Software
Houzz Logo Print
yellowthumb

Is this a good gritty mix?

16 years ago

Hi,

Merry Christmas to everyone.

I am bothered by my discoveries on my grit. It's probably limestone. All the gritty mix I made from this limestone having a PH value of 7.18. It's on the sweet side.

It is unlikely that I am able to find a substitute of granite grit. I am thinking 1:1:1 of pine bark, turface MVP and Perlite. What do you guys think this mix? I combed through all the previous post, it seems that I can't find this combination.

I discovered another easy way to check your soil is acid or not. You water it first, let it drain for a couple of hours, then scratch it slightly, smell it, if it smells earthy sweet, then it's alkaline. If it smells acid, then it's acid. My Ph meter confirmed this at least on all my soils. Some containers have a PH of 4.5, it smells very acid, actually a bit aggressive.

Thanks

YT

Comments (13)

  • 16 years ago

    I'm pretty sure several people have reported using perlite instead of granite with OK results.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    I use Perlite in my mixes, and Pumice instead of Turface. I do have sharp Quartz gravel available, though, so I include it to add weight to my containers (as well as stability and drainage).

    If you screen the Perlite as you would any other component of the gritty mix, you shouldn't have any problems.

    Josh

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Al, I appreciate your help during Christmas time.

    Here is the picture of my grit, could you have a look?

    http://www.pestell.com/mineralselect.php?id=74

    Thanks

    YT

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Josh,

    Yes, I like the weight of the gritty mix too. Not for wheel barrel though. I have a lot less blown over problems this year for all my gritty mix plants. It can get pretty windy here especially at Spring time. I do have to use many bricks to stack the containers with 5:1:1 mix.

  • 16 years ago

    YT,

    I was following your posts about limestone/pH issues with your "granite" -- what bad luck. Thank you for continuing to post about it and help educate others.

    Do you mind expounding a bit on the "sweet" alkaline vs. acidic smells you're associating with the pH?

    I think I understand the earthly sweet you're referring to: my fresh, completed compost is light and airy and smells like some quality container soils -- which I guess I'd call earthly sweet (though I don't know what elements emit that scent). Is that how you associate it?

    How about the acidic aggressive side? Examples?

    TIA,
    Chris

  • 16 years ago

    I too have used perlite instead of granite when I ran out.

    I have not had any issues that are detremental to my plants just yet..

    I much more prefer the granite though, do to that fact that is doesn't break apart into smaller pieces, seems to retain a bit more moisture for my plant needs, and acts as an anchor for my root systems..

    The moisture is held on to the granite and surrrounding area, which stills allows for good air spaces and pourosity.
    The moisture held in my soil from perlite is because of it's breakage into smaller particles overtime, keeping the entire pot moist longer than I prefer, eventually filling in valuable air spaces.
    Therfore the need to screen your perlite before you even use it...

    Mike

  • 16 years ago

    Merry Christmas, Mike

    I just repotted a couple of plants using perlite instead of granite. Yes, I much prefer the granite. The perlite is just so light, even soaked in water, it is still light. I can imagine that my pots being blown away by the wind. But on the other hand, it drains at least as well.

    On a positive side, I might be able to locate the crushed quartz. To me the crushed quartz is better, since it's just SiO4, so stable in nature, and will not release Al into the mix.

  • 16 years ago

    LOLOL

    You wouldn't want to release Al into the mix.....

    What is crushed quartz....? I never seen the stuff..Can you post a pic of what it looks like..

    Hope you are doing good yellowthumb! I got your e-mail, am I greatful for the info...Thankyou...I am actually calling the place tommorrow for an olive tree.:-)

    Mike..:-)

  • 16 years ago

    Yellowthumb, glad you wrote about this. It made me wonder if this might be the problem with my African Violets in the gritty mix.

    Turns out I do have granite, so that wasn't my problem.

    But my water is about 7.8; when I water my soilmix and test it, the pH is about 7.3. That's too high for somewhat acid loving AVs. I thought I'd tried to kill only 3 plants, but last night I looked through my spreadsheet; I've put 5 AVs, different varieties, some with small roots systems, and some with large ones, into gritty mix. Every one of them declined after about a week. Some were bottom watered, some were top watered; no difference. The last one was top watered ONLY when a wood skewer indicated the mix was dry.

    When the first one declined, I screened the mix, thinking that maybe I hadn't done enough to make the mix uniform and had too much small stuff. No difference.

    Next, I thought it was just too wet because of the oildri. So, I amended the mix, one time adding an additional part of perlite, once reducing the amount of oildri. Plants still declined.

    Then I thought is was the bottom watering, so I went to top watering. Then I thought the delicate AV roots might not take being wet as long as the mix stayed wet, so I watered it very slightly from the top. No difference. I just removed the 5th plant from that mix. It started with 12 leaves and is down to 3.

    It has to be something! This thread is helping me focus on pH. When I use a peat based mix, the pH is about 6.3 to 6.5 with my water. That's fine, so they are happy. But, the gritty mix is much closer to neutral.

    I don't have a plant to try to kill at the moment, so no testing for awhile. When I do, I'll try the mix with water that is about 6.0 pH and see what happens.

  • 16 years ago

    I don't have a plant to try to kill at the moment, so no testing for awhile. When I do, I'll try the mix with water that is about 6.0 pH and see what happens.

    Vinegar is your friend ;)

  • 16 years ago

    I will second that!!!!

    Next to Al, vinegar is my plants best friend..

    Mike

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Mike, I mean Aluminum, sorry Al, I won't release you into the mix. Al's mix is first commercialized in Canada as a general purpose bonsai soil, it's in a 4L bag. Will have to sell my house if I want to repot everything into this mix.

    JaG, Yes, vinegar is our best friend if high alkalinity water. I put about one tsp per gallon, it brings down the pH to about 5.

    pH is often overlooked, but it's so critical with acid loving plants. When bare root plants transplanted into the new mix with wrong pH value, the old roots will simply be stunned, not dying immediately, but turning into brownish white, no new root growth observed even the mix is perfectly aerated. It's going to be a slow decline, losing leaves slowly. When transplanting with old soil into a new mix with wrong pH, the plant will live for a long time, but when you pull the plant up, you will see no new roots will grow into the new soil even the new soil is perfectly aerated.

    The gritty mix doesn't have as much buffer as 5:1:1 in terms of pH fluctuation. Peat is a good buffer. So if we are not careful with the water we use, the pH can rise to above 7 easily. To me, it's a good practice to use rain water or snow water, otherwise, use vinegar.

  • 16 years ago

    Yeah, I was using vinegar before, but the AVs seemed to be fine without it, so I stopped. The first plant I had in the gritty seemed to do OK initially. It may have been the time when I was adding the vinegar, but I'm not sure.

    I only need about a 1/4 t to a gallon to get it to the low 6 range, which I imagine will be fine.