Software
Houzz Logo Print
chlobell_gw

Compost

13 years ago

I have a raised bed that we built last fall and decided to compost in it until this spring. The compost is not fully decomposed. I was planning on doing a mix of 1/3 compost, 1/3 peat moss, and 1/3 vermiculite. Should I remove the not completely decomposed compost and let it finish "cooking" somewhere else or could I mix in more compost, peat moss, and vermiculite to what is already there. Thanks for the help!

Comments (13)

  • 13 years ago

    It's really up to you. Its hard to say,l really how decomposed the compost it.. If is almost decomposed add your amendments.. If its still steaming and is clearly not any where ready, shovel it out and let it finish.. Either way, I personally, would not use vermiculite.. It is expensive and basically inert.. That's more less used for container gardening.. You could use it no problem, though.. If it were me I would use good topsoil or some great finished compost and then mulch with leaves.. Can you post a picture of the unfinished compost in the raised bed?

    Joe

  • 13 years ago

    If you leave unfinished compost in the bed it will tie up nitrogen the plants need as it continues to decompose. For that reason it is generally recommended that unfinished compost be placed somewhere else.

    An alternative is to add a great deal of supplemental N to the bed to compensate. The only problem with that is that some crops may not tolerate the excess nitrogen.

    In case you didn't know there is a Soil & Compost forum here at GW and you'll find much more information related to your topic over on that forum.

    Dave

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the help. Hopefully a picture is attached. My hunch is that it's not composted enough to leave it in there. So if I take it out, you recommend a mix of compost and topsoil and then mulch with leaves?

  • 13 years ago

    That picture still doesnt do justice.. Just use your intuition.. If you think it looks rotted enough, use it.. If you can still see scraps of vegetable scraps and other plant matter not fully decomposed, dig it up and sit it aside.. Inuse a mix of compost and top soil from the woods.. Some use only compost.. Whatever you want to do.. Either way, I doubt your going to ruin your whole vegetable beds.. The uncomposted material will tie up some nitrogen, and you would have to fertilizer with let's say poultry manure, or something fairly high in nitrogen for your plants, but i doubt it's going to kill them or any major concern.. You know better than any of us whats in that compost, how decomposed it is, and your situation in general, use your intuition..

    Best of luck,
    Joe

  • 13 years ago

    Folks do the lasagna gardening all the time (some folks fill the bottom of their beds with sticks, straw, leaves, paper, grass clippings, etc.) and plant right on top. I'm trying that this year in one of my beds.

    From the fuzzy picture, i think you've got something that you can work with...especially if you don't mind adding fertilizer.

  • 13 years ago

    What kind of stuff went into the compost? That will probably affect the answer about whether you should use it. Is it leaves, kitchen scraps, lawn clippings, manure, or what?

  • 13 years ago

    It's composted enough from how it looks in the pic. You want some chunks, because they make long-lived life rafts for soil microbes.

    In spring compost waits for warm temps to finish. In a couple of weeks that stuff will look very different.

    Why peat moss? It has little to offer in this situation that compost can't do better. Both peat moss and vermiculite are non-nutritive amendments, but vermiculite sticks around for years while peat moss will be gone in one season in Z7a.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks everyone for all the advice and help. I am going to leave it in there. To answer a couple of questions:
    My compost has leaves, kitchen scraps, shredded newspaper, aged manure, etc.
    The peat moss, vermiculite and compost mix was a recommendation from a friend but I guess I will skip the vermiculite and peat moss.
    Should I just mix in topsoil and then leaf mulch on top? Should I do the mulch after my seedlings come up?
    Also as far as fertilizers go I've heard Jobe's is good. Any other recommendations?
    I really appreciate all the help. I will also check out the soil and compost forum.

  • 13 years ago

    Aged manure in your bed? Awesome. I'm feeling more confident about saying to go for it.

    Topsoil can mean almost anything, so its hard to say how ideal that might be, but adding compost & fertilizer and mulching will probably turn out just fine.

    Jobe's is such a big company that I'm sure they offer some good stuff. I'd suggest using some of their organic stuff simply because you're trying to create a healthy soil environment. Espoma also has some good stuff that is readily available (as are some other brands)

  • 13 years ago

    I'm not a compost purist or soil scientist, but I've used compost in raised beds for years in varying degrees of being finished. I shoehorn plants in pretty closely and like the results just fine. My seasons are long so everything breaks down completely over time. The soil has great tilth and fertility. If the plants show signs of needing a shot of N, just water in some fish emulsion. Generally the plants require little in the way of fertilizer.

  • 13 years ago

    The mix the OP is talking about is Mel's mix - the square foot gardening guy. It will do a very good job in a raised bed. Essentially, it's a container garden with an open bottom touching the soil for drainage.

    When I have compost that's not quite finished, I screen it through 3/8 inch hardware cloth screen. That takes out the bigger pieces and the fiberous stuff, and leaves me with nice organic matter. In the Mel's mix, the peat moss provides water holding and air space, the vermiculite provides water holding and lightness for good tilth, and the compost provides some nutrients, water holding, and it holds on to nutrients that can be accessed by roots.

    Don't let anyone tell you peat moss isn't good for amending soil. It's been the basis of the nursery industry for many decades, and those people don't do it if it doesn't work. To replace a bale of peat moss with compost, you need to start with a large pile of material, and then wait. A bale of peat is just a drive to the big box store away. Personally I have to ration my compost carefully, and I'd use it all up in a single raised bed if I was covering the entire surface with a few inches, as people usually advise.

    Unless you have a huge supply of compost, peat moss is the next best thing. And don't let people bully you out of using it.

  • 13 years ago

    The mix the OP is talking about is Mel's mix - the square foot gardening guy.

    Good point that I missed as the OP didn't mention Mel's Mix or Sq. Foot Gardening. But if that is the case then the Sq. Foot Gardening forum could be of the most help.

    It is my understanding that Mel's Mix calls for only finished compost so that one doesn't run into the nutrient binding problems. But since it is such a specialized approach to garden then that forum would know best.

    Dave

  • 13 years ago

    "Should I just mix in topsoil and then leaf mulch on top? Should I do the mulch after my seedlings come up? "

    You hit the nail on the head, right on! I would mix in some topsoil and mulch with leaves.. As far as fertilizer.. Compost/woodash is all I use.. Your going to have people tell you that you need a soil test, you're goon toruin your soil with woodash,etc.. I'm laughing because I been using it for a while.. Mans been using it ever since we made fire... If you are looking to purchase fertilizer - espoma biotone is my favorite, all espoma products are really good.. Fish emulsion,blood/bone meal, feather meal,alfalfa meal, and kelp meal is good... But becarful with the animal products(fish,blood,bone), the damn animals dug up my garden the first year i made that mistake! You could buy all those fertilizers and have great benefits, but they are expensive! A good compost should have everything a plant needs.. A prime example of this is Charles Wilber, man who grow world record tomatoes, the only thing he uses is his homade compost...

    Joe