Software
Houzz Logo Print
loliz

AWFUL floor staining job!

12 years ago
Hi Houzzers! Help me please! I just had my red oak floors stained with Minwax Espresso. I LOVE LOVE LOVE the color but my floor guy did a royally bad job, IMO! The perimeter of the floors was lighter than the central part. I called my contractor to complain and he sent the guy back out today to try to "repair" it and the end result looks worse than before! Now there are these wavy lines at the perimeter and there is no blend at all. Now what to do? Is this a common mistake for someone who "does floors for a living" to make? Do I have to resand and restain the entire thing over again? Now I don't even know if I should trust this guy to do it since he botched it so badly the first time! Any floor guys that can tell me what to do?

Comments (12)

  • 12 years ago
    I did see it after it was sanded and I thought it looked pretty good. But I don't really know what I'm supposed to be looking for. It seemed pretty even to me though. I didn't see it after he put the stain down and before the polyurethane.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I agree. This looks like it wasnt done by a pro. They need to make it right. That will mean sanding and refinishing.
    loliz thanked Oak & Broad
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Agree with Oak & Broad. This is an unacceptable job and the only way to fix it is going to be to sand it down to bare wood and start again. I know it's tough to monitor this process because you can't be in the house for much of it, but you should find a way to approve the stain before the clear coat goes on.
    loliz thanked McAdams Remodeling & Design
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I'm concerned about two things with this floor. How much wood is left in the planks (thickness)? Will the next finish be applied by a more qualified person?
    loliz thanked Oak & Broad
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I have never seen this before. For the flooring guys in the conversation, is this caused by using a sander in the middle and hand sanding the perimeter?
    loliz thanked Brickwood Builders, Inc.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Not enough of the original finish was removed from the perimeter, leaving the wood unable to absorb the stain. Resand completely and start over. With someone else.
    loliz thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    If you start over with someone else then don't pay the first guy for something you'll have to pay for again when you have it redone.
    loliz thanked leelee
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks everyone for all the input! I am definitely talking to the contractor about getting a new guy to do it. I am concerned about how much thickness is left. Is there a way to determine this?
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    A flooring professional has ways of determining how much wood is left. They will look into areas that offer a cross section (like a heat vent with the hole it creates or underneath a transition strip...you can see the thickness of the floor in these areas). Each time they sand and stain, they remove a few millimeters of wood each time. This is normal. A regular 3/4" hardwood has almost 100 years of "life" in it. Once the tongue and groove are exposed the game is over and you need a new floor.

    The age of the house will help offer a "guestimate" for how much life you have in your floors. If your home is 50 years old...you are about half way through the life of the floors. If the house is 80 years old, you only have a few more kicks at the can to get this right.

    The problem comes in when you are dealing with engineered hardwood. Their wear layer generally 3-5mm = 2-3 refinishing efforts before you are compelled to buy new flooring.
    loliz thanked Cancork Floor Inc.
  • 12 years ago
    Wow. That is so helpful Cancork! The house was built in 1962 so I guess that means there probably is some room to go. But I will have the contractor check the cross sectional area to determine the thickness before sanding again. I know that it is solid oak and not engineered hardwood though.
  • 12 years ago
    had the same problem with our floors refinished. We had a professional flooring company sand our floors down and apply a dark stain with poly seal. Came home to find their sander malfunctioned (or something) and we could see swirl marks on the floor very clearly. Re-sanded and stained by the same outfit (around 1000 sf). Turned out beautifully! Years later had additional floors in the house refinished - called same company. Wouldn't ya know it? They screwed it up the first time and ONCE AGAIN had to re-sand and refinish. Turned out great! No longer believing their equipment malfunctioned the very first time we had them out --- I think they hire inexperienced people and WHEN and IF they get called out on it, they simply re-do the job. ugh. and, before you ask --- NO I would NOT use them again! lol Too much hassle!

    Best of luck to you getting it worked out. Definitely do NOT accept the job they did for you.