Contractor issues
12 years ago
Hello I am talking to a contractor to redo my kitchen,he gave me a price for the whole job.From ripping to painting but he won't detail it as to what will cost me what,it's my first time working with a contractor,if anybody have any experience with that can you please tell me if that's how it works thank you.
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (44)
- 12 years agoIf he won't give you any details then I think he doesn't want to put the time into it.
I would look for another contractor to just do the contracting bit of the project.
Then get quotes from kitchen people to design the kitchen for you. Get quotes from flooring companies for the flooring etc. That way you will be in full control of the project and know what you are getting exactly and how much it will cost. - 12 years agoWhy trust a contractor who won't tell you how and why he came up with that price? Is that the kind of contractor who will even honor that price in the end? I agree with Angel - get quotes from reputable companies to give you an idea of what you should expect. Look for these companies on Angies list, check their license numbers (contractor and business) to make sure they are valid up to date, as well as their insurance info. Read some info on the different functions of a kitchen (plumbing, electric, ventilation, etc) from books - Holmes is good resource, or on Internet so you are armed with the proper info and questions to ask when hiring so as not to get taken advantage of. Good luck!
Related Professionals
Evansville Interior Designers & Decorators · Middletown Interior Designers & Decorators · Lincoln Interior Designers & Decorators · Monroe Interior Designers & Decorators · Tucson Interior Designers & Decorators · Spokane Interior Designers & Decorators · Great Bend Architects & Building Designers · Covington Architects & Building Designers · Auburn Architects & Building Designers · New Bedford Architects & Building Designers · Alpena Architects & Building Designers · Glenwood Springs Architects & Building Designers · York Architects & Building Designers · Huron Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Cody Kitchen & Bathroom Designers- 12 years agoI agree, speaking as a contractor- there's no reason why he shouldn't give you a breakdown. He should be doing it to come up with a price for his own purposes anyway. It's possible he doesn't want you to see his markups. It's also possible he is really good at estimating and doesn't need to break it down, but if you ask, he should certainly be willing to for you. Look elsewhere. If he won't take that extra step now, he's not likely to if/when you run into any surprises along the way. Good luck.
- 12 years agoInsist on breakdown & contract. If he doesn't put anything in writing, I'd find someone else. Get at least two other bids from other contractors, too.
DH thought he could trust someone, got taken advantage of in the sneakiest of ways, and ended up in a lawsuit. - 12 years agoIn almost 30 years I never detailed the price breakdown and was never asked to do that except for a few prospects and I politely explained to them that I cannot detail prices, they insisted and I declined to do the job.
When doing an estimate you specify everything what you will do, i.e. the scope of work, materials to be included, specified in detail what they will be (model, name, etc) time to complete the work, warranty and labor for the total price.
If you think about it, its very hard to detail the break down and the cost, because you have to much involved in an average size project, like time to complete the project, other trades, procurement fees, omissions percentage, mark-up for overhead, profit, etc.
If the pricing detail is broken up, it will only create confusion, the customer will start searching internet if he can get this cheaper, or the customer will stark counting your money, how much you make on the job (been told a few times you making to much :-)).
IMO when people ask for the price break down, I usually steer clear from this type of customers, and don't want anyone to take this personally, but when a customer asks to line item cost, it because they extremely cheap and will try to beat you up on every item, or they're insecure and think that they being overcharges, which is a Red Flag for many contractors. Some will ask that just so they can see how much you making on the job, and even if you will break it down for them, they will only get confused why this cost this much or that much when they can get it cheaper.
Example: If I am doing a job 1 hr away from my house, as a GC I have to be on the job every day, that 2 hour drive not to mention running around getting supplies, etc. I know to complete that job will take 2 months... I have to add into my estimate at least $100 a week for gas, that would be $800 added to the estimate, not to mention other expenses for which a certain % is added to each job cost, i.e, overhead, etc, many who work for a paycheck don't understand that and why they have to pay that, but we have to do this to stay in business.
So if you specify travel expense- $800 they say "wow he is charging us $800 just for travel?" So you break it up the overhead cost between the items you include... and you specify a vanity cost $250 dollars, and they go online or check the Box store and the same vanity is $225, it becomes an issue, and if you have 10 items it becomes a huge headache. Been there a few times when I was starting out in this business, and stopped doing that after a few times it happened and I didn't get a job in the end after breaking everything up.
I already took the time, leg work and expense to provide a written estimate, now I have to sit down and re-write everything and only to create confusion or deal with the above said issues? Why, when all they have to do is compare my estimate apples to apples with other bidders and make a decision.
This has nothing to do with Contractor dishonesty, or being afraid to show it, or anything else... I don't do itemized break down, because I want to get the jobs and stay in business without wasting my time on nonsense. My experience and reputation speaks for itself and reputation only comes from a customer recommendation from a well done job I did for them, and I guess this one of the reasons why nobody is asking me to do that.
Last night I went out with another couple to a Steak House for dinner, the bill was in the neighborhood of $500 and change... What I'm gonna ask them for a detailed break down to determine why my steak was this much, or why my bottle of wine was that much? Its a ridiculous request and if you break it up it will do nobody any good because there is allot more goes into it.
So there is nothing wrong about this guy not wanting to break everything up... your main concern should be that he is qualified to do your job, has experience and good recommendations.
Good luck - 12 years agoDoes it matter? You are getting a price for a complete job, not a bunch of smaller jobs, so the price of each component of the job should not matter.
When you receive additional bids, you will compare total cost, and not line item pricing. - 12 years agoAnd, yes, ppf, it does matter. If the line item for flooring is based on the very cheapest available, then when it comes time to choose and the consumer doesn't like the cheap flooring then there will be a change order. Then consumer will either have to pay the difference and have cheap flooring or cut back somewhere else. If the competitive bid has the flooring at a higher price that is more what the consumer wants then having line items in the bids is the only way consumer can see exactly what they are getting. Most GCs have this all on spread sheets and it is only a matter of filling in the blanks to create a line item bid. And not to denigrate GCs, you have to have a lot of smarts to fill in those blanks.
- 12 years agoIt's just a single room. I assume he has shown you what cabinets, what hardware, what countertops, what flooring, etc. will be used. As others have said, if you compare total package to total package, you will be looking at the bottom line. So the line-by-line detail may be irrelevant.
If he is giving you a total, then, say, TBD or some kind of allowance for cabinets, flooring, fixtures, or whatever, then this is not good. Because he may be pricing it with cheapest available and you will end up going over on all the allowances. So in this case the only way you can know is with a detailed estimate. Then you have to figure out if that covers the quality of materials you expect.
I say spec it out right down to the hardware and then you can compare apples to apples, and it wont matter if the estimate is just one number or a whole bunch of line items.
Good luck and let us know how it turns out! - 12 years agoMF, you have a point there about being Old fashoned, even my kids tell me that I'm Old School and don't understand the way things work now... lol Maybe so, but I like to keep it that way because it never did me wrong, I have my principles by which I live and conduct my business..., I make a good living TG and like an old saying goes "you cannot stop an old dog from barking"
With that said, I never asked anybody why they charge me this or that, or what theirs profit is... I count what I have in my pocket and if I like the price I buy, if I don't I walk and look elsewhere. Sometimes I don't like the price but I like the person, and I will pay his price just because of that.
About my customers, I don't think my customers unintelligent, in almost 30 years in business and this is not the only business I owned, I did jobs for a regular blue color workers like myself (by the way, they're one of my best customers) I also built many homes, not to mention the remodeling jobs I did, for doctors, lawyers, judges, business owners like myself, CEO's of some major co. and none ever asked me for a cost break down, so I don't know what to tell you, other then this is how I always done business.
I guess we have different experiences, and if your contractor who works for you broke everything up, I guess that works for him and it is fine with you, and it's definitely fine with me... but that is 1 out of 100 who will do that.
Good luck - 12 years agolast modified: 12 years agoAngel, your suggestion is for them to act as their own GC, if they going to design cabinets with a kitchen designer, that same company can include installation (most do) some hire anyone with insurance, some do it in house. When I was starting out, I did all high end kitchen installs for major kitchen distributors, and all the basic kitchens they would have theirs own guys on the payroll handle.
Same goes for flooring, select the flooring and have them install and everything else goes the same, get your own painter, plumber, electrician, this one and that one.
That is the only way they can be in control of the job and the job cost, and the only thing is required from them is dedicate theirs time, schedule everyone to keep the job moving, work out all problems and issues if any arise, get the supplies needed when requested, etc...
Doing that they don't need that contractor, because there is nothing there for him to do, and if you have something for him to do, tell him to give you price for labor only and call it a day. - 12 years agoThe OP only asked about getting a price for the job and not pricing for the individual parts of the job.
Nothing was said about not understanding what services, materials, finishes etc were included.
Like many others, my proposal includes details about these things, but not pricing.
If the OP is not getting that level of detail, then he has cause for concern. - 12 years agolast modified: 12 years agoI also like to add that In the last 5 or so years there is a big change in the type of clients we're faced with.
The "new wave of clients" we deal with, they all seems to have very successful businesses or good jobs, but for some reason they call legitimate contractors (licensed and insured) to obtain writen estimates for various home improvements and use our estimates as a bargain tool with another bidder or unlicensed trades)
Quiet often a customer would show me a proposal whether its a legitimate proposal or something scribbled on the toilet paper asking me if I can beat this estimate I get the job... and before they get to finish a sentence, I am out the door.
My price is my price, and I will only do the job if agreed on that price. If I could do it $1000 cheaper my price would be a $1,000 cheaper to begin with.
That is another reason why I will not break the cost down and show my profit margin, to give someone else to beat my price by a few dollars after I invested so much time writing a detailed proposal without any surprises down the road. I can easily cut anybody price and get my foot in the door and try to make it up down the line, but you can call me again Old Fashion, because that would be against my principles and I don't break them for nobody. - 12 years agoSo far we haven't gotten any quotes broken down in that way for the work we've had done. The only time I ask for a line by line is when I'm trying to see if an add-on item, like expanding closets, is something I'm willing to pay for when the main project is getting my kitchen remodeled.
I think much more important than the line by line is who are the subs they are using. We found out a very pricey GC uses cheap subs - luckily not the hard way... - 12 years agoWe are currently building a house and part of contracting with our GC is that he pays his subcontractors and then passes on full bills or partial deposits to us with his added profit %. This is a percentage mutually agreed upon. I suppose this is a cost+ structure. It works perfectly for us. We see the bills from the subcontractors so we know exactly what everything costs and we don't begrudge the GC his percentage for all the time and work involved.
- 12 years agoGN Builders, I hear you loud and clear. My ex son-in-law and daughter did the exact thing you are describing and thought they were so smart and manipulative. I found it to be against my principles and absolutely not the way my husband and I did business in building two custom homes and a whole house remodel. I guess I'm old fashioned also....
- 12 years agolast modified: 12 years agoThat's how it usually works - you get a price quoted for a job. I would have the GC write everything down that he is doing. Even to the smallest detail. And start making a list now and don't let him treat it as unimportant. Know the quality and quantity of things you are getting. Everything needs to be documented. I've lived through a few builds and had issues with them all. Also, I would get several references and not necessarily go with the cheapest GC. Look at some remodels he's done. Ask the homeowners questions. Also, try going with a contractor that has his own EXPERIENCED crew and and ask if he drug screens the employees. I think this may be one area where that is lacking. Remember you are the employer here!!!!
- 12 years agoI agree with you Grobby, it is very important to hire a reputable company with good reputation. Things are not like they use to be, you meed a customer, shake his hand and do the work... It seems in the old days it was a much better understanding between people without making things complicated.
Today my written proposals are 2 pages and contracts are 3-5 pages long, depends on the job size, not to mention all the legal stuff you have to put in there which required by law, but it is what it is, so be it if this what you have to do to conduct business today.
People are losing trust and I cant blame them with everything that is going on, the media, the reality shows, etc about bad contractor, about the rip-offs, botched up jobs, etc.
Most contractors see this in reality every day, we have our own statistics and I communicate with contracts all over the country, and Canada, UK, and most of us deal with the same issues.
I have been called to fix many botched up jobs or jobs that were left unfinished, and "contractors" came with recommendations (not sure who recommended them, but they did) some not only walked away with the money, they even took materials customers purchased.
A few weeks ago I was talking to someone, and they told me when doing a basement remodeling, the so "contractor" they hired, was getting different trades on Craig's list and send them to the house... you be amazed how much of that going on.
I know a few who hire laborers on the street and bring them to peoples homes to do the work.
Getting someone good today to do the work is very hard, its a task on its own not only for a homeowner but for contractors as well.
When I was starting out as a GC, it took me years to find contractors to work with and when I did, the prices what they charge wasn't a concern (of course within a reason), the only concern there was is to get the job done and see a smile on your customers face. Thank god most of the guys I work with, with most I go back almost 30 years, some 20 and I still up to this day after completing every job no matter how big or small, I ask the homeowner for a feedback about the service and about people who worked on the project, and I'm proud to say not one negative feedback, except one about 20 years ago when I changed a plumber because he retired, I hired a new company, and the feed back I got was, "Greg, everyone was great, but your plumber sucks" the exact words and that was the last job he did for me.
With that said, the only real Contractors out there is guys who take theirs trade seriously and who do work with pride and integrity and look out for theirs customers best interests.
You get someone like this, all you need is a handshake and they will take care of you.
Good luck
P.S Sorry about me venting here, but I'm stuck at home with poison ivy and I'm bored out of my mind. ieme
Original Author12 years agoWow so much to learn here thank you to everyone for your input.i understand that he has to make his money doing the job,believe me I am not stingy I run a small business,and sometimes a Custumer screams at me and says why you are charging me so much and I will take my time and explain why.I want to know because I like certain things like my sink,my faucet,my backsplash,he offers granite I want quartz so like someone said I might have to cover the difference,so how would I know.Let say he plans to buy a 40$ faucet for my sink the kind I want is nowhere near that and I don't think he is going to over budget himself by taking care of it. I tried explaining it that to him but says that he did that before and the people he was working for starting asking for credit for the things they brought in,and got into big disagreement.I will try talking to him and be more clear this time and see if he will get it.
Thank you again for taking your time to help- 12 years agoBoth parties need to be clear on the level of product and the quality of work expected. This is a continual discussion on Houzz on getting what you pay for. There is a reason a mercedes cost more than a ford. You will almost always in the construction business get what you pay for. Most of the short cuts in construction on the lower priced bids are taken in the prep work and unseen work so it comes to haunt you later.
- 12 years agoSomething went wrong somewhere, ieme, with communication.
"I want a new kitchen, how much will it cost..."
"I can give you a nice kitchen for $50,000."
Of course this doesn't work!
"I want a new kitchen with quartz countertops, kraftmaid xyz cabinets. How much will it cost?"
Now you might be getting somewhere.
My sister is doing her kitchen. She asked for quartz countertops and a bunch of other stuff. When she got the estimate, the quartz countertops were itemized. They were expensive, so she opted for granite instead, to keep the project within budget.
The fact that you don't even have a clue what kind of faucet is going in is a big red flag. Can you start the process over? Itemize what you really want, and get a new estimate?
Best of luck! - 12 years agoIt is amazing the conversation always is about the cost of cosmetic items never about the quality of workmanship and low end products that go before the cosmetic items. Does any ever question the different in electrical or plumbing components that are not seen. Is the painter going to prime, sand, and finish his work correctly? I promise you the items I mention are much more important than whether a faucet cost 30.00 or 3000.00.
- 12 years agoMy GC wanted to use the following approach, so we did.
* He gave me a price that covered all his labor and overhead, plus all construction/non-finish/non-visible materials - lumber, wiring, plumbing, adhesives, nails, plywood, drywall, mortar, screws, new header beam, Simpson-type hardware, backer board, etc. These are materials where there is little to no need for consumer choice. The GC is motivated to choose good quality nails, lumber etc. because otherwise it's a pain for him to build with.
* He told me to go shopping for my own finish materials, including cabinets, counters, flooring, hardware, switchplates, lighting, faucets, appliances, sinks, tile, grout, roofing, paint. Where necessary, he helped me select, scope, or size them. These visible materials are largely about taste and preference...most have colors, finishes, and styles to select, and all have quality grades, e.g. from $1.49 basic cabinet knob to $110 hand-carved inlaid abalone mosaic swan-shaped pull.
* For roof insulation, the material was priced separately - I believe I had R30 and R38 options
This procedure gave me complete control of the cost and selection of "choice" materials, as well as complete transparency on his total bill. It was confusing at first, because the GC did NOT clearly lay this out and I had spoken to so many others that would give a complete bid which included "allowances". I couldn't understand why I had to do the extra work of budgeting for and selecting all materials myself. But the allowances don't bear much relationship to the actual materials you will select, so the "complete" bid with allowances is actually misleading and sets everyone up for misunderstandings....UNLESS you're happy for your builder to just go and choose all your flooring, cabinets, tile, carpet, hardware etc. himself. As one builder told me, "I can definitely give you a firm price for 100% of your kitchen and keep it under $50,000....it's just that you won't like the job when it's done (because it will all be builder-grade, generic, unspecial and unpretty choices)."
Bottom line, this method was more work for me but gave much greater visibility and control. I would recommend it. (Those decisions have to get made one way or another so you may as well explicitly take them into your hands.) - 12 years ago@ MS Colors -- I agree. Knowing what is being used and how it will be done, upfront, is so much better because I've found that one needs to keep an eye on those doing the work as some seemingly petty details can be "omitted" as the job gets done. Usually it's a matter of missed communication between supervisor and workers. Quality upfront helps guarantee less problems later for both the GC and customer.
- 12 years agoMany people have had the experience of learning, late in a project, that item after item that they expected (reasonably) to be included, was "not in the scope" of the job. The rule is, if you don't have it in writing, you are probably not going to get it.
Even if you do your best to specify details, there will be some things you leave out. Be very careful if you are asked to sign a contract quickly, because it can mean that you are being finessed. The fact is, that some people make a great deal of profit from the change orders that result from vague contracts.
As others have pointed out, unless you have detailed bids, it is impossible to compare them. As one poster pointed out, even reputable companies might employ inexperienced subs. My own experiences include: a large plumbing contractor assigning a person to my job who ended up leaving uncapped hot water heating pipes, resulting in a superheated geyser which destroyed my dining room floor, and who also forgot to connect the drain from the new kitchen to the main drain, resulting in everything from the kitchen dumping onto my basement floor. Items that were expected but not provided have included things like a couple of stairs up into a new entry hall, and topsoil around a new building (grass seed was thrown directly onto rocks and clay). All reputable firms, who were recommended, and who were not the low bidders.
I have seen many posts from unhappy customers of custom builders, who find out late in the game that the actual kitchen cabinets that are going to be installed are cheap, unattractive builder grade boxes that have been bought in bulk for an entire subdivision. The builders apparently don't like to point this out until standard contracts have been signed and money has been paid. Imagine going to the trouble and expense of building a new house and having to accept junk cabinetry, which you then have to look at every day. In my opinion, some contractors fail to understand the importance of the job's components to the consumer. - 12 years agolast modified: 12 years agoWhen you develop a list of specifications *on the front end* that you ask contractors to bid, YOU are then in the drivers seat. You tell them that you want XYZ brand of cabinetry, PDQ faucet, etc. and if you haven't decided on a sink yet, that you will pick one under 1K. It does little good to go around to different car dealerships car shopping when the only thing you are telling the salesperson is that you want ''a red one''. You might get prices that ranged from a used Chevy Impala to a new Porsche 911 Turbo .
If you don't do more homework before you start your bid process, then you have a mass of unequal quotes that are impossible to sort through. Which is where you are at.
How do you develop your specifications? You do a huge amount of homework. As in a year or more of learning the differences between products and construction materials.
Or, you hire someone who has done hundreds of renovations and is already well educated in those issues: a designer. Hiring a designer actually ends up saving you money and time on your project. And saving you the hand wringing over whether or not the contractor you're trying to get a quote from actually ''gets'' your project. scope. - 12 years ago@ GN -- I think part of the problem is due to the internet mindset of bargain hunting. Hopefully, the tide will turn as enough people get burned.
My 26 yr. old can't understand why I prefer to "see" what I'm buying.
My nephew bought a TV off the internet from a manufacturer, and twice it arrived with a broken screen. Seems to me it would have been simpler to just go to a store. - 12 years agoActing as your own general contractor is fine - if you have the time, money, and skill necessary to do so. Do you personally have the time to look at, compare, price, select, order, and pick up every item for this project? Can you alter a cabinet for a space that was improperly measured? Do you know how to move an electric outlet because the appliance cord doesn't reach? Can you afford to pay subcontractors to sit and do nothing because one trade/sub ran into issues and your project is now off schedule?
If you are hiring a contractor, do your homework! Read reviews, talk to past clients, look at completed projects. Select a reputable one that will provide you with a comprehensive plan and timeline for the project. I have never found it necessary to get a ridiculously detailed breakdown of a bid, but absolutely get a general breakdown of costs with allowances, i.e. plumbing, electrical, framing and drywall, etc. Pay close attention to the allowances in each category - which are essentially your budgets for the items you will be picking out (sinks, faucets, flooring, appliances, light fixtures, countertops)...if you have your heart set on a built in Sub Zero fridge and your entire appliance allowance is $5000, you are in trouble!
Lastly, a good contractor should have a contingency dollar amount as a separate line item. Although they are good at estimating costs, they are not clairvoyant. Issues and unexpected costs come up on every project. If that contingency budget needs to be tapped you should expect a clear, accurate accounting of how it will be used. If you are lucky and nothing or very little goes wrong, it will be refunded to you in part or in whole. Remember, you don't want a contractor who is working with such tight margins that they skimp or cut corners on your project just to make a living. - 12 years agoI couldn't agree more with you Vicky, and people already getting burned all the time and I see it on some jobs or when we get a call to fix something that was done 6 months ago and already is falling apart and needs to be replace.
On all my jobs I offer quality plumbing fixtures or quality cabinetry by well known manufacturers, who offer worry free warranty and replacements if needed...
It is better for me to install a better quality product even if it cost a little more, then have call backs because something is not working. When I have call backs, this is when its costing me money... So the motto always is- do it one time, do it right or don't do it at all and I pass this on to my sons.
But some clients (not all but some) for some reason think you will provide something cheap, and they can find something better on the internet or some store someplace who get this and that, what ever they can get theirs hands on at the time for a good price... So they start ordering vanities and this fancy faucets from manufacturers I never heard of. When items arrive, they fall apart as you taking them out of the box, some will start delaminate a month later. Fixtures will start leaking or break or better yet when they come in and the parts are missing and you cannot get a replacement part anywhere because no body knows who makes this faucet. So it starts shipping back and forth, delays, aggravations, etc.
I guess in the end like some of the above post said, you get what you pay for, and its very true what when they say it that the bitterness of pour quality will stay with you longer then the sweetness of low price. - 12 years agoWhat's harder than finding a good contractor?
Having a major appliance last 20+ years. Heck, I'd settle for 10. ieme
Original Author12 years agoHello here I am again this a layout I am considering its a peninsula I really wanted an island big enough to seat 4 but most pro that came in didn't recommend it they said I don't have enough space my kitchen is 14' by 12' and my ceiling is 8' the cabinets I am considering is made by CUBITAC I saw it in a showroom the shaker style in café it's made out of birch wood the box is 1/2 " all plywood doors all wood,drawers are 3/4 " all wood full extention glide,dovetail joints,soft close does anybody knows if this characteristic are descent for semi Custom.please also look and if you think I can still get my island please please let me know and how would it place in my kitchen thank you again



- 12 years agoYou really need to put on the brakes here and do a lot more research. In 3 seconds of Googling I was able to find out that those are Chinese import cabinets, and no where near semi-custom quality. And no, you are not going to shoehorn an island into that kitchen without getting rid of all of the cabinets and refrigerator on that side of the room. Which you would know, if you had researched the NKBA planning guidelines and done some basic measurements. You're getting ahead of yourself in even talking with a contractor without knowing mre of the nuts and bolts of your project. Like I said, at least a year's worth of research is ahead if you want to be able to be able to do this project with wise, informed, choices.
Or just hire the designer that I also suggested. ieme
Original Author12 years ago@Sophie wheeler thank you but believe me I have been looking and reading about this for more than a year bought issues of mag from consumer to anything that has kitchen in it and it's a lot and gets confusing and I know that with the island I will have to loose the cabinets by the fridge still wouldn't give me the size I want and about the cabinets I know they made in China but I think they assemble in their jersey warehouse and you are a pro maybe you can tell me I have looked at Medallion silverline and it seems to me that the construction is about the same or is that also another bad company so please if you can help About cabinetry let me know I have even follow the guidelines from consumer report in what to look for in cabinets they recommend to look for the stuff I mentioned earlier thank you- 12 years agoIeme,
I would consider putting the stove where your dishwasher is, center the sink with the window and put the dishwasher next to it. I would also suggest if you can remove the soffit and go with a 36" cabinet, with a build up filler and crown to the ceiling.
Medallion, is a much better cabinet and offers a semi-custom and custom lines. They have a much better manufacturer stain and clear coat finish, much better in comparison to Chinese line cabinetry etc.
I read a few articles a while back and it was said that there is a limited US standard for emissions, hence why formaldehyde laden plywood which is too toxic to even sell it in China can be shipped and sold here. Now I think the law which tries to control that, but I'm not sure how effective it is.
Some Chinese plywood, which is also used in a low priced furniture, can contain high levels of formaldehyde, they use it to make it up for excessive moisture during production.
Here in USA, they use a more expensive technique which eliminates the need to use glue which contains formaldehyde when they glue the layers of plywood, this why when you want plywood cabinet box, there is an up charge and you will pay about 10-15% more depends on the manufacturer.
That whole kitchen you have there, will run in the neighborhood 5-6k using Chinese cabinets, any other in comparison from a well known manufacturer around 7-8k.
I joke when customers ask me "what about Chinese cabinets", I tell them as long as you line your drawers with tinfoil, you be OK, this way your utensils will not corrode.
You can try the following manufacturers who make a nice cabinet in any price range, Armstrong, Timberlake, Ultracraft, Aristofraft, etc
When buying your kitchen, it should be KCMA ( Kitchen Cabinet Manufacturers Association) certified.
Good luck and I hope it helps. ieme
Original Author12 years ago@GN builders LLC Thank you so much and you are so right about pricing and your input is a big help but the sink is the corner how can I put a range there?It won't slide in al the way and the reason for the sink being there is because I will have a blind there and loose spaceieme
Original Author12 years ago@ GN builders sorry about my misreading ok the reason why I didn't want the stove there is that it's close to my hallway entry and I don't want the food smell as I cook with heavy spices to get in easyieme
Original Author12 years ago@GN Builders can you please explain to me the soffit you mention I google it but didn't get much understanding thank you- 12 years agoIf you have a soffit right now above your cabinets and you have 30" cabinets right now. You can remove existing soffit, and instead of 30" upper cabinets go with 36" cabinet and use a cabinet filler on the top with crown molding.
Something like in the picture.
- 12 years agoI understand both sides of this issue. Our problem is that our contractor has put us in an awkward place where we feel like demanding clients for correcting mistakes. No matter how many times design decisions are discussed, he does it the way it's laid out in his head. Then he gets behind schedule and blames it on us. We asked for an itemized bid in the beginning and he wrote out some things but was really upset we asked and then later we find out most of those things aren't included in the price. When we question charges (I swear he's doubling up charges), he gets very upset. We're tens of thousands over budget now as a result and considering subbing out paint, flooring, and tile ourselves to save money (and time--our contractor is only on site one-two times per week because he took another big job). We are so frustrated and don't know how to handle it at this point. I know we're not blameless, but I'm ticked we've reached this point.
- 12 years agoI work with contractors on a regular basis. It really depends on how they like to bid their projects. Some base it on a square foot basis, others base it on a labor and materials cost, if you are wanting to save some money and are looking for areas to do that the. You could ask him to break it down room by room. When doing a huge remodel sometimes a itemized break down is just not possible. When I start out with a client we go room by room and list out all the items that need to be addressed and then I usually get a total price from contractors. I can the. Go back and negotiate by asking where we can save money. They can give ideas based on using different materials. Don't be afraid to talk with your contractor but you may want to hire a designer to help negotiate everything. Hope this helps!
Related Stories

REMODELING GUIDESContractor's Tips: 10 Things Your Contractor Might Not Tell You
Climbing through your closets and fielding design issues galore, your contractor might stay mum. Here's what you're missing
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESContractor Tips: What Your Contractor Really Means
Translate your contractor's lingo to get the communication on your home project right
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESContractor Tips: 10 Hats Your General Contractor Wears
Therapist, financial advisor, mediator — for the price of a single good contractor on your remodel, you're actually getting 10 jobs done
Full Story
You Said It: Hot-Button Issues Fired Up the Comments This Week
By Becky Harris
Dust, window coverings, contemporary designs and more are inspiring lively conversations on Houzz
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESContractor Tips: Advice for Laundry Room Design
Thinking ahead when installing or moving a washer and dryer can prevent frustration and damage down the road
Full Story
WORKING WITH PROS7 Tips for Making Contractors Your Allies
For a contractor as vested as you are in your home project's success, follow these time-tested techniques from a professional designer
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESContractor Fees, Demystified
Learn what a contractor’s markups cover — and why they’re worth it
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDES10 Things to Ask Your Contractor Before You Start Your Project
Ask these questions before signing with a contractor for better communication and fewer surprises
Full Story
MOST POPULARThe Polite House: On ‘No Shoes’ Rules and Breaking Up With Contractors
By Lizzie Post
Emily Post’s great-great-granddaughter gives us advice on no-shoes policies and how to graciously decline a contractor’s bid
Full Story
CONTRACTOR TIPSWhat to Look for in a Contractor's Contract
10 basic ingredients for a contract will help pave the way to remodel happiness
Full StorySponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!

mfwolfe