Software
Houzz Logo Print
keepitlow

Dealing with clay soil

17 years ago

My top soil is pretty good looking but soon I hit some hard packed clay. When I plant a tree I have been using mostly my top soil in the bottom of the hole and mid section. Then at top, I've been breaking up the clay and sieving it with some other looser soil to use the clay soil up.

I tried buying some bagged top soil at Walmart, but it was really garbage and did not want to use it. So I have to make use of what I have the best I can.

Before I fill the hole, I have also been chipping away at the bottom and sides of the hole with an axe/pick to try and loosen it up for roots to enter.


Is this a good way to deal with clay soils with tree planting?

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    No. First of all you are putting subsoil on top of topsoil. Do not bring subsoil up from below and put it where roots will be trying to grow. Secondly you are pit planting, that is planting in pits of purchased soil surrounded by existing soil. This is liable to have adverse effects on how water enters and exits the planting hole, due to the difference in textures likely to be present between the soil inside the hole and outside it. Where and when there is a high water table plants so situated may end up in puddles and drown.

    Poking through the compacted layer is a good idea as long as you make into to a layer of more open soil underneath, into which water can drain - and will then drain away. If this is not accomplished, there is no reason to bother with this.

    The basic effective general procedure for dealing with disagreeable soil in home gardens and other small-scale operations is going up instead of down, that is with berms or mounds of better soil made on top instead of digging down into the existing soil. If a wide enough area is going to be made into a bed it may also work to dig out and replace existing soil. But that way you have to get rid of the excavated soil somewhere, whereas with berming or mounding you just have to bring and spread the new soil.

  • 17 years ago

    keepitlow,

    "My top soil is pretty good looking but soon I hit some hard packed clay."

    This is me too. I am fortunate enough to have a plot of land that was not mass-cleared and was not stripped of all topsoil to grade for a new housing development. My yard was part of a farm and sectioned off over 40 years ago to build a house. Therefore, I still have all my good topsoil. However, and thats a big "however". I am in an area that has poorly drained soils. It is on the USGS soil maps labeled as such. It has just rained here for 3 days straight and I just walked up and checked the rain gauge = 2.5 inches. That tells me that the backyard especially will be mushy for a week.

    When I planned my orchard a couple years ago I was very distraught when I dug down below 6" and found hardpan. It is lighter orange than the typical red clay, and worse. As you go deeper it got lighter and some spots (I had to dig 20 + holes) were yellowish and even whitish. Bad. The white is worst of all and deemed in-penetrable. By this point I had already invested money in the trees and fence so this is what I did:

    I dug 2.5' deep and the holes were 24" wide. I then took a soil auger and augered a few holes down to about 3' in each planting hole and filled the augered holes with drainage rock. A little extra work but it was advice given to me by some local nurseries dealing with the same soil issues as I.

    I'm babbling all this for a reason, and that is to tell you that there is hope! My trees SO FAR have done well. I had many sleepless nights that first year before they leafed out, wondering if it was going to work. It has so far. I do agree with bboy that adding bagged soil is no good. I will add that I did not raise any mounds when I planted. The graft unions are all 2" above the soil level for all trees. I'll point out that in weeks of drought, this soil can be a benefit, holding moisture longer. These trees can uptake a lot of water during the growing season and still be ok. Hope this encourages you.
    ~Thomis

  • 17 years ago

    I've read that adding a small amount of gypsum will really help a clay soil, can't remember why. When I have the money I'm going to have a dump truck full of sand put on my garden to till in just for friability. Of course loads of organic matter will help. I have found when local farmers have round bales of hay that are rain-damaged they will give it away and it makes fine mulch, and adds geat fiber for next year.

  • 17 years ago

    Gypsum is not the miracle cure for clay soils as has been trumpeted in old gardening myths for years. Unless, that is, your soil is loaded with sodium chloride. The gypsum will do nothing for clay.

    Also, I'd like you to reconsider adding the sand to your clay. You will very likely end up with something closer to cement than anything else. The best cure for clayey soils is, simply, plenty of organic matter.

  • 17 years ago

    Unless, of course, you are willing to add tremendous quantities of sand. There is a point when a clay soil is lightened by sand but getting there is not generally considered practical, but a lot of us gardeners are not completely practical- bring on the dump truck!

  • 17 years ago

    wiki "brick" and see clay and sand as key ingredients, though at certain proportions.

  • 17 years ago

    Digging in enough sand to change the texture of a soil with a high clay content results in a high volume of new soil that has to be dealt with. It can be like a rising loaf of bread.

    If you mix the two together too much the clay may coat the sand particles. If you use too much sand you may end up with an excessively draining, droughty sandy soil. In many instances you'd be better off with a clay soil - it retains moisture and may by comparatively high in nutrients. The world's most complex, lush rain forests often occur on terrible highly degraded, muddy, low fertility soils. You don't need a deep highly porous soil to grow trees. It's always a matter of matching kind of tree with soil type.

  • 17 years ago

    I once installed an orchard in what I was told was top soil. Instead it was subsoil taken from the top of a mountain. It was pure grey and looked nothing like soil. Grass couldn't grow in it- it was perfect for pottery.

    Although I was well aware of the literature on amending clay I did use large quantities of sand- about a half yard a tree along with equal quantities of compost. I only tried to create about a 12" depth of satisfactory soil in 6' diameter raised circles. We mulched the trees with 1/4 yard aged woodchips and all the trees survived although the peaches have underperformed- although they are bearaing. Plums and pears have flourished and the apples are satisfactory. I did not create concrete.

    So there you have it goosperts. Don't worship the book and you might learn something all your own.