Software
Houzz Logo Print
marial1214

Limas or Favas?

17 years ago

Does anyone know if lima beans taste better than favas? Also when would I plant them? Do I plant them in spring when I plant my beans and snap peas? I live in PA, zone 6.

Also can someone suggest a good seed site to buy from? Victory seed company doesnt give telephone support so I cannot ask them my questions.

Does anyone know which lima or fava variety I should buy?

Comments (12)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    They are virtual opposites in terms of preferred weather; favas can be planted in cool soil and like cool to warmish weather, while limas must be planted in warm soil and like hot weather.

    IMO, favas are rather disgusting while limas are about as good as it gets.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lima beans seem to be one of those love 'em or hate 'em vegetables like brussels sprouts or parsnips. I can't tell you about favas. There is a thread here on favas which help with that question.

    Peas are planted early, when the weather is cool. Beans need warm soil. There is no advantage to planting them before the soil is warm, especially limas. In your area that probably means early June.

    A friend of mine who loves fresh limas grows a large amount of Fordhook limas every year. They are large bush limas. I grow mostly pole beans. My favorite so far is White Willow Leaf, which is a smallish lima.

    I like Victory seeds. It's a small family run company and they offer many of the varieties I want. Also, I like Sand Hill Preservation for the same reasons. Your order is handled by the owners, unlike the big companies, so you know it receives close attention.

    Jim

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oops. I thought I was still in the bean forum when I posted the above. The link below will take you to the thread I was referring to.

    Jim

    Here is a link that might be useful: Why not try favas?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you All! Limas it is and I have heard of Fordhook so I hope to find them at the local Lowe's this afternoon. I think it is a pain to open each pod to remove limas. That is the only part I think I will not like. Prolly have to open 50 to get a meal or an amount to freeze. My understanding is I must put two stakes in and tie string between them. I think I can handle that.

    My excuses to all for not posting my question in the bean and legume forum.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My friend who grows Fordhooks does not provide any support for them. It's easier than you think. :-)

    Jim

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Taste is purely a subjective thing. I like limas and cannot stand favas.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Watch Me Grow A Giant Pumpkin

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There's nothing that compares to the taste of fresh shellies, whether peas, beans, or cowpeas, so I think you'll get over the dislike of shelling.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Personally, I think that limas picked in the ripe shell stage ("butterbeans") are one of the true joys of home gardening. Limas do, as others have already stated, require heat - especially high soil temperatures for germination. They will just rot in cool or waterlogged soil.

    "Fordhook 242" is probably the best bush variety, followed by "Burpee's Improved". Both of these are large seeded, and neither requires staking. There are also "baby" bush limas (such as "Henderson's" & "Thorogreen") but personally, I don't find their taste appealing. Others, of course, might disagree.

    My preference for limas is the pole varieties. While they are a little later, the yields can be huge... and because of their high yield per plant, they are worthwhile started as transplants. There is also much more variety to choose from for pole limas. "King of the Garden" is the most widely available, and is a large-seeded variety which is similar in quality to "Fordhook". It is probably the earliest large-seeded pole lima. "Christmas" has even larger seeds, with red & white stripes, and is a little later. "Dr. Martin" is probably the largest, with huge seeds, and requires a fairly long season. "Florida Butter" and "Florida Speckled" have red & white seeds.

    "Seiva" and "Carolina Red" are small-seeded pole varieties that mature quickly, and are probably the best choices for short-season areas. "Seiva" is one of the few limas that I can direct seed this far North, and it will still bear reliably. It has a very high yield, but is not my favorite as a green shell... really good in succotash, though.

    BTW, green shelled limas are a bear to shell, due to the stiff pods; limas in the ripe shell stage are not that difficult. The pods generally turn yellow and/or begin to brown, shrivel, or become translucent in that stage - some varieties are more noticeable when ripe than others. After harvest, I let the pods sit for a day to soften them further, then shell them... a pinch at the tip of the pod generally pops them open. With practice, you can do this quickly. Of course, the larger the lima, the faster you can shell a large quantity by weight.

    Of the limas listed, "Fordkook 242" and "King of the Garden" are probably the most widely available; you can usually find them in seed racks. Those & others are widely available by mail, from such companies as Victory Seeds, and Baker Creek.

    There are also quite a few heirloom limas, some quite interesting... but most of them require long, hot summers to be productive. I have had limited success starting some of them here as transplants, mostly with small to mid-sized varieties. Some good sources for heirloom limas include: Sand Hill preservation, Southern Exposure Seed Exchange, Native Seeds/SEARCH, and Southern Seed Legacy.

    Favas do best in cool Maritime climates, or as a Winter crop in the South. As much as limas love heat, favas hate it. The plants are attractive short to medium-tall bushes, with black & white flowers & very large pods. Like limas, there are both small-seeded & large-seeded varieties... and the large ones can be very large.

    "Taste is purely a subjective thing. I like limas and cannot stand favas."

    I agree; personally, I don't like them as green shell. The flavor is strong, and not what I am used to. The tough skin must be removed before eating. But more than that, there are large numbers of people who are allergic to them ("favism") so you would want to be cautious if serving them to someone for the first time.

    There are not many varieties of favas available here in the States. Thompson & Morgan (U.S.) once carried quite a few, but seems to have dropped them now. Johnny's, Territorial, and Vermont Bean (among others) carry at least one variety. Prairie Garden Seeds (Canada) has a good selection, but I'm not sure if they would ship to the U.S.; you'd probably want to email them first.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    for something very like limas that can tolerate the cool weather, plant Scarlet Runner Beans. they are a tender, broad, flat bean that you can cook like limas. I think they are very under-appreciated.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree, SRB is really tasty as well as super-showy.

    Zeedman, thanks! You are the last word on beans. I always do beans as an after-though, I have to stop doing that. For instance, I forgot once again to order sieva limas. If I can find one of those pole limas locally I will try starting indoors as you suggest.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I love favas!! I have never had fresh lima beans, though, in the interest of full disclosure.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The allergy problem is what has always kept me from trying favas. I love all beans and peas, but seed catalogues used to carry warnings for fava beans. The allergy is most likely to effect people of Middle East or Mediterranean descent. I have learned recently that it effects males more often than females.
    I might like them if I tried. Actually, shelling peas or beans has always been pleasurable if you can keep it straight which parts you want to keep and which to discard (or at least get it figured out before you cook them).