Software
Houzz Logo Print
miriyumb

I can't decide between a wood deck and a composite deck, any suggestions

14 years ago
we are building a new house and my builder is giving us a choice of wood or composite decking. I read very mixed reviews online and now I'm all confused! I would love to hear from professionals as well as those who chose composite decks. Thanks!

Comments (23)

  • PRO
    14 years ago
    thanks!
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    AGREED - if you can do composite - do that because my husband talked me into Cedar again, and every second year, we're re-staining...enjoy your deck, don't be a slave to it - go composite!
  • 11 years ago
    Composite!
  • 11 years ago
    Installed in 2 homes now, it is great, no regrets, cleans beautifully, love it!
  • 11 years ago
    We live in a heavily wooded area. Oak trees surround the house. Friends have said it is hard to get organic stains off a composite deck and they can scratch easily from chairs being moved in and out. Our contractor said that one client scratched his deck shoveling snow off this past winter. He used a plastic shovel. Any advice.
  • 11 years ago
    A friend who has composite once remarked how HOT composite gets.
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    When rebuilding our deck several years ago, we considered composite but discovered that we could get Ipe (Brazilian hardwood) for about the same cost. No maintenance needed unless you want to keep the dark color and that only requires a coat of oil in the spring. After 6 winters the deck still looks great and best of all, it is real wood and has a look which no composite that I have seen can match.


  • 11 years ago
    I echo the first reviewer. I've had both and will never go back to wood decks again. Composite costs quite a bit more but after that, there's minimal maintenance, no touch-up painting required, and it seems like it will outlast me at this point.
  • 11 years ago

    Ipe all the way


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    As a composite decking manufacturer, we advise customers to get a sample before they decide. This may help you get a sense of what the composite will look like, and how it will stand up to the elements.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Well, both deck material having their own advantages. But the majority of decks built today are made of wood. The main reason people choose wood is for the initial cost savings. And on the other side the reason people choose composite or man-made deck materials is for the low maintenance required.At the end the decision is all your's with which deck material you go for.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    EP Visualz made a great suggestion with Ipe, a Brazilian hardwood that requires much less maintenance than a traditional wood deck. Ipe is a naturally resilient building material and stays beautiful with minimal maintenance.

    It also provides many benefits over composite decking beyond the more desirable appearance. Composite deck materials tend to get unbearably hot in the sun and it's uncomfortable to walk on because they absorb and hold the heat. This effect can be amplified if you are in an area with a lot of sun.

    If the composite boards get deep scratches or stains, you are unable to sand and refinish the boards - you must replace them. This can cause additional problems when the new boards do not match the original ones that you had installed due to discontinuation or discoloration.

    If you are concerned about the maintenance required with a wood deck, you should consider exotic hardwoods like Ipe, Tigerwood, or Cumaru. These materials have much lower maintenance than most wood decks while still providing all of the benefits of having a wood deck.

    Other great options are Redwood and Mahogany decks.

    We have a couple articles on our blog about the pros and cons of wood vs. composite decking materials if you would like to learn more which I have linked below.

    What is the Best Material for a Deck?

    Wood Vs Composite & Synthetic Decking – The Annual Debate Begins

  • 10 years ago

    If the deck will be in direct sun, consider that the composite decks can get very hot.

    We used mahogany in the front and pressure treated in the back. Mahogany wins. The PT tends to bow a little. We oil each in the spring. That's all.

  • 10 years ago
    I've had both, and count me in the "composite fan" group. It's so carefree and you don't have to worry about splinters or stubbed toes on popped nails. They are very friendly to bare feet. And most importantly, no staining and no ugly peeling paint/stain ever! We did scratch ours shoveling snow off it, so now we just wait and let the snow melt. It gets a little warm when the sun shines right on it in the heat of the day, but not ridiculously hot.
  • 10 years ago

    Look at cumuru. Similar to ipe. Less expensive. Love ours

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Composites and get very hot and some will scratch if you have big dogs. Ipe is the way to go if you don't mind a little maintenance.

  • 9 years ago
    Old post 2012!
  • 9 years ago

    Yes - but remains relevant...

  • 8 years ago

    I would definitely go for African Mahogany wood decking if you choose to use wood for your decking at all.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    IPE doesn't splinter like the old wood decks you are used to. It is 8x harder than Redwood, 2.5x stronger than Redwood and has a Class A fire rating. Meaning it's as good as brick in terms of fire spread. It's termite and mold resistant and certified for use in ADA applications. As far as stubbing your toes you can use hidden fasteners so there are no screws from above or IPE plugs if screwing from the top. IPE is long lasting too: The boardwalk at Coney Island used IPE and it lasted 70 years before being replaced and the wood is still going in the form of benches, planter boxes and other things. I'd never use composite over IPE ever unless you like that plastic look...

  • 7 years ago
    • Wood plastic composite decking does not corrode
      Woodd plastic decking has strong corrosion resistance
      The wood-plastic decking has better working performance and can be molded into a natural-looking decking with real wood grain
      WPC decks are considered sustainable building materials because they are made from recycled plastic and wood industry waste.
      Wood plastic composite decking has good durability and stability
      WPC decking are safe to use because they are not like traditional wooden deck debris or cracks

    Wood Plastic Composites are not only used in decking flooring. Due to their huge popularity in the sustainable building materials category, a lot of building professionals are using wood plastic composite for railings, fencing, landscaping timbers, Pergola and Pavilion, as well as indoor furniture.

    In addition, many customers like to use black , Brown and reddish Color.With the color, the display of the wood-plastic floor is more popular.

    While there a lot of composite Decking Manufacturers in China, Changxing Hanming Technology Co.,LTD only provide high quality WPC Products.


    SO we suggest use a a composite deck。

  • 7 years ago

    There are many materials to choose from while building a deck. From Cedar to pressure- treated wood and composite, following link help you

    Various Decks You Can Use to Make Your House More Appealing