Software
Houzz Logo Print
northernellie

Plants dying in gritty mix?

17 years ago

I have managed to sift through a few bags of Floor Dry and repot a few of my plants into a gritty mix of 1/2 Gran-I-Grit and 1/2 Floor Dry (diatomite) and some lime. I made a weak MG fert solution after thoroughly drenching the plants and letting the powder run out of the drain holes. Within 2-3 days several of my plants wilted from the outside in (and sometimes inside out, entire branches dying, leaves dying from the stem out, roots blackened) and were dead. Anyone else had a problem with Floor Dry or Gran-I-Grit, or did my emergency/impatience with not letting the mix sit for a few weeks saturated (as suggested but not demanded afaik) cause this?

Another possibility I thought of earlier when my husband told me (see below): On some of the plants I used one watering can with 1/2 strength Miracle Gro fert (1/2tsp/gal). My husband made some for me also and later on he told me he mixed 3 tsp in a 2 gallon container. He said I asked for it that way, I guess I had a serious brain fart. I usually prefer to err on the weak side. That mix got dumped after he told me but not after I used some of it. I can't recall which group of plants got which water as I was and am moving everyone around. I wouldn't think even 3 tsp (not tbsp) in 2 gallons would be enough to kill a plant though, would it? It is a lot for a container plant, but I did flush afterward when I noticed the decline, talked with husband and what all. They still died.

In any case I'm glad I'm short on time and haven't repotted them all yet.

Anyone willing to rub heads with me? Maybe we'll get sparks.

Thanks,

Ellie

Comments (24)

  • 17 years ago

    Am new to fertilizing btw - always used stuff I had around the house (mostly bird poop from our bird) but in the new soil I am using the pure nutrients. It makes more sense from what I read. After some googling these past many minutes perhaps I am using way too much even though I thought it was weak from the package directions. Hmm.. Still, dead in 2-3 days?
    This is turning out to be an expensive learning experience.

    Thanks,
    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not sure what the problem is, but maybe one of the more knowledgable members can give you a better answer.

    I've been using the gritty soil mix (equal parts Turface/pine bark/granite) for a couple of seasons now and have no problems at all growing tres in it. In fact they thrive in it.

    I've not used actual Grani-Grit but instead used a crushed granite from a local feed store. I assume what I use and Grani-Grit are nearly identical. I use Turface rather than floor dry but again they should be interchangable as long as the floor dry products contain either calcinated clay or diatomaceous earth.

    If you use a weak fertilizer solution you should be Ok on that as well. If the fertilizer was really strong I could see it causing problems but sounds like that's not the case here.

    Any chance that the roots of your plants dried out during the transplanting process?

    Did you wash out the containers carefully before using them to remove old soil? This helps avoid disease and/or bacteria issues.

    Seems like this gritty soil shouldnt kill any plant, let alone kill one in only a couple of days.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    I would suspect the transplanting process rather than the mix. There is nothing about the mix that would lead to plant death.

    Did you bareroot the plants as part of the transplanting process? If so some wilting is expected. At this time placing plants in a shady location is desirable until the feeder roots regrow and the plant can take up water normally again.

  • 17 years ago

    If the 'floor-dry' and granite were appropriate materials, it's definitely a cultural problem other than the soil. If you used lime (instead of gypsum) in combination with the floor-dry/granite, your pH is very high (8.0+), but not high enough to kill the plants that quickly. Using floor-dry leaves no possibility of using lime as a Ca source because of this very issue.

    The two most likely suspects are over-watering or over-fertilizing, with over-fertilizing being the more likely of the two, but again, it could be either.

    Was the 'floor-dry' the product from NAPA and was it stable, or did it turn to clay when it was moistened?

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    What, no bark?... does it matter? And I thought mine with a third of bark was too dry.

  • 17 years ago

    You can grow perfectly healthy plants in just Turface (screened is preferred) or a mix of Turface and granite. I grow several plants in a mix with no organic component at all (some pines, junipers, succulents). The bark does more to ease the angst of newbies making the soil (you'd prolly never buy the idea you can grow in a mix completely devoid of an organic component), than it does for the soil. Take that last with a grain of salt, please. I took SOME license with the statement to help inject a little dry humor. ;o)

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    The roots for sure didn't dry out. I make sure I have everything lined up and do it quickly. At the time of transplanting (in the evening so they do not dry out, braving the mosquitoes) I do the following: Whack the container all the way around and ease out the root ball. If it did not colonize the entire container and/or had root rot, dump the rest of the existing mix into the wheelbarrow (to take to the garden later). Spray out the container until clean, scrubbing with a bristle brush if necessary (no soap). Add insect screen on drain holes. Fill part way with gritty mix (eyeballing to where the root ball should be). Spray (groundwater is 55-60F) and massage the rootball till all visible organic matter is gone and roots appear clean. Prune out dead roots with my fingernails or scissors, depending on thickness. Hose off again to get all dead roots off. Place in pot over dry mix. Backfill, tapping and shaking to get the mix into the root voids. Top off to desired or appropriate level. These last few steps take at most 30 seconds. Then I drench the plant until the water that runs out of the drain holes is clear. Then I fertilized.

    Bad step in there somewhere? A step not taken?
    Al you mentioned pH could be a problem. How much vinegar should I add per gallon to err on the safe side of pH?
    I used dolomitic lime.
    I don't think it's overwatering. I merely drenched them to rinse out the substrate, and it is screened to 1/8-1/4" so I know it drained. After that it merely felt cool/humid to the touch several hours later (though some pots have darker colored substrate just a couple of mm below the surface 3-4 days later). I have overwatered plants before and they never die like this. I usually get lots of warning. I am leaning towards overfertilizing and the plants being more sensitive to it due to the shock and horror of transplanting.

    Thanks,
    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    Should add: Only the hardiest plants went back into full sun. Some Dahlias and my Pelargonium. They are still happy (so far), though the Dahlias did not appreciate it (yet) they are not dying. Others I put into shade or part shade and it was several of those that died. My Ficus maclelandii is on the decline now too, dropping leaves left and right. It doesn't appear to be turning to black mush like the others though.
    Yet.

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    Forgot to also add: The floor dry did in fact hold together through a soaking and freezing test. It is diatomite. After rinsing there are no particles finer than 1/8" in the pots.

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    Al you said I shouldn't use lime if I used the floor dry, but then where would they get the calcium? Mag I can do with Epsom salts but I don't have soluble calcium nor am I willing to pay a premium for it (I'm not aware of a compound that is readily available, cheap and soluble). In any event one thing I DO have is elemental sulfur for my blueberries. Think that would be a terrible idea in containers at perhaps a fraction of the recommended rate for outdoors?

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    I am curious...

    Do you know how to take photos?
    I would love to see them of the mix you planted in, like say a handful. Take a close up of the mix. Then take pics of your dying plants too.
    Is this possible...? Pictures speaks volumns!
    I have never lost a plant in the gritty mix unless "I" transplanted incorrectly....My fault..You learn though..-)
    Hope to see some pics soon..ok
    Mike

  • 17 years ago

    The Ca source for the gritty mix should be CaSO4 (gypsum), because the pre-limed pH of the soil is higher than bark/peat soils. This is ESPECIALLY true when you're using floor-dry @ 50/50 with granite. Turface comes in at a pH of about 6.2 and floor-dry @ 7.0. Since container media should be at least a full point lower than mineral soils, you want the soil to be below 5.5 as a starting point, and that can't be done with DE and lime. Gypsum has very little effect on the media pH.

    You should consider what I said as a sidebar, because I don't think it's the telling issue in what you described, though it does pretty much assure you of micro-nutrient deficiencies in the future, especially Fe and Mn, unless you acidify the irrigation solution.

    I'm wondering if maybe you used quicklime instead of dolomitic lime? What kind of lime DID you use?

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    I used prilled dolomitic lime.

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    I am not willing to chuck this mix if the pH can be workable with acidulated water. So a tbsp of vinegar/gallon? More? Less? I spent way too much time sifting this stuff and way too much money. :)

  • 17 years ago

    Well - it's not the lime that caused the problems then. I don't know what to think. An ounce of vinegar per gallon of irrigation water is a good starting point to try to correct the pH issue, and switching to gypsum for Ca would also be wise. Unless the pH was sky-high (10+, which it isn't) it wouldn't cause the issues you described, so the cause is still unknown.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    From what I have been reading for many weeks, after you said that the plants have declined within days, 2 to 3? It can not be the lime so fast....
    I hope you find out. Check the roots on one of your dying plants, and tell us what they look like?
    Good luck.....;-)

  • 17 years ago

    One more thought.....

    If you made the gritty mix CORRECTLY, the way you said you did by sifting to appropiate size, and then saying it drained well, then one flush of plain water, even a regular watering until it drained out after feeding too much fertilizer then, would of fixed it.
    So I tend to think it is not that initial overdose either..

  • 17 years ago

    There is something I forgot till now. The diluted MG I used was from a bottle in which I mixed a specified amount of MG as well as alfalfa and seaweed teas for the micronutrients and growth boosting chems. This had sat a while but didn't smell bad so I figured it was fine. My new guess is overwhelming root infection from organisms in that old tea. The roots were rotted and slimy and that fits.
    I think we have our culprit.
    Thanks for talking to me guys and getting the other possible problems out of the way so we could get to the root of it (har har), and fixing future ones too, like pH!

    I do have a camera but I couldn't take a good pic as I'd already thrown away the dead parts, unless you just want proof of particle size. ;) The affected plants are gone and others seem unaffected, except the Ficus maclellandii which may just be leaf dropping as Ficus are wont to do. At least I hope so. It's one of my favs.

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    I do remember watering a couple more plants with that now that I think of it... some cacti. I think I'll try some H2O2 or Isopropyl or both to help them, but I don't know if it's too late now or not. I don't see rotten areas, but I expect it's a matter of time unless I do something.

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    Well the cuttings from the dead plants appear to still be alive. I sterilized the mix in the oven and potted them up so far so good. I guess I didn't water F. maclellandii with the pathogenic brew as it still seems to be alive and just doing the Ficus thing. My Cereus 'Ming Thing' I am pretty sure did get watered with it, and I guess that's a waiting game. No rotten spots that I see yet. It is outside and it has been raining like crazy today though. I think I'll bring it inside and let it dry out as it is supposed to rain for 2 more days. Hopefully cacti are more resistant. Crossing fingers.

    Thanks again for all your deducing everyone. This is definitely a case of operator error. I had some of the tea left over (one of those things I had around the house) and figured it'd be fine. Yuck.

    Oh well. Not much I can do about it now except learn. No more yucky brews. Even if I urge to "waste not want not."

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    It's far more likely that any problems associated with your mix/plants is the result of a soluble salts level that is too high or an anaerobic soil than it is from a biotic pathogen. Think of all the dead and rotting material that is scattered all about the farms, fields and forests - x-illions of tons of rotting plants and animals, and the in situ vegetation has no difficulty dealing with it - even thriving as a result of it.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Anaerobic soil is impossible. I did screen it this time and there truly are no particles finer than 1/8". I think if the tea was full of phytopthora or fusarium or other pathogenic single celled critter it could indeed kill them even in aerobic soil if present in overwhelming numbers. I postulate that the flora present in anaerobic alfalfa+seaweed tea is different than that in rotting plants on the ground. I'll do an experiment. I will repot some small weeds growing in the yard, dandelion is pretty survivable that way. I'll water one with the regular MG and the other with the leftover tea+MG mix I haven't dumped yet and take notes and pictures. That seems the only sensible way to try to eliminate pathogenic activity as a cause.
    I'll post the results here either way.
    I'll also look at a sample of the tea under the microscope, but I don't have a way of taking pictures of that.

    Ellie

  • 17 years ago

    Ok - let us know how it turns out.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Lol - sorry. I just woke up & re-realized we were talking about plants dying in the gritty mix. You're right, of course; problems couldn't be from anaerobic conditions unless you were almost intentionally over-watering. My bad.

    Al