Software
Houzz Logo Print
mark_roeder_gw

Peach Varieties

Those of you growing peaches -- could you give me a critique, based on your experience -- not based on catalog descriptions -- of the hardiness of your trees and flower buds, and qualities of for taste, texture, and timing, of your peach fruit.

I will enjoy your responses.

Comments (10)

  • 14 years ago

    Hey -- if you have peaches grown from seed and no parentage -- tell me about them too, and about size, productivity, and hardiness of them. I am not really clear how effective it is to grow from seed. The articles I have read seem to have no consensus.

  • 14 years ago

    Hi Mark,I can't be of assistance here, but I am growing some from seed as well.I planted them in 2008 and some of them seem to be quite hardy here ,surving their first year at just over a foot tall seeing a few days of minus 25F (-32C). This year was very mild (-6F,-21C)so I can't say how hardy the flower buds are. I hope this will be the year as they have a lot of flower buds .
    There is another poster on here that has grown peaches from seed(franktank),maybe he will catch this thread and offer some of his experiences as he sees some pretty good winter lows.

  • 14 years ago

    Mark-

    I've got a couple of trees out there that are from seeds, that had a lot of peaches last year, never got PLC (unlike my other trees that were smoked by PLC) and the peaches were very good...I wish I would have labeled my peach seed, because I really have no idea what the parentage was. It could be Reliance or could be some sort of Red Haven. Your free to have seed, budwood or whatever... Just let me know

    {{gwi:67688}}

    {{gwi:67689}}

  • 14 years ago

    That looks pretty good. I thought I read that trees from seed could have fruit that were smallish. These don't look too small.

  • 14 years ago

    Mark,

    I don't have much to contribute regarding hardiness. You guys up north have a unique set of challenges. Sometimes I'm a amazed at the lengths you all will go to grow peaches.

    In terms of flavor, as a general comment, I'm liking Stellar series peaches more and more. Coralstar and Autumnstar seem to consistently produce good flavored peaches. O'Henry, which ripens around Autumnstar is a tad better, but hardly noticeable. Risingstar is probably my favorite early peach for flavor.

    Redhaven is so familiar it sounds unexciting to most folks, but it's still a great peach as grown here. It ranks as good as any of the peaches I've mentioned.

  • 14 years ago

    Polly: A white variety introduced in Iowa in the 1920s. By far my most productive tree. It took a long time to come into production for a peach, but that just means there is more fruit when it does arrive. I got it from that nursery in Atascadero California. I forget its name now. Only medium sized by today's standards, but who cares about that?

    Good old fashioned Redhaven: Its like it wants to produce fruit for you. Quality is as good as any.

  • 14 years ago

    Mark:

    I have grown Reliance in in S.E. WI for 11 years. My oldest tree is on its way out but my other two are still bearing well. I find the fruit on Reliance to be small if not thinned and medium sized if thinned. Hard to get Large
    size peaches on this variety.

    Flavor? It does vary. My original tree had fantastic flavor 3rd leaf. A person could not stop eating at just one. The following year the peaches were mediocre, ok to cook with but not real great fresh use.

    Since then, they have been good to eat every year but never
    as good as 3rd leaf. Hardiness? They do fine for me here
    in Northern zone 5 with winter temps down to -6 for a few
    days two winters ago It seems we usually just hit zero
    degrees for a night or two the past few winters. Global warming?

    Farther N.W. in WI, a friend has a Reliance. It grows well
    but his winters are colder. He gets about 15-20 peaches a
    year while I got 150-350 a year when my large original Reliance was at its peak. Sadly, my other two Reliance never grew as big as the first one.

    I have tasted PF24C at a friend's orchard in WI and found them to be really good tasting and perhaps a firmer peach than Reliance. Just really hard to find a supplier at this
    time.

    Another friend grows Veteran. While large and tasty, it has poor skin color (all yellow). Seems to be a fairly hardy variety. I have not yet tried growing Contender although I have heard favorable reports on it.

  • 14 years ago

    Hey Mark

    I have been reading up a bit on hardy peach trees. Im up in NW ontario zone 4. Ive also read up on starting fruit trees from seed. I dont know about personal experience, about hardiness, but again, ive read up on this quite a bit.

    In regards to growing from seed. ITs not like you wont get something satisfactory when growing from seed. THe "problem" lies in the fact that the fruit you get from the store are hybrids, which produce varies offspring. THis just means you have NO idea what you are going to get. You could get one that never blooms, that isnt hardy, and getz 100 feet tall, or one that is a prize winning, super hardy variety. IMO, thats the best part about growing from seed, you get a surprise in a few years. If it isnt what you like, but hardy, get some scion and top work the tree. Peach seeds needs 6 weeks of stratification (cold conditions in a fridge), and in my experience with stone fruits, the shell should be cracked, or the "seed" or "nut" inside should be taken out, and sown that way. The nuts are easiest to crack if you soak them for a few days.

    When speaking in terms of hardiness. I have read people successfully growing then in minnisota. The thing with peaches, is that most need a long growing season, with a long "chill" to set flower or fruit (I forget which). IT also depends on how prone you are to late frosts. I have read that planting them on an east, or even northern place stops them from budding too soon. I have also read that too much sun on the trunk in places that get cold, then warm, makes the trunks explode. Apparently shading the trunk in the winter can make the difference ( again, NOT from experience, this is from reading). Late fall watering can also have an effect on some fruit trees going dormant, which effects hardiness, as does your soil, mulching and snow pack.

    The only variety that comes to mind for good hardiness, is "reliance". THis cariety has the most literature. There are some others, but dont have as much info backing itself up.

  • 14 years ago

    Spartan,

    I have grown Reliance, and I think it is a good tasting peach. A tree ripened peach is good. Weather plays a role in flavor.

    I have a third year Red Haven that may produce this year, so I might have some basis for comparison, soon.

    kokopelli5a,

    After reading your post I tried to find some information on Polly. How does it taste. Some of the photos of the fruit I saw showed fruit that were not attractive. Comment if you can on the appearance of the Polly fruit, and its flavor.

  • 10 years ago

    Has anyone heard of "Eburt" and "Purple Peach" Peach Varieties? I couldn't find any information on them and Home Depot is selling them. the names were on the white strip tag meanwhile the generic label just states that they are semi-dwarf hybrids.