Software
Houzz Logo Print
kawaiineko_gardener

problems with root vegetables and spinach

I attempted to grow spinach this year, and unfortunately wasn't successful at all.

I know one of the main problems was the soil. It just didn't grow very well in the soil mixture I used, whereas the rest of my plants thrived in it.

The germination was poor, and I only managed one harvest; unfortunately even that harvest the plant was very small.

I know some stuff just prefers sandy soil. Is spinach one of these things?

With root veggies, they didn't do well either. I just didn't get decent sized root vegetables at all; they were spindly and thin with the vegetable portion of them.

What primary nutrients do root vegetables need to thrive?

I know some vegetables prefer sandy soil, are root vegetables (carrots, beets, parsnips, white Asian radishes) among the vegetables that have this preference?

If so, how much sand should I add to my soil mixture? I have a soil mixture that worked beautifully. I don't want to mess it up by adding too much sand to the original "recipe" but at the same time, I know if I don't add sand, it might continue to create problems with growing root vegetables.

Below is the soil mixture I use for container gardening. It works beautifully. However, how much sand should I add to this? Should I replace some of the materials in the recipe, with sand? If so, in what quantities?

Big batch:

2-3 cu ft pine bark fines

5 gallons peat

5 gallons perlite

2 cups dolomitic (garden) lime (or gypsum in some cases)

2 cups CRF (if preferred)

1/2 cup micro-nutrient powder (or other source of the minors - provided in some fertilizers)

Small batch:

3 gallons pine bark

1/2 gallon peat

1/2 gallon perlite

4 tbsp lime (or gypsum in some cases)

1/4 cup CRF (if preferred)

micro-nutrient powder (or other source of the minors)

Comments (8)

  • 16 years ago

    Having had a look at your 'Soil' mixtures the question arises....Where's the soil? You have little natural microbes or bacteria in that lot, and you need bacteria to provide the nutrients that plants need.
    Suggest you re-examine what you're doing, and perhaps start again.

  • 16 years ago

    That is weird.

    I would research all your questions but I am too busy right now researching for answers to my questions.

    Would you please do me a favor and research the answers to your questions and post the answers back here for everyone to read.

    Thank You
    Garden Dawgie

  • 16 years ago

    I find spinach very hard to grow due to the fast change of temperature in the far north. BY the time it is up the temps are too hot and bolting a big problem. You might try to grow it in the fall and use a frost cover over it. I now grow it in my high tunnel. I plant the last of August through September. If a planting does not look good I pull the plants and replant the area with new plants.I still have spinach growing and there is snow on the ground and freezing nights.
    I am not an expert on soil but that looks like a 5-1-1 Tapla mix I would not add sand unless a container grower was to recommend it. Did you have good sun? Have you added the fertilizer as recommended? It seems that you should be growing good vegetables in that soil! Are your plants too close together? If they are they will be small
    Maybe Al will see this and give a hand?

    Curt

  • 16 years ago

    I feel I was wrong about the soil and root vegetables I have no experience with your mix and root vegetables I only know about the Spinach with a mix like that. I grow many root crops but in a different container mix than what you have or in the ground. Did the soil cause the roots to fork?

    Curt

  • 16 years ago

    Where's the fertilizer?

  • 16 years ago

    My spinach, lettuce, root vegetables all do fine seeded in heavy clay loam soil.
    IMHO it is heat stress which causes poor germination and poor root development. Heat stress and dry-out seem to be the biggest issues with container gardening - both hated by cold weather crops and root vegetables.
    I also agree with beeman_gardener - where are the microbes?

  • 16 years ago

    Spinach likes cool weather and any heat does it in. I haven't had any luck growing spinach. I don't have enough cool weather without freezing; it's either too cold or too warm for spinach at my place.

    Root vegetables don't like lumps in the soil. So maybe bark isn't ideal.

    If you are growing in containers, I suggest that you continue with the soil that you are using, but do a different soil just for your carrots and root vegetables. For the carrots in containers, perhaps a mixture of sand and peat, I'm guessing 2/3 sand and 1/3 peat, with a little bit of perlitte mixed in to reduce the weight of the container if you move your containers around.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm not a genius with gardening, however I do know that direct sowing stuff in a plot in the ground, and container gardening are very different.

    When I tried to make a "soil" recipe that was like soil in the ground for container gardening, it was a disaster.

    I'm also a bit confused because when I asked if I should add sand to original soil recipe for container gardening for root vegetables somebody gave me the advice of "you shouldn't add something to the original 'recipe' unless the instructions tell you too. Yet at the same time, I have people telling me I should make it more like "soil" in the ground, even though initially I was told not to mess with
    the recipe unless the instructions said what variations I could and couldn't do.

    In regards to you should add more fertilizer to it, well the main problem is I couldn't find something for micronutrients, something my recipe was lacking although the recipe did call for it. I didn't add it cause I couldn't find it. I didn't even know there was such a thing as "benefical microbes that help the soil" until somebody mentioned it. I did find something called microbe tea; is this what you're talking about?

    How much of it should I add to the big batch of soil?
    In regards to the micronutrients here is this....

    http://www.gardeners.com/PHC-All-Purpose/FlowerGardening_FertilizersSoil,34-976,default,cp.htm

    Could I just add that mix to my soil mixture as is (dry) and would it still work?

    http://www.tandjenterprises.com/CCPRO/ecom-prodshow/prebrewedteaoneqt.html

    I'm wondering for root veggies is the depth of my containers to shallow? In general my containers vary with their depth (it depends on how big the container is) but they're generally between 9-18" deep.