Software
Houzz Logo Print
squibt

HOT concrete-soil mix?

19 years ago

I have a E-W facing concrete patio that gets full sun almost all day. Very little rain in the summer so pots need watering sometimes 2 times a day (maybe more). I want to use ALs soil mix but cannot find a source for Turface here in Nanaimo or on Vancouver Island for that matter (sigh). Any reccomendations for a soil mix I can use for Kilmarnock Willow, Acer shisigashira, and assorted flowers and shrubs all in containers? I have read many of Als posts and others posts regarding soil and containers and really want to use a soiless mix.

{{gwi:35483}}

Comments (25)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have no answer for you, but I just wanted to say that your patio looks fantastic! So many teeny pots!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thankyou CG,

    A lot of them are succulents. Going to have to move the pots around when the weather gets really hot...its a little more shady against the house.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Squibt,
    Why not try putting down a bamboo outdoor carpet?
    They are inexpensive, totally weather proof and washable and would cut down on the reflection of the concrete for your plants.
    Just a suggestion. your garden is beautiful!
    Love the shelves on the fence!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Excellent idea butterfly4u,

    Got to keep the heat down. I did put some pots on wood scraps...now to come up with a soil solution that would keep the plants cooler without over watering....

    Shelves were made from scraps of wood lying around...

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Squibt,

    In some old GW discussions about container soils, Al (Tapla) mentions Espoma Soil Perfector in the same context as Turface. Perhaps this is something you can find. You should do a GW search of this product to read some of the discussions that may be helpful in using ESP as an alternative to Profile Turface.

    I also couldn't find Turface but just recently purchased the ESP to make the potting mixture Al uses. It's too early for observations but I am confident that the results will be positive. Since trying my hand at container gardening, I have always had to water daily because of our hot summers (which for the last couple of days have reverted to early spring) so this requirement from using Al's mixture is nothing new for me.

    VaBreeze

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Forgot to mention that your yard is gorgeous! Love your arrangement of plants on the shelves and at varied levels. My back yard receives full sun all day and is all concrete where my containers are. I use the pot feet, 2" miniature pots, and some soda crates given to me by persons who bought Pepsi at a church fundraiser to raise the containers off of the concrete to allow for air and drainage. My containers are about 21" in circumference and 20" in height so perhaps the additional potting mixture makes their placement on or slightly raised from the concrete a non-issue.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Espoma Soil Perfector is Permatill marketed under another name. It's identical; I called the Permatill people because I can't find Permatill any more, and they told me they make it for Espoma. It's (baked) expanded slate -- much larger particles than Turface, which is a baked clay product. Not saying it won't work in containers, but it is very different stuff. I use Permatill to lighten clay soil.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanx for the advice all and the compliments. I have been reading every soil post I can find and have a good idea of what to use but Turface and Epsoma are not to be found in my area...I will continue to search for these products but for now I have created a planting mix that may work better than the store bought stuff:

    3 parts fine bark mulch
    1 part MG potting mix
    1/4 part peat moss
    1 1/2 parts perlite
    1 part #2 chicken grit
    1 handfull of Osmocote

    Seems to be extreamly well draining and holds just the right amount of moisture for my hot patio. I still want to try Al's mix just the way he makes it but for now this is the best I can do.

    squibt

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Turface was not available here either, but Play Ball a different product but serving the same original purpose as Turface was easy to find and so far I am happy with the results. Al

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanx Al,

    I will look for Play Ball here and see what I can find.

    squibT

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There are many recommended potting and soiless recipes. Some can be made easily with two or three commonly available ingredients. My containerized gardenia and roses, for example, are very happy and healthy (and mescluns, herbs, vegetables, and strawberries equally) growing in a mix made of only two ingredients (other than nutrients): perlite and some potting mix (or pine park fines). Although the ratio of my perlite mix vary depending on the preferences of the plant and sunlight exposure, I just mix 2-3 ingredients that are easily available to me locally to create the likely ideal pH-moisture-air mix for the plant I'm growing subject to the local climate/sun exposure/type of container. Pine bark fines, perlite, and potting mix are three commonly available ingredients in most areas. Due to individual variances of the plant and growing conditions, there isn't (nor does it need to be) one potting mix to be had. As long as the soiless mix you created can support a proper water-holding/aeration capacity, an approx. pH, and an efficient electrical conductivity (for nutrients) ideal for the plant in question, the specific ingredients are not so important for growing productive healthy plants, vegetables/fruits, and flowers in my view. Moreover, high hydropnoic crop yield in shorter amount of time and space can also be achieved with even more technical precision without a growing medium. Clearly, the main purpose of soiless growing medium is to provide some structural support and an approximate ideal pH, soluble nutrients, and moisture-air ratio for containerized plants easy to manage for home gardeners.

    From the picture, it appears you are successful with your current potting mix. What growing medium are you using? Are there specific reasons that you must use Al's mix or subject your plants to new environmental changes or even change your potting mix if your plants are growing well?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanx legacy,

    I am using my own mix of MG, peat, compost, bark fines and perlite. I think it may be a good mix for this year. Last year I used SeaSoil (PNW mix of seaweed/compost) peat and compost...the heat is incredible on the concrete patio and the mix dried out fast. Hope my new mix retains moisture a lot better. I want to experiment with Als mix just to see if the plants do better and are cooler. I know watering is an issue but I can do it. My "Al's mix"...

    3 parts fine bark mulch
    1 part MG potting mix
    1/4 part peat moss
    1 1/2 parts perlite
    1 part #2 chicken grit
    1 handfull of Osmocote
    ...seems to drain exceptionally well and also retains the right amount of water so you have kind of verified my thoughts on this soil mix...
    I will only repot a few items to see how it works. I will post my results at the end of the season.

    squibT

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I see what you are looking to do now. Here is another perspective for you. Since I have never heard of or read of any studies done about any potting mix that is either designed or can be used to reduce soil temperature or keep plants cooler (coir comes closest to it but more quality studies need to be done), I was confused when you spoke about finding or using the right mix to achieve these goals or mitigate your current problems. You certainly can add mulches, double pot, bury pots underground, create shades, hose down the patio, or cover the hot concrete patio with bamboo/carpet, and etc. to reduce the ambient heat and slow the evaporation rate of the potting mix to protect the roots and keep your plants cooler in these ways somewhat productively, but a potting mix (Al's mix or any soilless mix) by itself will neither significantly reduce or insulate the roots or the potting mix from drying out from exceptionally intense heat, nor can it keep a plant cool substantially in mitigating problems associated with a given micro-climate.

    I see other problems where the intense heat and water retention problems remain unsolved. Soilless mix are designed and by nature used to provide increased porosity and drainage to reduce soil compaction essential for healthy root growth in container culture. Hence, if you have had problem keeping up with watering with your old potting mix, which is made of peat and compost, combined with the intense radiating heat on the patio in the summer, then you'll be watering even more, not less, if you were to add Turface or repot with your Al's mix. Because your new soilless mix that you are about to repot your plants with has an even higher air-to-water ratio than your old soilless mix (peat/compost), I am at lost at both fronts how you will keep your plants cooler as well as hydrated with an even lighter mix.

    Even if we just rate composted pine bark fines and perlite as neutral, neither air nor water, since they both can have good moisture/air ratios, your proposed mix is barely on the wet side with the remaining components of MG potting mix/peatmoss(wet) against grit(air) at 1.25 : 1 ratio respectively. If you know your old soilless mix was drying out excessively last summer, then I would suggest you not use an even lighter mix but take out the grit and increase the percentages of both MG potting mix & peatmoss as well as perlite to a combined level at a minimum equal to pine bark fines, if you are looking to water less (the patio heat has to be reduced more productively in other ways suggested previously) and improve upon past mid-summer growing conditions. To give you some perspective, this proposed mix with more perlite and potting mix will still be on the dry side for your growing conditions since a roughly similar wet/dry potting mix ratio is just right for plants grown on a balcony (under shelter) getting morning sun and afternoon shade in hot humid Texas climate.

    I don't want you to waste time and be disappointed by your result if you can avoid it. Hope you find yout right mix and good luck!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Virginia is ten times hotter than Naniamo and I find that the addition of the very hydrophilic Acrylic resin products(available under a variety of brand names)to the potting mix makes a world of difference. This material swells with the addition of water and releases it to the roots slowly. Nanaimo is one of my favorite places in the world!
    Good Luck

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Squibt, how about growing (what I call) shade-makers? I dunno what will do well in your zone... here is one very pretty :o) idea for containerizing a dwarf tree, which might give your super duper BEAUTIFUL plant collection some needed heat-relief. 'Course you don't gotta use that particular example; the gist is creating a temporary dappled-shade-effect and bonus, you get to get a new plant! lol, Who knows, you might need more than one. Put the containerized dwarf tree(s) on one of those roll-around-caster-dealy-thingy-cannot-think-of-what-the-name-is-do-dad-mah-bobs, and it's easier to position it where and when needed, and then pull it back out of the way afterward. Really great job creating your container garden, gosh it's so pretty.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    taxonomist, sooth...excellent ideas...I have some container trees...just need some wheels on them now....

    legacy...thanx for the in-depth reasoning on this problem. You gave me a lot to consider. I have not taken the grit out entirly but have added a lot more MG, perlite and peat mix....mostly MG and perlite...the mix seems nicely loose but retains water. I hope it stays moist but watering is not a big problem...I just dont want to drown the plants or have a muddy mix where the PWT is soaking and rotting the roots. Will let you all know what happens ....its starting to get hot here....

    squibt

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    taxonomist, sooth...excellent ideas...I have some container trees...just need some wheels on them now....

    legacy...thanx for the in-depth reasoning on this problem. You gave me a lot to consider. I have not taken the grit out entirly but have added a lot more MG, perlite and peat mix....mostly MG and perlite...the mix seems nicely loose but retains water. I hope it stays moist but watering is not a big problem...I just dont want to drown the plants or have a muddy mix where the PWT is soaking and rotting the roots. Will let you all know what happens ....its starting to get hot here....

    squibt

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi squibt, you would know best and adjust base on what you know about the horticultural needs of a plant and the result(s) you observed from previous summer(s). Perlite is fool-proof and my friend. I would add perlite when in doubt. I add potting mix (peat-based) only if I had a hard time keeping up with watering in the past for water-loving plants or if pH is a major issue (for acid-loving plants). Then again, perlite will take care of most unexpected moisture and aeration problems created by mother nature (I can't possibly be guilty).

    I haven't started searching for comparative studies done on Turface and other inorganic soil amendments, but what do you guys think about the prices of perlite, hydroton, Turface MVP being offered here "Hummer International"
    or about this company? I may have to look up some conversion factors, but the price of perlite at least seems very economical. I'd be interested to know what you know.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Perlite seems reasonable...I paid $18.00 CA for 4 CbFt at a ShareCost animal/garden supply co. in Nanaimo

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Squibt,

    Patio looks very nice. Legacy is on the right track. I'd start with the soil you used in the past. Making it lighter will aggravate the watering thing. Within reason, you can made the soil heavier, but use care. Perlite is a must for aerifying.

    Adding the water storing gel products along with perlite is worth investigating.

    I notice that most of your containers aren't sitting in dishes. There will be some expense, but the fast dry out time you're citing will allow you to water and leave the plants sitting in full dishes. I've done this for years when needed, and it works really well for lengthening the time between waterings. Take care that the plants don't sit in water for more than a few hours, and not overnight.

    If you feed with anything, but especially fish emulsion and other things that stink good to dogs and cats, don't let your pets drink it.

    rangier

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanx rangier

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hello Squibt,
    Have you tried looking at your local aquatic plant store for the baked clay? That's the soiless product used for most pond plants because it doesn't cloud the water and goldfish don't eat it. Some of the brands I've seen have nice course edges and a medium grit, similar to decomposed granite in texture.

    On the fly, there are a lot of "home recipes" used by folks who specialize in bonsai, that would work well for what you're trying to do. If you know of any local bonsai specialists it wouldn't hurt to pay them a visit. That's what I did when I couldn't find "traditional ingredients" for older recipes and the local bonsai wizard helped me out with local alternative materials. I'm still looking for alternative substitutions for some of my "favorite" mixes after having moved from California to Missouri, but talking to locals has helped narrow things down considerably.

    Regards,
    Dan

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    poultryguy,

    Exellent ideas...I will follow up on them for sure.

    Thanx,

    squibT

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Good coir is hard to come by. 98% of the coir purchased in the US is obtained as by-product of the bruch and rope making industry in India and Sri Lanka. To make the fibers tough the husks are soaked in salt water. The salts are left in the coir dust that are packed and sold are alternative to peat. In the past there was no market for this waste and it sat in dump and got rained on. This leached the dust and made it a fine growing medium. However nowadays all the old dumps have been used up amd the new dust is not being given time to have the salt leached out before being shipped. So some product come with high ECs an low pHs.
    Pls go to my website at www.densuventures.com and click on the research tab.
    Let me know it I may be able of further help to you.
    Jake

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    .... he says shamelessly as he continues to post dozens of self-serving commercials all over GW.

    Al