Software
Houzz Logo Print
caligirl555

Door knobs for craftsman bungalow

9 years ago

Hi guys, hope you don't mind helping with an issue outside the kitchen.

With my kitchen-bath-overhalfmyhouse remodel, I'm replacing nearly all the doors (6) :( Even sadder is losing the original door knobs, so I want to put in a nice period-looking reproduction.

I ordered antique brass for the door hinges, which goes with the original brass hardware in the house, though that's only visible in the window hardware now. The kitchen lighting will be ORB and antique copper; cabinet hardware is TBD. Bathroom lighting and hardware is nickel, maybe an antique brass light fixture. I think I could go in a lot of different directions with the finish.

House of Antique Hardware has a nice door knob that looks like my original. I thought I wanted antique brass...but the finish seems dull not antique. For the cost, and for having to give up the originals, I want to love them.

I could go with Timeless Bronze. I like that it's a little distressed, but seems like the dark may be stark on the white doors.

I kind of like the idea of doing un-lacquered brass. It would be like what was originally there, but there won't be any other shiny brass in the house.

Rejuvenation has a version, I like the finish better but the crystal knob less (it's different than mine), and the cost would be $400 more across all the knobs I need to buy. I feel a little silly paying that to get a better faux finish!

What do you guys think? Do you hate or love any of them?

Also! One of my new closets will have bifold doors. What knobs would you put on there? Like a crystal cabinet knob maybe?

Thank you for reading. My bathroom was supposed to be done in 5 weeks--it's been 5 weeks, and there's not even insulation yet. I'm hanging on by a thread and not sure what I'd do without GW.

Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    What about getting the unlaquered brass and aging them to match? It would take a little elbow grease, but seems like it's the best option for the finish you're really looking for. You could order one to try it out and see how you like it. I'm considering this for my drawer pulls. But 31 would be a lot of work.

  • 9 years ago

    Why couldn't you save the original knobs?

  • 9 years ago

    I didn't think to pull them before demo :( though not in great condition and/or splattered with lead-based paint, so I'm trying not to feel too guilty.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I second townlakecakes' suggestion. I got push-button dimmer switches from House of Antique Hardware, and I wanted switch plates that looked like the one that was already in the house. None of the available options looked quite right, so I ended up buying their unlacquered brass plates and dunking them in brass ager to get the look I wanted. I now have no idea which one is original to the house.

    Another option might be a building salvage shop/antique store. I poked through lots of those too and bought milk glass knobs and plates for three doors that cleaned up nicely:

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Have you looked at Emtek? http://emtek.com/


  • 9 years ago

    The darkest is more in keeping with the era and, yes it will stand out against a white door. I am not sure that they used straight white paint that much (a lot of white paint in that era would have turned creamy yellow as it aged), I think their goal was to use more natural colors-greens and creams. You may prefer the bright brass color, if you do, I would just make sure that you don't have to polish it regularly to keep it that shiny color. I would pick the first or the second, the fourth looks very 70-ish antiqued to me.

  • 9 years ago

    I like the top knob too, and agree with the brass ager ideas. It is also worth a look around salvage shops - there are a couple near me that have matches to just about any knob and plate if you are willing to dig around. I also have an old Craftsman Bungalow and am following your projects with great interest!

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for all the responses! I'll see if anything turns up with salvage. If I buy new, I'm not entirely sure what I'll do, but no one seems to like the expensive Rejuvenation one, so that eliminates an option!

  • 9 years ago

    i second looking in thrift/antique stores and eBay. at least u get the original and not a remake. and u might save $$ in the long run.

  • 9 years ago

    I've fixed up a series of bungalow/craftsman homes and always look for salvage first. My area has all sorts of options, and several have piles of hardware and knobs just like yours. That said, I have a chandelier from Rejuvenation in that antique brass and it is a gorgeous finish. I don't think I'd pay their price for door hardware however, and their shipping costs just add to the misery.