Software
Houzz Logo Print
gigi7_gw

Range issue: Wolf or Cornufe?

15 years ago

Although I'm normally a lurker, in 2005 I was here a lot when we remodeled our kitchen. I ended up, buying sight unseen, my gorgeous Lacanche Sully in ivory. Well, fast-forward to 2010-2011, we are under contract with a sale (of course, never thinking I was moving when we remodeled) and I have to leave her here...bummer! The new house has a crummy cooktop, although it's gas, and only one wall oven. Not nearly enough for me! I plan on replacing the cooktop with a range and the space will take a 48" easily, but no more. Now, I have spoken with Art Culinaire and one of the new models with the drawer convection oven will work, but there is a 10-12 week lead time. A dealer here has Wolf (available in 1 week or so) and I found out that he can get a Cornufe, also. One happens to be available within a week from a supplier in CA, and it's the pretty red to boot! Considering price, the Cornufe is less than the Wolf, but I have no idea how well the Cornufe performs. Does anyone have any good info on quality here? I know that the Wolf has a good reputation and I can get service. Have had no trouble with my Lacanche either when I needed a little service call...there are only 2 Lacanches in my town but there is a service rep! Go figure that one! I would appreciate any input at all from you guys...thanks so very much!! We have to move March 10th!

Comments (23)

  • 15 years ago

    I went to a dealer with a working kitchen/cooking school using all of the available ranges (but not Cornufe). The advantage here is that not only do you get to try the ranges, but the professional cooking staff cooks on them with students on a regular basis so you can evaluate how they work after sustained use, rather than on a showroom floor. We tried the Wolf, the Blue Star, the Dacor, and the Capital Culinarian.

    Having been considering a Wolf, I'll tell you that it was the worst of the lot. Slow to a boil, uneven heat, cheap quality door that squeaked and stuck when you tried to open it. Very hot oven door when on. After comparing, the only good thing I could say about the Wolf was that it was attractive. The Capital Culinarian was hands-down the best serious cooking machine followed up by the Blue Star.

    Have no input on the Cornufe having never used one.

    Good luck!

  • 15 years ago

    I have no advice but I can't help but ask, did you not find your Sully to be that great? It just stands out at me that someone passionate enough about their kitchen to spend 5 digits on a range finds a mere 10-12 week wait for a new one too long.

  • 15 years ago

    I didn't say that I wasn't considering the new Lacnche model, and you are right about the time line. However, I am able to get both of the others much sooner and I was only asking for some input if someone had experience with especially the Cornufe. I live in a small-ish city and we do not have access to a wide range of the higher end appliances and service will be an issue. I already know how wonderful Lacanche is, but it IS the most expensive, by far, of all three of these. That also is a consideration. Even the sales guy for Wolf/LaCornue said that he has never sold a Cornufe and he has only sold the Wolf, with two exceptions, for looks in this town! I actually use my stove every single day and feed 20+ people every single Sunday, so I'm trying to get the most information that I can. If I could take mine with me, I would. Not possible. And thanks for the info on the Wolf!

  • 15 years ago

    About 2 years ago there was an elaborate kitchen in So Cal on the Kitchens Forum with a CornueFe -- there was a sort of Spanish mural behind the range if I recall. The kitchen was featured in either the Old House Journal, Old House News or This Old House -- can't remember precisely. It was a much fussed over and the owner posted frequently. She's had the range for long enough now to be a good source for use info.

    They're quite helpful over there. If you posted and asked if anyone remembers that kitchen I expect someone will. I'd also ask if anyone has used a CornueFe or just put one in.

    FWIW CornuFe has eclipsed Wolf where I live in the super expensive, high prestige apartments. You can scroll down for a glimpse of a gorgeous stainless 6 burner in the kitchen of a showhouse in an $8 mil apartment. Hard to compete with that.

  • 15 years ago

    I posted this somewhere last night and do not see it here. Rococo's reference is to a poster named "yesdear." Perhaps a search of that poster's threads will lead to more information. Use Ixquick or another search engine as the links have scrolled off of Gardenweb.

    Here is a link that might be useful: yesdear's kitchen

  • 15 years ago

    Boy just checked out the CornuFe on the Williams-Sonoma website and at $8,600 (without a required $1,300 white glove delivery) for a 43" range with three anemic 12k BTU burners, one 17.5K BTU burner and a dedicated simmer burner, it doesn't seem like much bang for your buck. I'm sure it's well made and it certainly makes a style-statement if you like that sort of thing.

    Seems there are better performance choices at this price point. Am I wrong?

  • 15 years ago

    I scanned the comments in the yesdear link. It appears he had some issues with the distributor and vendor and was unhappy with both. I did not look for other links, so I am not sure whether any follow-up about functionality of the range was ever offered. I understand the Fe is a rebadged AGA, but I'm unsure as to which AGA that refers. I can tell you from my personal examination of the range at Williams-Sonoma that it does not have that tank-like solid feel of the true La Cornue at all.

  • 15 years ago

    Ive seen and futzed around with two CornuFes at two different Williams Sonomas--one was black, the other that periwinkle blue (forget what their name for the color is, but it was beautiful). I opened and closed everything, moved the oven racks, picked up the grates, turned the knobs, did some "air cooking"... They both felt very solid to me, very well built. I fell in love! Then I had to be peeled off the floor when informed of the price.

    Last Christmas I also futzed around with a yellow La Cornue (not CornueFe) at another Williams-Sonoma... no idea why they had it there, but they did. Personally I prefer the looks of a CornuFe, and while I'm sure it must be "better made" (though nothing stood out to me as being clearly better than the CornuFe), I should certainly hope it is, given that it costs as much as a car. Since the OP is deciding which $7500-$12,000 range to buy, it doesn't make sense to compare either of them to a $20,000-$30,000 range.

  • 15 years ago

    FWIW, CornueFe is the range of choice here now in the super-upscale apartments. They look to be very substantial and they are very beautiful IMO. Seems like it's the same price range as a new Lacanche or a Wolf dual fuel.

    The La Cornues are a different world. I spoke to one of the top KDs about them and asked specifically why he uses them in so many kitchens. He said that they are amazing to cook on. They are completely custom and have 1 gas and 1 electric domed oven, which I believe lock down to preserve temperature. The tops have various configurations. The company gave him a training session and he says they do things no other range really does. They are made by hand in a relatively limited number. He owns a Wolf. Aga Rangemaster owns La Cornue.

    They are hanging around W-S because they sell them. The one near me has a huge LaC installation that's got several people cooking at once on weekends.

  • 15 years ago

    gigi7 - If I recall, in some of the LaCanche threads people have discussed the LaCornues sold at WS as being flimsier? I'm not totally familiar with the Cornu vs CornuFe, but that was my recollection - one is better than the other. Anyhow, you may want to search some of those threads as I know it has come up. As someone who is planning on buying a Lacanche for my new build, I'd love to hear more about what you get and how it compares to your beloved LaCanche!

  • 15 years ago

    gigi7, If you're interested in a top-performing range of superb quality, go try out the new 48" Capital Culinarian.
    The quality and craftsmanship are impossible to miss. Very powerful and dynamic open burners. Built-in Rotisserie oven.

    I did just that last month and it made the Wolf they also had in the demo-kitchen look like a toy.

    Happy hunting!

  • 15 years ago

    Wow, thanks SO MUCH for your replies!!!! I have been so busy the last few days with inspector this and inspector that...driving me crazy! My main concern, actually, IS the "heft" of a CornuFe, for instance in the doors and grates, etc. I can actually see a Wolf here and since I already have the Sully, I know the Lacanche. I am 6 hours away from Williams-Sonoma (nearest is Dallas area or Denver). No Capital Culinarian even close. I don't even know where I'd find one! I live in the Texas Panhandle and this is an area that loves pretty basic appliances, although 3 places here do carry some higher-end brands. Berta is here, too, but I didn't think the doors were as heavy as the Wolf or as my Lacanche, I could be wrong. I have also read mixed reviews; what to do, what to do. The Culinarian sounds intriguing, though, I must admit, having read several good reviews here. LaCornue is gorgeous, but waaaay beyond the budget! I just feel that there are several good ranges out there, I need to find the right fit in a 48" maximum, and considering what you get for the price. Thanks again!!!

  • 15 years ago

    I haven't played with a Capital, but the CornuFe's doors closed with a satisfying clunk. Maybe clunk is not the right word, but it's whatever word means "a sound that tells you the thing is solidly made."

    Here's a weird idea--I wonder if you can find videos on YouTube of people showing off their CornuFes?

  • 15 years ago

    If you're interested, here's the Capital distributor information for Texas:

    CHRIS RANDLE

    PARAGON DISTRIBUTING COMPANY
    13921 Senlac Dr. Suite 100
    Farmers Branch, TX 75234
    Phone: (800) 683-4745
    Fax: (972) 241-8912
    email: info@paragondistributing.com
    www.paragondistributing.com

    You can also go to the retail site www.eurostoves.com as they are uniquely licensed to sell Capital anywhere in the Country. They have a pretty slick deal where you can fly in to Massachusetts, they pick you up at the airport, take you back and you can actually cook on the Culinarian (and competing makes) all day. If you wind up buying from them they'll reimburse you your airfare.

    I have no affiliation with Capital or Eurostoves, but I went to Eurostoves to try out the Culinarian and was impressed by the experience. Several other posters on this forum have done the same and have had their airfare reimbursed.

    Good luck!

  • 15 years ago

    And for something different, check out Green Demolitions for a 2004 La Cornue, toward the middle of the page.
    They ship. I've picked up a few things there; someone on the kitchen forum had a whole kitchen shipped.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Green Demolitions

  • 15 years ago

    Omigod omigod omigod omigod omigod omigod. I'm goggle-eyed at the Green Demolitions site and their $41,000 La Cornue Chateau 120 selling for $14,000 OMIGOD. That's quite a find, ChestersHouse!

  • 15 years ago

    The reason I mentioned the regular La Cornue and its different "feel" is that I've never played with a Lacanche in person, but if the OP has seen the La Cornue IRL and is looking for that "closing a bank vault" experience, this will be absent from the Cornue Fe. Now, I cannot say how the Lacanche feels in comparison, but some folks here probably can.
    Okay, last attempt. Here's a link that gives the owners' name and the KD information for yesdear's kitchen.

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0214024120464.html?15

    You'll need to scroll all the way down.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Perhaps they'll tell you their experience

  • 15 years ago

    I'm close enough to have checked out a couple of the GD stores. We've picked up random things for renovations -- an exterior door, a toilet and sink, and windows. That range turned up on an email they sent yesterday or today. Sometimes with high-end items, including kitchens, they do this auction format. Staff I've talked with have been friendly and helpful,so I'm sure they'd answer questions.

  • 15 years ago

    Gigi7 - what did you end up doing??

  • 15 years ago

    Oops...sorry, I didn't see this until now! We have been so busy trying to finalize all the little details on this house sale. Let me tell you, it has been tedious at best. I didn't want to even think of ordering anything and be committed until and unless I was positively positive that this deal was going to work out, and now I guess it will. So, answer is nothing yet, but I called 3 Williams-Sonoma stores in the DFW area and two of them have a CornuFe. Spoke with two very knowledgeable people there and got some good feedback, mostly addressing my concerns on the heft of the oven doors and one of them especially spoke of how well the doors sealed....a big deal to me. I still think I would like to have an oven size as large as the Wolf large one, but am leaning to the red CornuFe. I am concerned with the length of preheat on CornuFe and need to find out a little more on that. Hope to make a decision this week. Gosh, this is nuts. This house sale is a trade thing....they came to us and the house was on our top three list of favorites. However, I wanted to be darn sure that their funding was in place before I did a thing...I will NOT pay two house payments! So, although I know that anything can happen at closing, it seems that all is a go. I'll let you know what happens! And, try to get my photo skills up to par! I think there is a link to the house on one website, but don't know if it will help you at all to see the kitchen. I may run down there to see one in person at WS....one of my boys lives in FW, so it would be easy to do, but packing right now is overtaking my days! With the supplier happening to have a red CornuFe ready to ship right now, I was worried that I might miss a chance to get it sooner rather than later.

  • 15 years ago

    I will not recommend Wolf. We have one and it has all the problems mentioned in the following blog.

    http://blogs.consumerreports.org/safety/2008/09/wolfrange-recal.html

  • 15 years ago

    Dear Peng,

    I'm sorry to hear that you are having difficulties with your Wolf range. We would be happy to assist you. The mentioned recall was initiated so that existing customer ranges could be repaired properly. You can contact us directly via phone Mon-Fri. 8:00-5:00 CST at 800-222-7820. We can be reached via email at CustomerService@SubZero.com.

    Thanks!

    Customer Care Team
    Sub-Zero/Wolf Appliances