I'd paint the bars on the bottom pair like wrought iron and leave the cups as is.

Both designs seem appealing to me. I am having trouble telling which ones are painted and which are rustic. For the base, I prefer the top look with the solid, rusty-looking design. I love the cup type holders on the bottom set. If you are making photos to sell these items, try replacing those red candles with amber or brown and see if you like the look better.... I can just see some of those small 3-tone candles in shades of tan and rust and brown in there!!
Laura