What does the label on top say? Does it show the same number? With Behr paint samples, they put a computerized label on it that is generated from imputting the code for that color. That's the first place I'd look to see if they really are the same color.

Another thing I've found with paint, and this is more of a heads up, and that is that paint with primer is darker than without primer.

Hi Brenna, We're sorry for the inconvenience and would like to help you. Toasted Almond information can be found here: http://www.ppgpittsburghpaints.com/color/paint-colors/toasted-almond-414-3 To make sure your paint was tinted correctly please contact us via email at tchsrvaf@ppg.com or speak directly to a PPG Pittsburgh Paints® representative by calling us at 1‑800‑441‑9695.