We hired Rick in the spring of 2018 to provide a landscape design for our home. Before receiving final payment, Rick was quite responsive, albeit a few weeks late on the deliverables, such as the preliminary drawings and final plan. Rick also has a good knowledge of plants and trees and he has a good design sense. He was good about scheduling meetings to discuss the design and he elicited a lot of feedback from us. And before receiving final payment, Rick was very personable.
Unfortunately, two issues spoiled our experience. The first was that Rick ignored the budget we had in mind. Early on, he asked about our budget and was told that it was in the neighborhood of $10,000 to $20,000. I realize that's a broad range, but as I explained to Rick, we've never done landscaping and had no real idea how much it would cost.
After the design was delivered and we obtained bids from landscapers, we discovered that the design Rick had delivered was a $50,000+ design, which was a good $30,000 more than what we could spend. (We got three bids, including a bid from the landscaper that Rick had enthusiastically recommended, which was the highest bid of the bunch.) As a result, we scaled back the project significantly and discarded much of what Rick included in the plan. That was frustrating. Either Rick didn't have an understanding of what his design would actually cost to implement or he didn't pay attention to what we told him concerning our budget.
Our other principal complaint is that Rick, once fully paid, was rude and stopped responding to calls, emails, or texts. That was surprising and disappointing, given that we had a pleasant relationship up to that point.
Rick had gone on at length about how he only used certain landscapers on his projects. I knew that landscapers are extremely busy in the summer, so weeks before Rick delivered the final plans, I asked him if we could get on one of his recommended landscaper's schedules. Rick had recommended a particular landscaper, who I'll refer to as "Landscaper S." Rick told me that he had been discussing our job with the landscaper and that he had reserved a spot for us on Landscaper S's schedule in June.
As soon as Rick delivered the final plan to us, which Rick himself sent to Landscaper S, I tried to schedule a meeting with Landscaper S in order to obtain an estimate. Unfortunately, he wasn't responding to me. I therefore emailed Rick on May 23, advised him of the issue, and asked if I could have the name of one the other landscapers that he had talked so much about. Rick, who was now fully paid at this point, didn't respond. I sent Rick a follow-up email on May 29, which said:
"Just following up on my [May 23] email. We understood that you had other landscapers that you recommend. If so, can you please send me their names? Last Wednesday, I sent [Landscaper S] an email with proposed dates to meet this week but he hasn’t responded. It doesn’t appear that he wants/needs the job so I’d like to speak to someone else. I don’t feel comfortable using someone I have to chase in order to give them my business."
This prompted Rick to call Landscaper S, who apparently gave Rick a different story. Rick then sent the following email, which was the last time I ever heard from him. (The ALL CAPS are Rick's.)
"Landscaper S has attempted NUMEROUS times to contact you...he sent you a series of times that you and he can connect. Landscaper S said you have NOT responded. He just re-sent that, please respond. Landscaper S, I and my other contractors are extremely busy...you must be patient if you want a QUALITY job done...other wise you are on your own."
For the record, what Landscaper S apparently told Rick was simply untrue, so the shouting and lecture in Rick's email was a bit surprising and offensive. And if Rick had stopped to think, he would have seen that it also made no sense. If Landscaper S had been so responsive, as Rick claimed, then why in the world would I have contacted Rick repeatedly asking him to provide the name of another, more responsive landscaper? And why wouldn't Rick simply provide the information, which he never did. Simply bizarre . . . .
Notwithstanding Rick's email, I did eventually meet with Landscaper S and learned that--contrary to what Rick had promised--Landscaper S had not reserved a place on the schedule for June and couldn't start work until September. And as noted above, Landscaper S's estimate, which he delivered a week late, was the highest of the three we obtained. Thankfully we are just finishing up the job with another landscaper, who has been absolutely fantastic to work with.
I am confident that Rick will post a lengthy response to this review, citing the positive reviews he has received. (While working with him, he bragged several times about how he "BURIES any negative reviews!!!") I certainly wish that we had the sort of positive experience that others claim to have had. Unfortunately, we didn't.
In summary, while we have been able to use some of the design that Rick provided and we like most of the plants he selected, most of the plan he provided was simply out of budget and therefore unusable. We were also disappointed in his professionalism, responsiveness, and behavior at the end of the relationship. In good conscience, we cannot recommend him.
17 Comments