’t buy the home for that reason. Beautiful color & texture, but wider grout line due to not being rectified. Everyone comments on the beautiful flooring. I think you should leave it. It’s beautiful.

Dead thread for over 4 years!

So.....four years later, how do you like it?