Software
Houzz Logo Print
oldgreybob

Expanding the vegetable garden

17 years ago

In the next 2 months I plan to expand my vegetable garden, at least doubling it in size. The current garden is 20Â by 30Â. I have been told a number of ways of handling the existing lawn in the area of expansion.

1. Just till it in with a heavy duty tiller.

2. Spray it with Roundup as soon as snow and frost is gone, wait a few weeks to a month and then till it in.

3. Get a sod cutter, remove and dispose the sod, (composting it in the village compost site.) Then get a couple cubic yards of top soil.

4. Cover the area with a heavy opaque plastic. For the first year cut holes in the plastic to plant transplants. The following year all the sod should be gone!

Anyone have experience with these ideas or have additional ideas and tips?

Comments (14)

  • 17 years ago

    I would personally use Option #1. I would then go through and pick out all the big pieces of sod.

    I am not a fan of using RoundUp...I am not exactly an organic nut, but I think it is best to use as little chemicals as possible.

    If you go with option one...you wouldn't have to buy topsoil (if your soil was good)

    I would not go with option #4...I would be afraid that the roots of new veggies would be hampered by all the weeds and grass roots. Also, if you use black plastic the soil may get too warm. Clear plastic would allow those weeds to get the sunlight they need.

    Now if you wanted to wait one year...till it, cover with black plastic...works like a charm...That's what I did.

    I think the easiest option would be #1.

    Here is a link that might be useful: How my garden grows!

  • 17 years ago

    I think it will depend on your type of soil, grass and your time frame.

  • 17 years ago

    For best first year production, (as long as you don't have bermuda grass) just build raised beds with 2x6 lumber and fill with trucked in topsoil. The grass will be smothered, you avoid the work of tilling and expense if you don't have one. If you get a source for topsoil that delivers with slinger trucks, you don't even have the work of filling the beds. It buries any weeds too. Most will not come up through 6" of extra dirt.

    I just had 10 yds of 50/50 premium topsoil and "zoo brew" compost. Zoo brew includes manure from the Columbus Zoo. Last year I had drainage problems in my clay soil, so raised beds filled with this mix is my solution.

  • 17 years ago

    I will give you the disadvantages of each. I assume you want to garden this year.

    1 and 2. They leave the seed bank intact, producing weed problems later in the season.

    1 will leave pieces of rhizomes that will later produce grass weeds.

    2 the Roundup is applied too early. It will have its maximum effect in May for you (Zone 5), when grass is growing aggressively.

    3 is good but expensive, and leaves the seed bank in the bought topsoil intact.

    4 will probably be OK, and given your northern latitude, it will not affect vegetables too much, if you grow heat loving vegetables such as eggplant, watermelon, and pepper.
    Next year, you will have to cope with the seed bank.

    To remove the seed bank, you will have to cover with organic matter (mulch), which will later form a weed free top inch of soil. There are numerous ways to get free organic matter in the quantity (a few tons) you need. Mulch will keep the soil temperature down, which is probably a bad thing for you the first year, although by no means the biggest consideration.

    If I were you I would solarize now (black or clear plastic), mulch in May, when the soil is very warm (removing the plastic first), and plant the area with large summer veggies only (squash, tomato, pepper, okra, melons, beans). As the mulch turns into soil, you can then upgrade to greens and smaller veggies.

  • 17 years ago

    You'll probably get as many different opinions as you get replies.

    If I were doing this, I would do #2 and then #4. Glib is absolutely correct, Roundup applied too early won't have a big effect. But, as soon as the grass really greens up, you could hit it with a fairly concentrated shot of Roundup, then till, then cover with black plastic and plant through it.

    I've done #4 many times -- it works fine, except that grass will regrow through your planting holes unless you give it a couple of months to die first, hence the reason for doing #2 first.

  • 17 years ago

    I would add a 6th option---cover it with cardboard and turn it into a lasagna bed. The sod breaks down under the cardboard and becomes part of the compost. It doesn't require any chemicals. The worms do the work for you, it costs less if you use materials others discard. etc,etc. You don't have to use just the materials Patricia Lanza used. In the end you have beautiful rich soil.

  • 17 years ago

    Removing the sod from your property is the worst option by far - just giving away fertility. Followed closely by the round-up. Of course there are as many options as there are gardeners.

    Another way is take your sharp shovel and shear of the sod from bed-sized areas and pile it upside down on other bed-sized areas to rot out. Mix amendments into the freshly-exposed beds and plant.

    It's kind of difficult to get beds into growing shape so quickly without importing some kind of growing medium and making raised beds.

  • 17 years ago

    Till it, cover with lime & let sit for a few weeks (or until a good rain passes), then till again...plant a week or so later.

  • 17 years ago

    Last year we did #1 with our big patch (20x20) and it worked just fine, though you must mulch heavily afterwards because the weeds are still going strong.
    This year Im going to try the lasagna composting on a new patch, but I dont plan on trying to plant it this year, just let it rot all season and use it next year, it seems like the least labor-intensive

  • 17 years ago

    I second the lasagna bed suggestion. Just cover the area with cardboard or a lot of newspaper (6 sheets or so), water it down thouroughly, and then dump compost on top. It's still pretty early so if you cover the whole thing with clear plastic it should cook away, kill any seeds and keep it wet and decomposing. When it's time, uncover it and plant right through, cutting the cardboard/paper if necessary.

  • 17 years ago

    I've tried several different methods, and what works the best for me is to till, plant, then put layers of newspaper around the plants and cover with mulch. That way you have nice, easy soil to work with from the tilling and the newspaper keeps the weeds down while still allowing for the mulch to break down and feed the soil. I find any non-tilling method annoying because you have to dig through grass roots to plant anything which is difficult even if the grass is dead. I don't want to pay to truck in dirt for raised beds either as I have very nice soil. I still get some weeds using this method, but not a lot and I just use roundup or grass-be-gone when they do show up.

  • 17 years ago

    Personally I wouldnt use round up. Its a nasty chemical, you could do the same thing by pouring boiling water over the area to kill whatever is there. Or use it for spot treating weeds when they show up. I worry about it killing worms and other beneficials in the top layer of soil, but I figure round up is probably worse for them and for you. But thats JMO. I spot treat weeds with boiling water and they brown up and go away in about a day. The lasagna method is the way I chose to go this year. Its great spongy soil filled with worms and its a rich blackness in color.

  • 17 years ago

    I'll tell you what I've done in the past.

    I did the tilling method, the weeds come back.

    I did the sod lifting and replace with top soil. The weeds came back, but not as much as the first.

    I have used plastic to kill weeds over the winter, then removed the plastic and replaced it with newspaper/cardboard and covered it with soil/compost/mulch and planted. This worked the best for me.

    Additional note: If it is interesting, the worm population in my final option was much more prevalent and the worms were much more robust than the other options in the second year. Using chemicals (I've heard) will reduce worm numbers. Leaving the sod and letting it die under the plastic held moisture in the soil (and kept it warmer over the winter), so I believe it attracted worms and they feasted all winter and the second year they were absolutely HUGE the following spring (incidently I covered the bed with plastic the second winter as well, just to keep weed growth down).

  • 17 years ago

    I've personally used the cardboard method and have no complaints whatsoever. Use some good thick stuff and make sure to wet it down good. Cover it with compost or even a layer of thick woodchips. It saves a TON of time. Let the worms do the work.