Shopped 1000s of lights, and can't commit to new fixtures for our island bar. Seeking any suggestions to get it completed!!

Photos show old pendants and one new we tested. Cabinets were resurfaced, and at some point, we will also redo counters/backsplash. Casual family room and breakfast area adjoin kitchen.

(NOTE: We have a traditional, almost Tuscan, home which we are updating with modern elements so it will reflect an interesting, youthful, relaxing, yet upscale blend of its architectural style and our modern taste. Some new things are very modern and others have remained complimentary to the home.)