Software
Houzz Logo Print
skeip

How crazy are people...

16 years ago

Last Sunday at the garden center there was a mature woman snatching up 4-cell packs of lettuce for $2.99each, like they were gold. Well, gardeners being a helpful bunch, I suggested that for the cost of a $2.99 pack of seed that she could have a lot more lettuce a lot cheaper than what she was paying for those cell packs. The look she gave me told me in no uncertain terms what she thought of my suggestion! I guess from now on I'll wait until asked.

Steve

Comments (48)

  • 16 years ago

    I saw that a store here was selling individual tomato plants for $3 each. I thought the exact same thing - I can get a $1 packet of 50+ seeds for that price. The other $2 would cover the electric usage to start them inside.

    Here is a link that might be useful: BsnTech Gardening Blog

  • 16 years ago

    Just to play devil's advocate...I think some people may not have the time, space or energy to start their own seedlings under lights. Or they forgot, or they moved into a new home (me last year),or etc. This year, I'm starting seedlings that are either not available at all (okra, mini eggplants) or not available at the right time (broccoli). They take up all the space under my lights. The rest I'll buy as transplants (tomatoes, peppers).

  • 16 years ago

    They probably didn't appreciate a stranger telling them they're doing things wrong. Likely taken as criticism even if not meant to be. And there's really nothing wrong with buying veg starts, even if it can be done cheaper.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree. I personally can't stand it to see people selling 4 packs of green beans or Sweet corn. Those are about the simplest things to grow. Put in ground, water and they will grow. Also, a four pack of beans will get you less than a pound of beans. Corn, maybe 4 ears if you are lucky.

    Squash and cucumbers are another questionable transplant. I can't say much because I just started some to sell. I will see how they work.

    Jay

  • 16 years ago

    A smart gardener with good soil would know how to make some money this time of year. Start a bunch of seeds, get a stand at a flea market, and get rich. If I had a green thumb I would do it, but I'm struggling as it is with my soil. Experimental year this year with composting.

    Next year if I get any better, I'll start some flower seedlings and sell them. We have a few nurseries here and they stay busy.

    I'll take my chances with a pack of seeds.

  • 16 years ago

    Many gardeners aren't willing to put time into anything...or work...or want to get dirty for more than a few moments in an entire growing season.

    A noticeable chunk of people buying cell packs at box stores either end up killing them, ignoring them, or not even planting them.

    I know so many people who think they want a garden, pick up some cells, throw them into the ground and promptly linger until they eventually die from lack of basic care.

    The people who buy tomatoes and don't know/understand/want to stake them up love to kill them some tomatoes, too.

  • 16 years ago

    You mean I could've purchased seeds?! So much for our instant gratification lifestyle! People have lost touch with what is fiscally prudent vs where does food come from? People want it all and they want it all right now. This is why I don't allow people in my garden. Just me and the bugs!

  • 16 years ago

    It's surprising to me how many gardeners consider direct seeding any vegetables something that only a very advanced gardener would attempt. I was brought up direct seeding everything but tomatoes. Since then I have found reasons to start certain things, even lettuce, in flats. But you will not catch me paying $2.99 for three lettuce seedlings.

    Steve, my attempts at helping people with their shopping yielded similar results. It just is not appreciated. LOL.

    Jim

  • 16 years ago

    Besides that, when lettuce is on sale you can get it for less than 99 cents a head usually, and that's already grown.

  • 16 years ago

    Hey, you did your part. Don't feel bad. All you can do is plant seeds..it is not up to us to make them sprout...in the ground or in people!

  • 16 years ago

    My first garden last yr I bought 10 tomato plants. That was my biggest expense. This yr I have 46 plants started from seed and they all look great as far as I can tell. Sounds like alot but I wanted to make sure some would grow. I bought a canner so I can can them. I also plan to share plants with others and tomatoes too. I only had to buy seed starting mix, soil and cups. I have lots of garden space and I am off work for the summer to do the tending. I think seed is cheap compared to cell packs. Not everyone has time/room to grow from seed though. My seedlings cover my dining room table for about 3 months. I have 300, give or take, assorted pepper plants. My boss, the neighbors, my sister and my daughter LOVE jalapeno peppers...so I am learning how to can them. Last yrs pepper seedlings didn't do much because I planted them from the soil I got outside in the yard(hard as a rock). I still got a dozen good plants though. Last night I repotted many of the tomatoes and I think they grew several inches over night. Isn't gardening fun! I wish everyone could grow something. Cheaper and healthier!!!

  • 16 years ago

    Canning rocks, my gma used to do that, she also used to make her own grape jelly. I am going to make pickles when they start to come in! Kids dig it!

  • 16 years ago

    This is my very first year gardening and I am starting off from seed. I just figured that was how it was done! I consider cell packs a "back up plan"

  • 16 years ago

    Maybe I'm crazy, but i'm not worried about blowing 5 or 10 dollars. I don't have room to plant a packet of Lettuce seeds. 2 or 3 plant packs for $2 each is all I need, and I can plant multiple varieties in small amounts. Variety instead of mass quantity. Plus I also think that planting Lettuce plants in early to mid April produces very good quality Lettuce to eat mid May to late May. Direct planted Lettuce may not get big enough before the summer heat ruins the taste.

    I want to get maximum productivity from plants, I value my time and garden space more than a few dollars I waste.

    But I do have to admit they are selling a bunch of highly questionable plants to gullible people. Lowe's sells single plants of Broccoli and Cauliflower for like $2.99. They are in a small pot, but there is really no actual advantage over the 9 pack cells they sell for the same price.

    And as said, green beans!!! and corn!!! ...? These plants will be highly stressed being transplanted into cold spring soil, and nobody really would plant those except in large groups... it doesn't make sense on any level.

    I would agree that there really is no advantage planting Zuccinni or Cucumber, but if you only had room for one planting, the cost will be about the same, plants or seeds.

    What about people thinking they are buying "Green Peppers" and "Red Peppers", that they are different plants?

  • 16 years ago

    this is my first year gardening, m doing all container due to lack of space and not enough sun in the right places. My deck is my garden. Anyway, i jsut planted seeds in pots. The only plant I bought was a banana pepper. My mother said to buy tomatos (yuck) and peppers as plants. I have no idea if thats true. I only wanted one pepper plant since this year is a year to learn, to see what works and what doesnt (and im the only one who eats them). But, everything else is seeds-lettuce, carrots, peas, watermelon, pumpkin, squash. I get so excited when I see that little bit of green stick out of the soil. Growing from seeds is definately more gratifying.

  • 16 years ago

    If you are a serious cheapskate like me, you will soon reach the next level of cheapness beyond growing from seed. Which is letting some of your crop self-seed each year. I do that with lettuce, aurugula, scorzonera, tatsoi, salsify, etc. You just have to keep the weeds under control. The plants don't arrange themselves into beautiful patterns, so forget about this if you're a neat freak.

    I'm in SW Washington state with fairly mild winters. I don't know if this would work elsewhere.

  • 16 years ago

    I get the instant gratification point, but it's also what you know, as in normal, I started gardening last year and even thoug I have seen starter plant, My Dad and Pop always grow from seed and it never occurred to me to not start from seed, to me normal, that said did buy most of my Herb's as transplants, the hardies, Basil, cilantro from seeds, staggering the planting, but it is hard work and I can have sympathy with buying, and then not as if you are paying that much money, might as well hold off and buy the plants in the grocery isle fully grown?

  • 16 years ago

    That is way too much to pay. But I ended up buying starts of lots of things since I decided to direct seed my stuff and it is doing nothing. I really wanted to start harvesting from the garden as soon as possible so I bought cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, and lettuce transplant but I got it from this place that is supposed to be the biggest place in the state and they had really good prices - 12 plants $3. I also bought pepper and tomato starts because I can get such good variety because only a few of the tomatoes and peppers did I get more than two of. This is my first year gardening and I am learning lots already!

    Next year hopefully I can get me some lights and a low tunnel/high tunnel/row cover going and buy very few transplants.

  • 16 years ago

    I think you have a point. There are folks who just buy plants all the time. They never, never start from seed. When I started gardening years, and years, and years ago we could buy bare root bunches of cabbage plants, sweet potato plants, onions and such as that. Back then nobody and I mean NObody sold lettuce transplants around here.

    You did your duty as a concerned citizen. I did my duty at Lowe's yesterday. A man and woman were talking about getting a different type tomato plant this year. Last year they were telling each other their tomato plants (only 2) grew beautifully but they got absolutely NOT ONE tomato. I found this hard to understand so being a busy bee I asked them a few questions. What type did you grow last year - Better Boy. What type fertilizer did you use - none at all just the MiracleGro potting SOIL because it already has fertilizer in it. I explained at some length that the MG does not have enough fert to grow tomatoes and showed them the back of a nearby MG bag which clearly states to add fertilizer to your plants ON THE BACK OF THE BAG! They looked at me like I was from the planet pluto (I have big ears)!! I then asked if they had the plants in the sun and they said - no under the tree in our back yard. I said -very gently- tomatoes need 6-8 hours of sun a day in most places. They calmly told me they had only that place to grow their garden and their lettuce and chard did just fine. I gave up and wished them a great garden year.

    Ah well..............

    DL

  • 16 years ago

    lilydude - I want to learn to do that, I wonder if you would get better seeds. Most of the seeds I bought this year didn't germinate.

  • 16 years ago

    You don't even need to figure the cost of grow-lights, because they aren't necessary for merely getting 2-3 week jump on the season. A cold frame does that, or a window sill for something like lettuce that will germinate at relatively cool soil temp.

  • 16 years ago

    Please remember this! Direct seeding does not work in a lasagna garden. To plant like that...you will have to pull back all the mulch and plant on more bare soil. When the seeds germinate you can gradually pull the mulch closer to the plants. @@@@@@@@@@

  • 16 years ago

    I direct seeded lettuce this year but like noki said, if I'd planted store bought seedlings at the same time I'd have much bigger lettuce right now. As it is they're still tiny seedlings and I'll have to pull a lot of them out before I get any harvest to make room for my tomatoes and peppers next week.

    I also bought all my tomatoes and peppers plants from a nursery. I look at the value like this -

    cost of seeds + (approx hours over several months it takes to setup grow op, plant seeds, turn lights and fans on and off, water, transplant to bigger pots, take them inside & outside to harden off X amount I get paid per hour) = bundle saved.

    In other words, not having to worry about nurturing seedlings for weeks and weeks when I have a million other things to do is worth it to me.

    That doesn't mean I don't know enough to put them in full sun, or that I don't put a lot of love into my garden all season. (I do!) It just works better for me to buy some plants.

    And sure the tomatoes cost $3 each, but considering I won't buy any tomatoes all summer from the grocery store, I'll make my investment back over and over. For the 6 plants I bought that's $18. It costs more for me and my husband to go to the movies on a Friday night. So no big whoop there as far as I am concerned.

  • 16 years ago

    I myself do a mix- some from seed, some from transplants I get at the greenhouse. The stuff that's easy to do directly sowing from seed, I do. Peas, carrots, radishes, lettuce, spinach, zucchini, some herbs- all that comes from seeds. But since I don't have the space or the set up to sow from seed early on in pots and then plant out, I let the experts with the means do that. (And yes, I've tried it, but it's not for me.) My tomatoes, eggplants and peppers, plus some herbs, will come from my local greenhouse as seedlings. Sure it's a bit more expensive, but it's worth it to me to not have to deal with growing lights and pots everywhere at the mercy of my cat. Plus, this year I expanded my garden quite a bit, but didn't know I was going to go as far as I did until a couple weeks ago. There simply wasn't time (or space!) to start all the things I'm growing this year. Next year I will probably do a few more seeds than this year, but I love my local greenhouse's variety and I like supporting a local business. Not to mention the fact that with only my husband and I around to eat the veggies, I only need a plant or two of each thing, so instead of planting seeds and thinning, I just buy what I need and don't have to hang on to packs of seeds for years.

    All this is just to say, not everyone who buys seedlings is a gardening idiot/newbie and we all have our reasons. Sure, there are plenty out there who don't understand that plants come from seeds and that they can do it themselves, but there are plenty more who not only get it, but DO it, and supplement with seedlings. I'm heading to the greenhouse this afternoon, and I can't wait to see what kind of marvelous things there are to try this year. :-)

  • 16 years ago

    Another thing to remember is that everyone is on their path as a gardener. some people will buy a few starts and that's it - they won't do more.

    Another person may buy lettuce starts even, but start in with reading, boards, and progress to being a market gardener over time.

    You can only start where you are. You only increase your knowledge and skills if you try to do more.

    To each their own in other words. A lettuce start today may grow into a retired/ second career farmer a few decades down the road, or someone who prefers to buy their lettuce at the market...could go either way...

  • 16 years ago

    Yeah, don't judge...

    I do grow certain things from seed. But, I have planting areas that won't get seeds to healthy plants, but will grow up a robust transplant--area that don't get quite enough sun. So I do multiple things to get multiple results.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with everything everyone has said here. I don't know that woman's background, or living/gardening situation, or her health concerns or economic status. She simply needed to be gracious, say thank you and ignore me from there on.

    That being said, I will be back at the GC this weekend buying cell packs of Brussels Sprouts, Eggplants and Jalapeno Peppers. I prefer to use my limited light space for heirloom tomato seed that I have saved, and unusual peppers, etc that I can't get at the GC.

    By way of confession, I did start Lettuces and Bok Choi in cell packs. My thought is that I can then pop in one cell at the propper spacing and grow them on that way. I invariably miss that "thinning window" and everything gets too crowded to do well. I will also be creating my own seed tapes with paper towels and Beet seed so I have the proper spacing there.

    Happy gardening to us all!

    Steve

  • 16 years ago

    If you think that's bad, tell them they don't water correctly. I tried teaching a gardener that this year. I think he hates me now. I pity his beaten plants and soil.

  • 16 years ago

    "That being said, I will be back at the GC this weekend buying cell packs of Brussels Sprouts, Eggplants and Jalapeno Peppers. I prefer to use my limited light space for heirloom tomato seed that I have saved, and unusual peppers, etc that I can't get at the GC. "

    o o
    0

  • 16 years ago

    "By way of confession, I did start Lettuces and Bok Choi in cell packs. My thought is that I can then pop in one cell at the propper spacing and grow them on that way. I invariably miss that "thinning window" and everything gets too crowded to do well. I will also be creating my own seed tapes with paper towels and Beet seed so I have the proper spacing there. "

    next year for me I'm afraid!

  • 16 years ago

    I can see window shopping at a nursery, you can get plants you never heard of, just one to try them out, save the seed if you liked them. I like the money I'm saving from seeds and will try them first before anything.

    I can't see paying 3 dollars for one broccoli or what ever it was transplant. I put out my seed too early, so the things I'm having problems with, I probably deserve. My spinach of all things does not like my soil, third year, now I have at least sprouts from seeds started off in a pot next to the garden.

    My strawberry seeds did not do well, have another pack to try, but a reminder is this, I paid 5 dollars counting shipping and handling for these seeds from Czechoslovakia, an ever bearing variety. You have the world at your feet if you are good with seeds. I may have to buy strawberries because second year of trying seeds, no strawberries still. Wait until May 15th when the last pack goes out, see if any comes out of it, by June no strawberries, to the nursery I go.

  • 16 years ago

    I was there, buying tomatoes, peppers, kale, and violas. I know it would be cheaper to grow my own, and I usually do. Other things I will plant from seed (the peas and carrots are already in).

    You see, my mother died in late January, and I have been in a fog ever since. Very few of my winter and sping plantings got done (I do have sweet potato slips, and I already planted my Irish potatoes, but that is about it). At this point, there is no time to start my transplants. So I bought them.

    I'm sorry, I'll try to do better next time.

    Catherine

  • 16 years ago

    I work part time at a family owned garden center. I feel like a crook selling single lettuce plants, single cabbages/broccoli/cauliflower, and curcurbits for $2 or more. People buy lots of them and want them so we keep bringing it in. I don't understand.

    I can see not wanting to start tomatoes, peppers, eggplant because of the time investment in it.

  • 16 years ago

    I think the post about paying more for a start than you can buy the product for in grocery stores is a good point - zuke - sure - easy to start, but if you buy - you get to have a lot of fruit - worth the $2.

    head of lettuce or broccoli - not so much...

  • 16 years ago

    Catherine, goodness, no need to apoligize! We all do what we're able to do :) When I had no time or knowledge, or the summer I had pneumonia (yuck), I bought plants. Now that I have more time and knowledge, I grow from seed. I think the comments here are about people (esp rude people) who have no desire to learn and even then, it's still their choice.

    (((HUGS))) Take care of yourself!

    Leisa

  • 16 years ago

    I just bought 2 tomato plants even though I am growing 47 beefsteaks from seed. Reason why is that we live in the mountains in zone 5 and an hour from town. Cool nights. Last yr most of our toms ripened indoors. We wanted earlier toms this yr while waiting for the beefs. One store had them for 4 bucks and Walmart had the same ones for 3. People were buying pepper plants with tiny peppers...aww...we wont be having those for months.....but last yr I had sooo much fun watching them grow...worth the wait!

  • 16 years ago

    Everyone has to start somewhere and some people have more money than time.

  • 16 years ago

    There are reasons for everything - although I agree that there is no way I would buy starts for corn, beans, lettuce or squash. I get squash popping out of the compost pile without even trying!

    On the other hand, I totally understand the motivation for purchasing tomatoes, peppers, eggplants, and some other things. Last year I spent $1.38 for a 4-pack of red cabbage, and canned a half-dozen pints of beautiful sauerkraut at the end of the season. This spring I'm starting almost everything from seed - I will have 16 tomato plants in the garden, so I could have purchased those as individual plants for $48. Given the amount of time I've spent on those plants, not to mention starting soil, potting soil, cups, electricity, seeds, etc. if I was getting paid at my hourly wage - those plants would probably be more like $10 apiece! However, it's something I enjoy - seeing those little green leaves unfurl when it's still cold and wintery outside, plus I get to raise the exact varieties I want, and try to best last year's "first tomato" date. That doesn't mean I won't go buy one of those big plants already blooming in a gallon pot to get an even earlier tomato, but I know it won't be as delicious as the ones I nurtured from a tiny seed.

  • 16 years ago

    Guilty here. Despite my starting a few dozen veggie from seeds, I still bought a few tomato, pepper, eggplant seedlings at the stores. Couldn't help it. I'm like a kid at Christmas when going to the store in the Spring, got to buy some seedlings to be festive. Plus my pepper seeds always go two months slower than store bought (don't have heat lamp). But I was really surprised seeing some veggie seedlings for $4 a small pot. Shouldn't people get 24 seedlings for that money? I must be getting too old.

    But what's really crazy is this... while I pay for the 6 pack of veggie seedlings at the store, I've been pulling out healthy tomato volunteers from my bed everyday. I just can't be sure with all that vining and mixed planting. Now that's really crazy!

  • 16 years ago

    I admit that I do buy certain seedling in cell packs but not lettuce, corn, arugula, etc.
    Just this year I bought an 8 pack of RUTGERS tomato seedling for $2.99, that is 37 cents per plant. They are now flowering.
    I also bough some pimento peppers in similar fashion.
    O'! And my biggest per plant spending so far has bee $3.00 for a tomatillo plant
    which had blooms on it at the time . And now has one tiny fruit and many blooms.
    cyrus

  • 16 years ago

    Transplants are wonderful! There is absolutely nothing wrong with buying packs of plants. This year I started almost everything from seed, except for a few extra pepper and tomato plants purchased from the Farmer's Market for only $1.50 a 4-pack. The plants were very healthy, and already of good size. Can't beat that!

    I am a container condo gardener with very limited space. I traditionally start from seed, but next year may purchase even more pepper and tomato transplants. They save ALOT of time, with regard to starting from seed and babying the seedlings, plus I can start harvesting 1-2 months earlier. Each person learns methods that work best for his/her own situation. To each their own!

  • 16 years ago

    I am a third year gardener, and most of my plants are starts I buy from the annual plant sale at a local farmers market. The starts are very, very cheap, and I am supporting local farms. For instance, I get 4 tomato plants for only $2 total. Herbs are maybe $1 each. I know that seeds are cheaper, but I don't mind saving myself some time and room by buying starts of plants like tomatoes. I do start some things from seed, green beans, cucumbers, lettuce, carrots, peas, etc. However, I am quite horrified at some of the prices at the stores like Lowes and some of the garden centers.

  • 16 years ago

    I can buy single varieties of Peppers, and give them a try and have variety. Maybe not cost effective, but a lot more interesting and fun than having 10 Pepper plants all the same.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm a relatively new gardener but my family always gardened so I feel comfortable with growing things from seed. It seems a bit like highway robbery selling three lettuce starts for $2 or $3 but that's the nature of capitalism. In the same way I could never imagine wanting to drive a Hummer but people still drive those gas guzzling monstrosities! (Sorry for any of you gardening slash Hummer drivers who might be reading.) Eh, the nice thing about people is we're all different and what some of us find second nature others see as a God given talent. At the end of the day it's just nice to see people GROWING things, even if they don't do it right. ;) Besides, what would we rant about if everyone did what we thought they should?

  • 16 years ago

    Capitalism at it's best. That's why nurseries sell 4-packs of lettuce for 2.99...cuz (insert your choice of adjective here) people will buy them.

  • 16 years ago

    There's the "approach" aspect of this, too.
    When you are trying to teach someone something, or explain that there is a better way, always avoid using the word "you" at all costs. People don't like other people telling them what to do. However, if you said the same thing in a different way...

    "Starting lettuce from seed is WAY less expensive than buying starts" implies that "YOU shouldn't be buying them." and gets you a negative response.

    Whereas...

    "Gee, these lettuce starts seem rather high. I like to start most things from seed, but find that I do have to buy certain plant starts from the greenhouse. What kind of garden do you have?" ...implies nothing but in a round-about kinda way, they might consider starting from seed, but really moreso says "I'd like your opinion on the whole gardening thing." and will likely elicit a constructive conversation on gardening.

    People love to offer their opinions & experiences, but do NOT like to be told that they are doing it wrong.

  • 16 years ago

    Exactly, mmqchdygg. If somebody came up to me in a store saying that I could have more of this-or-that plant cheaper by purchasing in this-or-that form...I would take their advice politely, but I would definitely think the person is a bit pushy, and should mind his or her own business...LOL. So it always helps to consider how you would like to be approached, and spoken to, and treated, in all situations in life. :-)

  • 16 years ago

    Last year I started tomatoes, peppers and melon in a sunny window in February. It's a bit of work to keep them alive for three months. I planted them after the frost date and tried to protect them with hot-caps made of milk jugs.

    They got frost-bit anyway and struggled. Seeing them struggle, I bought some plants from Lowes. The store-bought plants were planted well after the frost date and they simply grew.

    Lessons learned; yes you might save a few bucks by starting your own, but if you're as busy as I am, store-bought has its virtues. And, I live in a cold micro-climate. Don't even bother to plant until two weeks after the 'last frost date'.

    Good luck to all.