Software
Houzz Logo Print
scottfsmith

Pomegranates survived 0F covered

17 years ago

I uncovered my pomegranates last night and was happy to find them looking very healthy. These were planted last year and are very small plants. Several of the varieties are not considered hardy ones, e.g. Eversweet, Angel Red, Grenada, etc.

I used "tents" of aluminum foil bubble insulation and that seems to have provided enough protection. The cover also keeps the plants cool when it is hot out and that keeps them from waking out of dormancy too early -- they are still fully dormant. My figs were uncovered as well and they also look good; one of the covers blew off and that plant had a bit of cold damage on some of the larger limbs but all the rest looked good.

Scott

Comments (56)

  • 17 years ago

    i may have lost my first pom, a wonderfull. it had gone through 3 winters fine.

    it had just started to leaf out in late feb, a couple weeks before my other poms. had all those tiny red leaves. then the temp dropped from 75 to 25 degrees about 3/1, & all the leaves died. twigs are still green but there's not a single leaf.

    my other 9-10 poms are fine. they were still dormant when the freeze hit but they all have good size leaves now

  • 17 years ago

    I checked my Kazake a few days ago, and *so far* it looks good, with only a little die back to the tips of the shoots. It got down into single digits several times, and the lowest temp was 2F. It had been killed back the past two years, but I'm starting to think that hard feezes in March may have been the killer, and not the absolute lows when fully dormant. I'll know for sure when I see good growth in a few weeks.

  • 17 years ago

    That makes sense. Bass and I may be a bit better than your location with regard to late hard freezes, I haven't seen one here recently (famous last words).

    I just pulled up the Ashton Poms book and he states 3F as the bottom for trying the most hardy kinds of fruiting poms; in 0F-3F lows he recommends ornamental varieties only. The ones which apparently did well under the cover for me are mostly in his "frost sensitive" category which he puts the low at 12F on. So, the cover apparently gives 12+F of protection.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Just checked my unprotected Kazake again a couple of days ago. Even toothpick diameter wood seems green and healthy, so I think it has survived well this past winter. The winter of 2007-2008 was probably not a good indicator, as most things were injured that winter due to the extreme drought in 2007 that left plants weak heading into winter. Now if we can avoid getting a hard freeze for a couple more weeks, maybe this thing will get big this year.

  • 17 years ago

    Scott
    I got signed up here on Gardenweb. Are you serious, you are raising pomegranates as far north as you are located? I love them but never thought I could raise them here.
    RED

  • 17 years ago

    BHawkins, Don't give up on your frosted pomegranate. My Wonderful had little leaves when it was hit with a late freeze. Killed every leaf black dead. Now it is fully leafed out.

  • 17 years ago

    Red, I'm giving it a go, we'll see if it works! I have noticed I have more tip dieback on the very thinnest wood but the main stems are looking very healthy.

    Thats great to hear your Kazake is doing so well kiwinut, pretty impressive for a 2F low uncovered.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Scott,
    I checked my 3 pomegranates that were left unprotected in ground. kazake, still green no die back, Salvatski very healthy and no die back and putting on new growth now. Wonderful pomegranate is still alive with some die back. Salvatski seem to be the white pomegranate variety, actually light pinkish color.

    Bass

  • 17 years ago

    Here in WashDC my 5 yr old "Favorite" (Lyubimyi) had no problems uncovered. I think we went down to 8*F a couple of times. Out in SE MD a new 'Granada' seems to have come though okay, also without covering. Not sure of the temps there, but close to same as here.

  • 17 years ago

    Looked - though not all that closely - at my row of poms last week - they spent the winter uncovered, though I did haul a truckload of bagged leaves home from town last fall and dumped them over them - but they settled/blew quite a bit over the winter.
    Anyway, all of them seem to be OK, with the exception of rabbits having browsed several of them, and are beginning to bud out.
    I have no idea what our minimum temps reached this winter, but I do know we got down into single digits at some point in time.

  • 17 years ago

    To follow up on this, all my pomegranates are starting to push leaves so I think they are good.

    Chills, I am having good luck on Kazake rooting and may have an extra. If you want one for the $10 or so it will cost to ship a potted plant to you, send me an email. The ARS sent me some excellent pomegranate cuttings, very long and thick and it looks like they may all work.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Scott, my Kazake was showing very slight bud swelling yesterday, but no leaves pushing at all so far. I'm surprised that your poms are already leafing out. Most things here are about normal or a little late, and we have just barely missed damaging freezes several times recently. Grape buds are swelling, but no leaves yet. Figs are just starting to show some slight green. Blueberries are starting to bloom. Kaki persimmons are still dormant and pears are not quite dime sized.

  • 17 years ago

    Kiwinut, I should have clarified that they have not pushed their leaves very far at all (1-2mm at the most), so our poms could be in the same state more or less. My asian pears are in full bloom now so the pears are quite a bit behind yours. Some of the kakis are showing bud swelling here and others are still completely dormant.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Update. Kazake started to push some weak growth from the largest "trunk" right up to near the tip, but it has all collasped and died the past few days. The other "trunks" did not survive at all. I guess the main trunk just barely survived enough for a little growth. There is strong growth from the base.

    Even though I got it from the most reliable source, I'm beginning to wonder if there was some mix up, after seeing how it has fared in other areas. I guess I will have to cover it next winter.

  • 17 years ago

    I am wondering if temperature swings as the poms come out of dormancy may also be a factor. I had two of my covered poms start sprouting after I had removed my cover, then it got colder and in the end a good part of those two died back. Not all the above-ground parts, just most of them. These were non-cold-hardy kinds; all of the cold-hardy ones lost almost no wood at all (covered of course). I have two new rooted Kazakes this spring and I put one in my area that gets the cover and the other one is going to be in the open for comparison.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    scott, thats what happened to my 3 year old wonderfull. survived the winter fine, had just started to leaf out; & then temps dropped from 75 to 25 in less than 24 hours; & 8 of the 10 or so shoots died

    at least it didn't die entirely to the ground

  • 17 years ago

    When do pomegranates get ripe? Is our season long enough to ripen them successfully
    RED

  • 17 years ago

    Red, I do think that is a significant issue. I am growing several early-ripening ones for that reason (all of the ones I have that are not very hardy I picked for early ripening: Grenada, Angel Red, Eversweet, Medovyi Vahsha, Nikitski Ranni). I am surprised at how little information I have found on the ripening time aspect for people that are more north like us. I also found very little such information on fuzzy kiwis, and now find myself with several fruiting vines but none of them adequately ripening for me. So, I decided to hedge my bets and do some early ripening and some hardy pomegranates.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    I grow salvatski, kazake, and wonderful in ground. The least hardy is wonderful, it got damaged, but seems to still grow. Kazake seems to be untouched, Salvatski seems to be a winner so far, it's growing like a weed. I spoke with richard ashton and told me that Salvatski was selected to plant orchards of it in texas. It's Hardy and it ripens early enough for up north.
    I'm still waiting on my Salvatski to flower. I'm hoping to see flowers this year.

    Bass

  • 17 years ago

    Did Richard know of a successfully fruiting Salavatski up north? Salavatski is not especially early ripening I don't think. in his book he states 180 days as the minimum number of frost-free days for most varieties and I am just above 180 where I am.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    He didn't mention if anyone who is growing it far north.
    I'll keep you informed how successful it will be for me.
    I had some pomegranates fruiting in containers and ripening before frost with no problems.

    Bass

  • 17 years ago

    If they are successfully ripening in containers that is a good sign. After running into trouble with the fuzzy kiwis I got more concerned about the season length issue, so I may be acting more conservatively than I need to be there.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Last year while visiting the Brooklyn botanical gardens. They had kiwi arbors, and they are growing hardy kiwi as well as the fuzzy kiwi. It was late september, the small kiwis were getting ripe and the fuzzy kiwi was still hard. I'm guessing it can be picked prior to frost, and ripened at room temperature.

  • 17 years ago

    Two years ago I picked my fuzzy kiwis at the first frost and they never got good enough to eat. They got to the point I could eat them, but I didn't want to because they had no flavor. Then they rotted.

    I was going to try ripening them at lower temps last year, but the squirrels stole all the fruit so I didn't get to try that. I am growing some fuzzy varieties which are supposedly needing a shorter season and will hopefully have better luck with them; I am also going to keep around my other ones to see if I can find a way to ripen them.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Want to correct my earlier post regarding winter damage to my 'Granada' in SE MD orchard (zone 7). Both it and a cutting from my 'Lyubimyi' did died back to the ground -- but both have since resprouted from the base. Both were put in just last year, hope they'll be stronger for this next winter. Will try to give protection this time.

    My older 'Lyubimyi' at home had no problems unprotected and is covered in blooms, and a few small developing fruits.

  • 17 years ago

    My Grenada had the most tip dieback (under the cover), so our collective experience indicates that one does not appear to be very hardy. I now have two rooted Kazake in the ground and growing well, one in my area I will cover and one I plan to keep uncovered.

    Let us know how your Lyubimyi ripen there.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Scott,
    Will keep you posted. I got fruit from it last year for the first time, but many more flowers this year. The fruits are not as large as 'Wonderful' in size, but I was delighted with them. A squirrel ate about 1/4 of one, but left it. Guess it was too tart for him, but I enjoyed them. I left some on the tree up until there was danger of frost with no problems.

    This year I've added new varieties to the SE MD orchard:
    Red Silk, Garnet Sash, Desertneyi, Sharp Velvet, Texas Rose (from Ashton), and Eversweet (moved from my house); I also added Angel Red to the yard in town. Except for the Texas Rose, none are known to be particulary hardy -- but one never knows...

  • 16 years ago

    I'm happy to report that all my pomegranates made it through the winter and are waking up in this fine weather. I copied Scott's idea and created an envelope of the foil-bubblewrap to cover each one. (I wrapped each first with a bit of burlap.) Hopefully another year of winter protection and even the more tender ones won't need it anymore.

  • 16 years ago

    Glad to hear it Gene. I also made it with 100%. I left one Kazake out uncovered and it also did great, that one is hardy enough it doesn't need a cover. I am also hoping to ease off on the covering. I didn't cover my mature figs at all this winter, and they did OK.

    Scott

  • 16 years ago

    I just bought an eversweet, and plan on keeping it in a 20gl container, the low winter temps get as low as 8-10 degrees, do I have a real chance growing this? I kinda think I do, but, what do I know about Pomegranates! any tips? reality check?

  • 16 years ago

    Mudflapper,
    I had Eversweet from Raintree in my yard, but it kept dying back each winter, whereas Favorite from One Green World did fine. I moved Eversweet out to my orchard last year, gave it some cover and it overwintered fine this time. I'm in zone 7.

  • 16 years ago

    Just checked on my Kazake yesterday, which was unprotected this winter. Every tiny twig is strongly pushing leaves, so it appears to be unfazed this time around. The winter temps were similar to past year's, but the major difference was that we did not have a single warm spell all winter. The consistent cold seems to have contributed to almost everything I grow having no damage at all. Now if things don't freeze this weekend, it could be a good year for fruit.

  • 16 years ago

    My dad in SW TN tells me that the little "Eve" pomegranate that I set out in his yard last year is starting to put out leaves. So looks like Tennessee is good pomegranate territory too.

  • 16 years ago

    My Salavatski survived with no damage, so did the kazake. While Wonderful died to the ground again.

    Bass

  • 16 years ago

    I would love to grow Poms, so I was surprised when I found out they were surviving in my zone. Has anyone gotten any fruit from the plants?

  • 16 years ago

    Christine, Bass posting right above you has gotten fruits off of his Salavatski. If you click on his name you can find his webpage which has the pictures.
    I only put my poms in a few years ago so I don't have any fruits yet myself.

    In our climate you need to grow hardy pomegranates such as Kazake or Salavatski. There are not many sources for them, in fact the only commercial source I know is Edible Landscaping which sells their Russian Hardy which is probably Salavatski.

    Scott

  • 16 years ago

    i'm sorry to say i've had some poms die on me this winter. seemed random. i'll give them another couple weeks & hope for the best, then i'll report which varieties lived & died. i don't cover them, most are on the south side's of walls

  • 16 years ago

    Christine,
    Everything I had read, indicated that pomegranates would live as far north as Washington, DC, but wouldn't fruit here. I set out "Favorite" from One Green World (original name is Lyubimyi and is available from UC-Davis). I've never covered it and had only minor tip damage the first winter. It bloomed and fruited for the first time in 2008, 5 years after I set it out. I really am enjoying the fruit. Here's two pictures from last year:



    {{gwi:70568}}

    {{gwi:70569}}

  • 16 years ago

    Gene, those are stunning photographs. I was inspired to order a 'favorite' from one green world after seeing your photos on another thread several weeks back. Even if you didnt eat the fruit it would be worth growing because it is so ornamental. Do you remember when your photos were taken or when you harvested the fruit?

  • 16 years ago

    gene, how hard are the seeds, can you eat them? is the fruit sweet, tart, or sour? do you feel they have enough time to ripen?

    thanks,

  • 16 years ago

    Here's my Salavatski first year fruiting. They're usually a larger fruit.
    I harvested the fruit in October and was fully ripe.

    {{gwi:70570}}

    {{gwi:70571}}

    Bass

    Here is a link that might be useful: Trees of joy

  • 16 years ago

    shane11: I don't recall at what point in the season the photos where made. I enjoyed looking at them so much I tend to leave them on as long as possible. When I did start havesting them, I did so one at a time as I ate them and tried to have them all off by the first frost (vaguely around Thanksgiving) though I think they would be okay through a light frost. The main problem last fall was all the rain that we got and I lost one or two to rot.

    bhawkins: The seeds of Favorite are hard. That seemed a little odd when I first started eating them, but I enjoy them all the same and don't think about it now; in fact, I think I'd miss it if it were otherwise. The taste is sweet/tart, deeper red and more intense flavor than the Wonderful pomegranate that I bought at the store last fall. None of the fruit I picked ever seemed to be not-quite-ripe-yet, but I did notice that the arils got even plumper, darker and sweeter the longer I left them. I don't have a wide experience with the taste of the various varieties, but I do like this one very much, and it's hardy too.

  • 16 years ago

    I love all the photos, the pix with them hanging on the tree remind me of ornaments on Christmas trees.

    I don't think it is in the budget this yr for a pom, hopefully next year. I've saved this thread so I know what kind to get when I do buy one.

    Gene, maybe because I always spit the seeds out, but I thought all the seeds to poms were hard. Sounds like some must be soft.

    Oh, when I showed my daughter the picture of the pom cut open she said that she wanted to put the whole thing in her mouth, that it looked so good.

  • 16 years ago

    Christine, you're right, there are hard and soft seed (and a range in between) of pomegranates. The soft seeded types are more cold sensitive, so here in the northern border of the pomogranate range we have to go for the hard seeded types--unless you want to do major winter protection.

    I would encourage you to eat the seeds too (unless there's medical reason not to, such as diverticulitis for example). The juice alone has healthy properties, but the seeds (and flowers, peel) have even more. So if you don't eat the seed you're throwing away a lot of good nutrition. I didn't like the seeds at first either, but grew to like them fairly quickly.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with Gene, The seeds don't bother me. People eat sesame seeds for a reason. Figs have seeds, and I love them. many fruits have small seeds that are edible, such as passion fruit, Cactus pears, Guavas, and Pomegranates.

    Bass

  • 16 years ago

    Well, here is an update from my post on March 20, 2009, above. The "Russian Hardy" poms (2) did fine coming through the winter of 2008-09. They leafed out beautifully from top to bottom... then a late freeze down to around 27 as I recall came in and - killed them back to the ground. Pretty annoying since it was clearly all about the timing of it. They survived fine down to 8 degrees back in November, but got killed to the ground at 27 during leaf bud.

    Well, same the same story may be unfolding this year, we'll have to see. The scoop this year was we got down to around 5 or six degrees, they looked to have buds on all the regrowth just fine, and then this year they were just starting to bud in a few places - and, we only got down to 32. All the new leaves are dead. It will be a little while before I can tell if the branches are done in to the ground like last year.

    Its hard to complain, I'm trying to grow them out of their normal zones (6b in the 1990 USDA hardiness zone map). But, it is annoying they can survive the hard winter freezes only to have trouble with light spring freezes at the wrong time. Argh! ;)

  • 16 years ago

    Whats the best way to propagate pomegranates? Is now a good time? Mine is pushing out leaves for 2 weeks now. Thanks

  • 16 years ago

    I think rooting dormant cuttings about the thickness of a pencil is the most common. I have airlayered one once, but they aren't as quick as the fig to root. This Spring I managed to seperate a few suckers at the base with a bit of root still on them.

  • 16 years ago

    I will try to eat the seeds. I've never met too many people that eat them. People always looked at me funny when I brought them into work, and my mom always spit them out. So it is weird to me to eat them, but I will try.

  • 16 years ago

    rc, i'm seeing the exact same thing as you. my poms due fine through the winter & most of feb, its the freezes around 3/1 that seem to get them

    bob