Software
Houzz Logo Print
myk1_gw

Should I try a plum again?

17 years ago

I really like Japanese plums. Problem is so do the curculio and they are a major problem here. But I'm spraying now so there's a chance to keep them down enough to get some plums, Triazicide has shown to be somewhere between very effective and somewhat effective on them. I can't find Imidan.

I'd be perfectly happy with a dozen or two plums a year so bagging is also an option to get them by that second wave of curculio that are more willing to ignore the spray.

Another problem is borers. Japanese plums also seem to be their favorite of the trees I've tried. But again, I'm spraying now and wasn't then. The same borers like to go after my sour cherries somewhat and my plan is to keep the trunks sprayed with Triazicide or Permethrin. Doing the same with another tree wouldn't be a big deal.

Other considerations, the plum could attract curculio away from my apples or the plum could attract borers to my cherries.

So what do you think?

Knowing I have bad curculio and borer problems would I just be buying another couple $12 plums?

I'd rather not waste my time or money especially if it means borers will go after my cherries once the plum is dead.

Comments (18)

  • 17 years ago

    mykl, I have also had lots of problems on my Japanese plums but now that I have the hang of it they are one of my most rewarding fruits. I have found Surround works very well on the curc so if the triazicide is not working that is another option. I have not had problems with borers. It is the cherries I am getting down on, I need to net them to keep the birds off but its too much hassle.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    My Meteor is at about the point i need to cover it...
    My Superior/Alderman both have a lot of blemished fruits and i figure i'll get maybe 30 plums between the two. I really have to protect them from PC next year.

    When do you spray for borer? I have no idea if that is a problem around here.

  • 17 years ago

    I've had my Methley for ten years and have yet to get a plum past the size of a grain of rice, and only a max of about five of them! Late freezes get them every year. I tried training to a "wagon wheel" shape and bend the branches down so I can tarp it, but it's not worked very well. It's a mess.

    Okay, this has nothing to do with bugs. I just had to chime in! It's been a while since I posted!

    Herbert

  • 17 years ago

    I had thought of Surround but that would be an expensive proposition in a year like this one. I think the constant rain is what made the curculio able to keep coming back.
    They don't seem to be in good enough health to have many successful layings but I don't know if that would keep them from laying on the softer plums, they had no problem on my softer cherries although they were unsprayed because I never had a problem before.

    I'd have to look it up but I think you're supposed to make 2 sprays for the borers June and August, but don't quote me on that, it may be July. I get the Lesser borer, I could paint the central leader to hopefully keep them from killing the whole tree.

    I never had a problem with my Santa Rosas getting frosted, although they only lived about 2 years each so I don't have a lot of data to go by. I was thinking of Methley, perhaps I should stick with Santa Rosa instead. At least I know I can manage a couple of expensive plums before the tree dies with Santa Rosa.

    What really gets me is my friend a couple miles away has some ornamental plums, no curculio, no borers.

  • 17 years ago

    My ornamental plum gets almost nothing on it. It is purple-leaf and maybe that confuses the curculio. I would definitely not get a Santa Rosa, it is not an easy one to grow. Methley is reliable but I think the new AU plums are probably the best overall in terms of reliability. I just got an AU Producer this spring. Of the ones fruiting for me I have found Superior, Redheart, and Satsuma all to be reliable.

    If you were using the Surround as a backup option in case the curc was getting out of hand you could probably get one bag to last a long time. I don't think I did any more than three sprays for curc this spring in any case. It takes about an inch of rain to wash it all off.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    What are the problems with Santa Rosa?
    I probably only had the trees for 3-4 years each but I don't recall any disease or frost issues.

    It would have to be Methley or Santa Rosa because I'm running out of room.

  • 17 years ago

    Santa Rosa is not the most disease-resistant plum since it has more Japanese plum genes in it than many of the hybrid plums. I had lots of problems with shot-hole myself. It also is not a great pollinator and drops too many fruits in June drop, in spite of being lightly loaded to begin with. This is my story with this plum and there was a recent post here where several others had the same problem. I expect it probably does great under some conditions or it wouldn't be so popular, but I don't think it is a reliable east coast plum based on both my experiences and what I have heard from others. In looking in Ashton's plum book he also calls Santa Rosa a "shy bearer in the east". He states AU Roadside is self-fertile so if it is self-fertile you need I would recommend that plum. I had ordered an AU Roadside from Johnson Nursery this spring but they had a crop failure and I got an AU Producer instead. I may get an AU Roadside next spring.

    Scott

    PS Richard's full description from his excellent book. Notice how disease-resistant it is, better than Methley in that category (Methley has black knot problems).

    AU ROADSIDE Â (P. salicina hybrid) Â
    Skin: Dark red, Flesh: Dark red, Ripe: Mid-season, Taste: Good, C/F:
    Semi-clingstone, Fruit Size: Large, Shipping: Acceptable, Tree Size: Medium.
    Developed by J. D. Norton, Alabama Agricultural Experiment Station at
    Auburn University and introduced in1983. A cross of Ozark Premier and Methley
    made in 1961. Tested under the name Ozark Premier F-2.
    Fruit have dark red skin that turn more purple upon ripening. The dark red
    flesh is excellent in quality. Good for the fresh market, as the fruit have adequate
    firmness for handling, packing and shipping short distances. The fruit mature about
    1 week before Ozark Premier. It is a self-fertile and flowers heavily; sets a heavy
    crop.
    It has resistance or tolerance to black knot, bacterial canker, bacterial fruit
    spot, and plum leaf scald. Has some resistance to brown-rot. Excellent fruit quality
    was inherited from both parents. Trees of AU Roadside are vigorous, spreading
    with dark green leaves. This variety comes into bearing early.
    When compared to Ozark Premier it ripens about 8 days earlier, has a week
    shorter growing season and is more fully colored at maturity. The trees also have a
    longer life as opposed to Ozark Premier. Overall, it is superior to Ozark Premier.

  • 17 years ago

    Scott, thanks I ordered the AU Roadside from Johnsons and didn't get it either. The Fortune plum I got from them is doing marvelous.

  • 17 years ago

    I use Imidan as an insecticide and have very little problem with curculio. I can tank mix it with a fungicide if I need to. I get it at the local FS store.

  • 17 years ago

    Scott,

    Some years ago, on the Nafex forum, I thought it was you who had researched the AU series of plums, and determined they did not score that high in taste among Nafexers. I thought you mentioned AU Amber was the best rated plum, but it wasn't rated as really great. Am I confusing you with someone else?

  • 17 years ago

    The curculio hit my plums so hard I wouldn't know if they would've dropped on their own. The few I managed to bag before the curculio got them stuck. But that's like 3 plums on 2 trees over a small number of years, not exactly a good judge.

    I was looking up the AUs last night. Seems they are limited in their distribution network.
    AC seems to be more interested in large orders and charges high shipping for small amounts, they only have AU Rosa. (AU Rosa isn't listed as self-fertile by the companies but is by the university.)
    Johnson seems biased towards the south rating their zones lower than others, which conveniently makes it so they don't have to guarantee it.
    And then there's TyTy and Willis.

    Maybe by the time I'm ordering AC will have some apples I'm willing to throw in for "sharecropping" to beat their shipping. Or maybe more companies will have them next year.

    Maybe I'll take my overflow row out of my garden which will open up a strip for more trees.

  • 17 years ago

    Imred,
    I've tried to find Imidan and can't. I even had my brother check in South Carolina.

    Taste is one reason I'm stuck on the idea of Santa Rosa. I've had storebought dark purple Japanese plums that were kind of bland. I've seen Methley pictured as dark purple and seen it pictured as red.

    I was driving a friend nuts carrying my Santa Rosas around for days smelling them.
    "Would you eat it already?"
    "This is a $12 plum. I'm going to get my money's worth out of it."

  • 17 years ago

    Olpea, you are right that I could not find much positive on the taste of the AU plums earlier, but I more recently heard positive statements from various sources and decided to give them a try. They may not be as good as the best plums but they are at least as good as Methley based on what I have heard, and probably better. Methley has astringent skin and some people like it and some don't; I am in the latter category.

    The store plums these days are like the store peaches: picked too early to be any good. So any decent home-grown plum will blow away the store ones.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    All the Methley trees they were selling locally this year looked like crap. Not sure what the deal was, but every tree i looked at had dead branches, etc...

  • 17 years ago

    How big is a full grown plum tree realistically?

    If I get rid of my garden overflow row I don't really lose anything I still grow and I have about 15' between the fence and the first row (I have a retaining wall on the other side of the fence so if I have to use all 15' for tree and spray from the other side I can).
    I have enough length to fit 3 trees 15' or better apart.

    One tree will be an apple (Newtown) but the other two could be plums.
    Right now I'm thinking Grandpas for Newtown, Shiro and Santa Rosa.
    With 3 trees AC is a possibility and then I'd consider AU Rosa. But that is the only AU they list and Johnsons bends their zone too much for me to have a big enough guaranteed selection from them.

    The bacterial diseases have never been an issue with my cherries, just the borers and curculio. As far as diseases just cherry leaf spot, powdery mildew and occassional brown rot, even those haven't been much of a problem, they're just there.

  • 17 years ago

    Plum trees can get pretty tall, 20' or so. But you can easily keep them 8'x8' or so with summer pruning. I have mine only 3' apart in a row, and 8' tall.

    The bacterial diseases are worse on plums than on cherries or peaches, with the exception of bacterial canker which is bad on both. They are also site- and climate-specific and it may not be so much of a problem for you.

    Good luck on your Santa Rosa. I don't think you will see many plums on it. I have about a dozen fruits left on my tree at this point. I would have pulled the tree out but they have a unique flavor so I put up with it.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    The same reason you hadn't pulled the tree is why I'm stuck on Santa Rosa.
    I realize any homegrown would be better than store bought but the few I got were really good.
    Getting low numbers doesn't really matter. They don't keep and I'm not that big into jelly or wine. With 2 trees I'm sure I'll have plenty.

    3' apart? I'll have to plot the sun. I might be able to squeeze in another apple at the end of the row with 10' spacing.

  • 17 years ago

    Does anyone known this variety of plum. My mom use to have plum tree with egg shape fruit with reddish yellow skin. Sweet as honey. I remember lots of honey bees buzzing around it. My mom does not remember the name. I love to buy this type of plum again.

    Thanks