Software
Houzz Logo Print
yellowthumb

Al, please help with Ca/Mg fertilization

16 years ago

Al, I hope you don't mind I ask another couple questions regarding the Ca and Mg fertilization. I am sure those kind of questions have been asked in the past, but I am having a hard time unifying them together.

Thank you for your kind help regarding the 5-1-1 variation. I basically redesigned the 5-1-1 a bit to make it a 5-1-1-1-1. Besides the regular 511, I added another part of turface MVP and Grit. How much dolomite lime you think I should add, instead of 1tbsp per gallon, I am thinking 2 tsp of dolomite lime plus 1 tsp of gypsum. Lime is to raise the PH a bit but the gypsum to supply extra Ca and S. Am I going too far?

How soluble is dolomite lime in water? How much will it affect the water EC? I am asking because I found out that when I put a pinch of dolomite into a liter of water, the EC becomes very high. I suspect my dolomite has salt or something I don't know.

Thank you for your time.

YT

Comments (14)

  • 16 years ago

    What you suggested sounds very reasonable & along the lines of something like I would do if I was making the soil you described.

    The solubility of dolomite is pH and temperature driven, but the Ca fraction is usually not very soluble in water at all. The Mg fraction is much more soluble than the Ca - about 125X more soluble, which is why you usually don't need to supplement Mg in long term plantings with soils using dolomite as the liming agent in the first year, but you often/usually DO, in the second and consecutive years.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Al. That could explain why I am having a high EC reading. The Mg fraction might be the culprit.

    If I want to supplement the Ca and Mg in the 2nd and 3rd year. What are my options? I read in your previous post that I can use 1/4 tsp of Epsom salt per gallon for each watering. What should I use for the Ca supplement. Can I just top dressing with gypsum? I got the impression that even I am using FP, if I don't do a repot very often, it's still a good practice to supplement extra Ca/Mg. Is that correct?

    Thanks

    YT

  • 16 years ago

    As I think about the question, I realize that almost everything I put in the 5:1:1 mix is in it for 1 growth cycle, so I don't think about the Ca/Mg needs. I would probably only supplement Mg in the second year, and not the Ca. In part, that's because I'm using FP.

    I can say that I've never noticed a Ca deficiency in anything I've let go 2 years in the 5:1:1 mix using lime, and a Ca deficiency is pretty easy to spot, even when there are no fruits involved to show BER as a tattle.

    I've also never noticed a Ca deficiency when using gypsum in the gritty mix for up to 3 years, but I do regularly add the Epsom salts every time I fertilize. I don't, but if you're worried, I would only broadcast something like a tsp of gypsum/gallon of soil (on top of the gritty mix) in years subsequent to the first and just continue with the Epsom salts as usual.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Al for your kind help.

    What are the symptoms of Ca deficiency in most of tropical plants? I have had some new growth on Citrus that is kind of cup upward. Not sure that's related to Ca. But when the summer kicked in, it fixed by itself. BTW, I am using FP.

    YT

  • 16 years ago

    I look first for distortion of the new foliage - cupping, strap-like leaves, general malformations, also varying patterns of chlorosis in new leaves only, but especially on leaf margins just behind the leaf tip, and sometimes blackened leaf tips, along with stalled or slowed growth when the plant SHOULD be growing robustly.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Al,

    I am wondering what strap-like leaves look like. I have had some new growth that is cupped upward. But when the summer arrived, it fixed itself. I am thinking it could be because of other environmental factors, the weather sometimes is the most deciding factor.

    BTW, I am so fed up with my Hanna PH/EC meter. Yesterday, I did a PH test on my new potted up citrus which is the 5:1:1 with 1 part of Turface and Grower Grit. The PH reading is 7.18. How come. It should be between 6 to 6.5. But the meter is right. It reads tap water at 8.1, which is very reasonable. I understand Turface is made of clay and should be neutral. But would grower's grit alter the PH? What the grit made of?

    Thanks
    YT

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Al,

    Now I am concerned about my Chicken Grower Grit. I could be made of different ingredients than the granite. Sometimes it's made of limestone or regular stones. It's the limestone that concerns me. I just called the feed store that I bought from. He told me that he is not very sure what it made of, but it could be limestone. But I doubt him though, since the grit I have is very hard and looks shiny. Not like limestone. If it's made of limestone, then it explains why I am having a high PH reading. I will be pissed.

    YT

  • 16 years ago

    Copy paste to your browser for a pic of strap-like deformity:
    http://www.greenhousegrower.com/articles/image/Pest%20ID%20Guide/Deformities/deformed_stunted_9.jpg

    Grower grit, at least the Gran-I-Grit I use, is mildly acidic, just under 7.0. Turface comes in at around 6.2.

    (a copy/paste job)
    Granite is primarily composed of feldspar, quartz along with various other minerals in varying percentage,which are stated as follows:

    Nominal chemical composition of various oxides
    Silica(SiO2) ---------------------- 70-77%
    Alumina(Al2O3) ----------------- 11- 14%
    Potassium Oxide(P2O5) --------- 3 Â 5%
    Soda(Na2O) ------------------------ 3 Â 5%
    Lime ----------------------------------- 1%
    Iron(Fe2O3) -------------------------- 1-2%
    Iron(FeO) ----------------------------- 1 Â 3%
    Magnesia(Mg0) ------------------------- .5 Â 1%
    Titina ---------------------------------- Less than 1%(.38%)
    Water(H2O) --------------------------- 0.03%

    I hope you get the limestone/grit thing settled. Doesn't it mention on the bag what the contents are? - seems like it should. I'd call the packager to find out, if the feed store guy can't help.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Al,

    Maybe that could explain why I am not able to get the optimal effects I have for some acid loving plants.

    What are the consequences of using so much limestone in a container medium? It will raise the Ph to 7 to 7.5. Good for lots of plants, but not ideal for most tropical plants.

  • 16 years ago

    You said yourself that it has significant buffering capacity - so not good. Remember too, that the preferred range for container media is about a full point lower than garden/mineral soils, so 5.5 is preferred to 6.5.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    I am wondering about the 5.5 thing. Isn't a bit on the strong acid side? Most of commerical soil is 6.5 actually. Gardenia would prefer that range. For the majority, slightly acid is preferred. To me, slight acid means from 6 to 6.5.

  • 16 years ago

    At some point, I'm guessing you'll probably want to realign your thinking on the pH issue. Here's an excerpt from a NC State site that also concurs with Dr. Whitcomb's findings re. preferred pH ranges of various soil types:

    "Soils are placed into three classes, based on the amount of organic matter that is present - mineral, mineral- organic, and organic. Soils that have more organic matter tend to have lower aluminum content. Thus, for most plants, a lower pH level can be allowed. Mineral soils contain more aluminum, therefore, a higher pH is recommended to avoid aluminum toxicity. For most plants, the desired pH level in a mineral soil is 6.0, 5.5 for a mineral-organic soil, and 5.0 for organic soils.

    Some crops have specific pH requirements that are also taken into account when determining desired pH."

    You can read the full text, which happens to be about liming, anyway, so you may find it of some value. What I hope you take away from it in the end, is that you can grow robust plants in containers when using soils with a considerable organic component at much lower pH levels than you could when growing in mineral soils.

    I KNOW I wrote a thorough explanation about that somewhere, but I can't find it. I'll keep looking ........ probably buried in one of the long soil threads. :-(

    Al

    Here is a link that might be useful: Full text if you click me

  • 16 years ago

    To me, the 5:1:1 would be the organic soil, and the gritty mix is kind of mineral-organic. Actually to get the ph 5, you probably can't lime too much. I remember I did a test on a un-limed 5:1:1 mix water with rain water, the ph value is in 5.0.x range. If we put one tbsp of dolomite lime per gallon, I am wondering the ph range would be. There are too many factors in play. I think I would never be able to achieve the optimal range.

  • 16 years ago

    Manna Pro Poultry Grit DOES list the makeup of the contents... it's insoluble crushed granite. That's what the bag I use says.

    Quite a while ago, I bought a water/light/ph meter for around 24 dollars... I originally wanted it to help with moisture, but I noticed that the readings were squirrely... I abandoned using it to test for anything. I really don't think they're that accurate.

    If it didn't give me accurate moisture readings, I would doubt its accuracy in ph readings.

    I would go by the ingredients listing on the bags I buy for mixing my medium. So far, the pine bark is 100% fir bark, the granite is insoluble crushed granite, and the perlite is... well, perlite. That's all I use in my medium.