Software
Houzz Logo Print
alabamanicole

Choosing and planning fruit selections

19 years ago

I am in the planning stages of my new property. The more I research fruit, the more disappointed I get. I have a lovely, mostly open 4 acres with moderately well drained soil and I would LOVE to fill it up with fruit and nut trees: ones I will eat; enough for me to eat fresh and put up, plus enough to share. Perfect, blemish free fruits not required and not expected.

However, I am very sensitive to chemicals of many kinds, and so spraying is not an option for me. I'm sensitive enough that I realistically don't even want it on my property, otherwise I would consider hiring out the job.

I'm happy to work at other sorts of control (bird netting, varmint trapping, attracting predators and beneficial insects, etc) within the limits of what one person with a full time job can reasonably handle by herself.

I dream of apples and peaches, yet it sounds as though no one recommends attempting them without spraying. We had many fruit trees as a kid and we had very good yields without spraying -- but me, my brother and the dog were on duty all summer with pellet guns to handle the squirrels. Plus lidded containers with kerosene to trap and kill the hordes of Japanese beetles. I'm a mean shot, but I can't sit on the back porch with a gun all day!

Assuming appropriate varieties are selected, if you were to choose the fruits (and nuts) which are more likely to perform well without spraying, which would you choose?

My wish list, but feel free to ignore it and suggest other items:

Walnuts, English

Pecans

Hazelnuts

Apples

Peaches

Cherries

Paw Paw

Elderberries

Hardy kiwi

grapes

blueberries

blackberries

raspberries

strawberries

Comments (10)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I grow Triple Crown Thornless blackberries, and get loads of fruit with no spraying. Japanese beetles are pretty bad around here (Lehigh Valley of Pennsylvania) and the blackberry plant gets some damage, but not much.

    Same is true for elderberries.

    I have planted Paw Paws largely because they are supposed to be trouble free. In two seasons, I have seen no pest or disease problems, but my trees are young, and have not produced fruit yet.

    My raspberries are Japanese beetle magnets, but they still produce. Not nearly so much as the Triple Crown blackberry. With 4 acres, I'd give raspberries a try, especially since the plants are pretty inexpensive.

    I plan on planting Hardy Kiwi this spring or next, and from what I have been able to find out, they are super productive and easy to grow without spraying.

    My bueberries get sporadic Japanese beetle damage, but not bad. They are young, and so far the birds have gotten most of the fruit. I need some kind of netting set up.

    Pears have far fewer problems than apples, especially Asian pears. Fireblight is the biggest problem I believe, but there are some resistant varieties. I planted mine in spring 2006, so it's a bit early to evaluate them, but at least the Japanese beetles left them alone.

    Persimmons, both Asian and American, have a reputation for being easy to grow. There are several Asian varieties that are hardy in zone 7. I planted a korean variety (Tam Kam) last spring, and the leaves were flawless until the frost.

    The bush cherries 'Jan' 'Joy' and 'Joel' are advertised as excellent no spray fruit. I plan on ordering 1 or 2 this spring.

    Mulberries should be easy to grow, but I think the birds will give you some pretty stiff competition, and it's hard to net a big mulberry tree!

    Alex

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Pears are easy to grow here -- I have access to a couple of very productive trees. And I don't like pears. Go figure!

    I've never tried a Persimmon or a mulberry -- or a jujube, which seems nearly bullet proof.

    I've never heard of bush cherries, but I just looked them up. Are they really similar in taste to regular cherries? If so, I could certainly find a place for them! Too bad they are sour cherries instead of the sweet ones, but I do like cherry pie.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Strawberries are a lot of work but if you keep the bed up well you won't need to spray it. I've never sprayed my bed. When it gets diseases in a few years move the bed to another spot. Just be prepared for a lot of work: netting, weeding, thinning, etc.

    Forget peaches plums and cherries, too much spraying needed. Some years I don't need to spray but then a disease pops up and its either spray or give up. There is some chance you could get some apples by bagging the fruit to keep the bugs off. Apples generally are not too bad for diseases if you keep them pruned open, and have them in a nice sunny spot with good air circulation. So it may be worth an experiment. Get disease-resistant varieties such as Gold Rush (awesome apple by any measure). Some sprays are not "chemicals": milk works on powdery mildew, and canola oil works as a dormant oil spray. So maybe you could get someone to spray those for you. Aphids are sometimes a problem on apples and canola oil will also work on them.

    The above observations are for my climate, I think yours is roughly similar but it could be a bit harder for you with more heat and humidity in the summer.

    Scott

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the input, Scott. I didn't realize that people sprayed with milk and canola oil! Those are certainly do-able for me.

    I have heard that heartnut is more resistant to predation than walnuts. True?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nicole,
    Many good recommendations above. Scott's right about bagging - probably your best bet for decent quality fruit, if you've got time to do it. Let me make a recommendation for MonArk and Centennial crab - I know they'll work well for you there.

    Pears are a no-spray fruit that should be almost no-care for you there.

    Same for persimmons - both Asian & American, and you should be able to grow most all of the non-astringent Asian types, if those are your preference(most Americans these days are 'uncomfortable' with a soft, aromatic fruit like persimmon - and they're really missing out!).

    Blueberries are a must - I'd recommend rabbiteye and Southern Highbush types for you - they'll be much more productive in AL than the northern highbush types.

    Triple Crown gets raves, but if you don't mind thorns, Kiowa blackberry produces good crops of HUGE blackberries.

    Pawpaw - most people either love them or find them disgustingly insipid; personally, I'm burnt out on them - one fruit is enough to satisfy me for the year. I've still got a few, but they're planted more as ornamentals, along with some mayhaws, in a low-lying spot alongside the driveway rather than as a prominent part of the orchard.

    Pecans - choose some of the newer varieties selected for home/low-input planting(see linked article below).

    I've not done much with Persian/Carpathian(they're really not English) walnuts - those I've had an opportunity to sample at the KY Nut Growers meetings have been lacking in flavor, and often have an unpleasant astringency, so I can't begin to make any recommendations on varieties that'll do well in north AL - you may need to check with AU extension folks for that info.

    Heartnuts - tastier to me than Persian walnuts, and my buddy in z7 SC says they do fine for him, so you should be OK. Nice, spreading trees, with an almost tropical appearance - a nice ornamental, in addition to the nut production. Late Rhodes, Jewel Box, and Frank work well here. More resistant to predation? Nope; you'll still have to keep the squirrels at bay.
    If you have any interest in black walnuts, there are some good ones out there; Thomas Myers, Emma Kay, and Clermont get my votes.

    Grapes - You'll need muscadine types - visit www.isons.com for best selections.
    Kiwis - I'm still waiting, 12 years after planting mine, to taste the first fruit. You might be able to grow the larger, 'fuzzy' kiwis where you are.

    Mulberries - yes!!! No-spray, and once they attain some size, they produce enough for you and the birds. Illinois Everbearing is the gold standard, but you should be able to grow some of the larger-fruited 'tender' types, like Pakistan, Shangri-La, Cat's Tail, etc., that just won't survive my z6 winters. Kokuso is good, as are Stearns & Collier.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pecan varieties recommended for Home/Low-input planting

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You are at the same place I was 20 years ago- bare land and lots of enthusiasm. Orchards are a lot of work. Any crop failures you have will negate that effort. So rule #1 is to choose your battles very carefully, and pick the low hanging fruit so to speak. Start with bullet-proof fruits that aren't bothered by pests or diseases. Spraying is just one more job, no matter how benign the substance. Asian persimmons, cold tolerant mulberries, figs, American grapes, blackberries, and pears are all delicious and very tough (also loquats and pomegranites for warmer zones). Try to set up a cycle of these tough plants that will yield crops constantly. My cycle is blackberries, mulberries, grapes, pears, figs, and persimmons. Also, considering the investment in effort and years of delay before your first harvest, research the heck out of every crop before making any other move. Don't try to save money on books. Prune your bird susceptible trees to be very low to to make it easier to cover them with nets. Systematize as many upkeep chores as possible, especially watering (drip pipe and timers recommended). Five years from now you will begin to get it . Then consider a few of the more popular (and difficult) fruits

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks to all for all the excellent ideas.

    Sandy, I'm not new to gardening -- just new to this kind of scale. (Well, the first 12 years of my life don't quite count, since I don't remember much of it. But we grew a LOT.) Still, your advice to start with the easy stuff is always good to keep in mind.

    Anyway, elimination of chores is very important to me... because I tend to end up neglecting all the important stuff trying to cram repetitive chores into the daily grind. I'm an old hand with drip systems, since I'm much better at doing occasional large chores, like every month or a few times a year, and leaving the daily work to walking out and looking everything over and picking whatever looks good!

    And I agree on the books. I have quite a collection and more I have my eye on. But so far, I have been pretty disappointed in the quality of fruit and tree books out there, which is the area I need the most information on.

    With the exception of the blueberries (which are a must, IMO!) almost any other fruit I choose will probably go in in the fall, so I still have some time left to make up my mind. But lots to do to get ready!

    So, a modified list would be:
    2 Walnuts, English or Heartnut
    2 Pecans, probably Curtis and Elliot
    4 Hazelnuts, American
    2 Cherries, experiment with bush type
    2 Paw Paw
    4 Elderberries
    4 Hardy kiwi (2 male, 2 female)
    6 grapes, American (Actually, I may have some old rootstock already on the property -- looks like it, but I am not sure until I see the leaves this spring)
    12 blueberries (probably Bluebell and Southland)
    6 blackberries
    8 lingonberry

    raspberries... maybe next year
    strawberries... maybe next year
    currants... maybe next year

    apples... not yet
    peaches... not yet

    Think about:
    white or red mulberry
    Asian persimmon
    jujube
    figs

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    nicole,
    Heed sandylighthouse's warning - I was where you are 13 years ago, and have been going through the same process you are, and that sandy has already been through. Bomb-proof, no-spray fruits only for me. Most of the apples I planted early on are gone or are going away, being replaced with pears and persimmons; the only apples worth my time are the early varieties and edible crabs. Stonefruits - a total waste of time & space for me, except for the native Chickasaw plums. Mulberries are a winner. Blueberries & blackberries, winners.
    Figs, good, but for me, pot culture is required.

    Check out NRTN(linked below) for your walnuts - they may already be sold out for the 2007 season, though.

    You might re-think your choice of 'Curtis' pecan - it's an old variety that's not all that readily available anymore - it's not 'bad', it's just that there are others that are better; 'Elliot' may or may not be suitable for north AL, as it breaks dormancy very early and may be damaged by spring frosts/freezes.
    There was a long-running thread over on the SE Coastal gardening forum, with the following response from Dr. Bill Goff, past president of the Southern Pecan Growers and AU Pecan specialist:
    "I am a Professor at Auburn University and have been evaluating pecans, particularly for scab resistance, for 20 years. Following this research, we suggest only 6 cultivars for home and low-input plantings. They are: Elliott (the standard of scab resistant cultivars, with exceptional disease resistance and quality, but disadvantages of alternate bearing, aphid susceptibility, and early budbreak leading to spring freeze damage), Jenkins, McMillan, Syrup Mill, Gafford, and Carter.
    Without sprays, I classify the following cultivars mentioned previously as terrible (meaning unlikely to ever produce a decent nut crop) : Desirable, Nacono
    Bad: Meaning producing decent nuts less than half the time in the absence of sprays: Gloria Grande, Stuart, Cape Fear.
    OK: Usually producing decent nuts: Curtis
    The varieties suggested as good are rarely available commercially, as most nurseries sell reject, left-over trees of commercial vareities like Desirable that knowledgeable commercial growers won't have to retail nurseries.
    A few nurseries are starting to hear us and catering to small-scale orchards and homeowners. These nurseries include Underwood Nursery, Foley, AL 334-943-8056; Dellwood Nursery, Foley, AL 334-943-8693: and Southern Heritage Nursery (container trees), Bastrop, LA 318-281-0681. Don't expect to buy any of the recommended trees without reserving them a year in advance."

    If you're planting 4 kiwis, I'd do 3 females and one male - 'he' can get the job done, and you should(theoretically) get 1/3 more fruit.
    Research the 'bush cherries' before you spend any $$ on them - you may find you'd be pretty disappointed in their tiny little fruits.
    Same for American hazels - the nuts are tiny, with thick shells. I'd check out the offerings from Badgersett Farms or some of the nurseries linked at the NNGA website( www.northernnutgrowers.org ) that propagate improved/hybrid hazels.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Nolin River Nut Tree Nursery

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lucky,

    The extension office is very pro on Elliot and Curtis. I've only talked to a couple of folks nearby with pecan trees, but most are very disappointed with the new varieties. I will keep asking around.

    "If you're planting 4 kiwis, I'd do 3 females and one male - 'he' can get the job done"
    I was thinking more along the lines of having a back-up male.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nicole, your list looks good but I would bump the Lingonberries from your initial list, they don't like heat. American grapes are still somewhat disease-prone, I wouldn't put them into the no-spray category unless you want to grow muscadines. Figs need no sprays and you are warm enough to grow them outside, so they are an excellent choice.

    Lucky knows his nuts and I would not be surprised if his advice was ahead of your local extension office. Those offices tend to be conservative in their recommendations, not always a bad thing.

    Scott