Software
Houzz Logo Print
wild_forager

zone requirements

19 years ago

When a tree has a minimum zone of 7 lets say, I know that referring to how much cold weather it can handle. But if I planted a zone 7 tree in zone 6, is it the root system that's likely to suffer or the actual trunk and branches? For instance, if I planted a zone 7 tree in zone 6, but in a hole cut into concrete, would the heat retined by the concrete over the soil protect the root system enough to lower it's zone requirments or would the rest of the tree still suffer?

Comments (5)

  • 19 years ago

    wild forager:

    You have to be more specific about what kind of tree you are talking about. Zone recommendations are only estimates, and deal with many factors other than simply the survivability of the roots, trunk, or branches. For many fruit tree types, such as peaches and other stone fruits, zone limitations deal primarily with bud hardiness, especially of the blossom buds. You might be able to grow a survivor peach tree in zone 3, but it would do no good since the blossom buds cannot stand the winter cold. When you begin to get into really cold zones, there are certain apple rootstocks (like Antonovka) that survive severe winter conditions better than others, and there are peach trees (like Reliance) that have better bud hardiness than others.

    Growing any fruiting tree in a hole cut in concrete is not a particularly good idea, for a list of reasons that is too long for this message.

    If you tell us what type of tree you plan to plant, the variety, and exactly where you are located, you might get some useful suggestions on whether pushing the zone limits is a practical idea for your intended tree and location.

    Don Yellman, Great Falls, VA

  • 19 years ago

    Well, I'm in zone 6b. The tree is a Tanenashi Persimmon, minimum zone 7. I wanted to create an opening in the slab near the edge of my yard to plant the tree. The edge touches a neighbors yard where there is no concrete and plenty of soil (I assume the roots would head that direction).

  • 19 years ago

    Asian persimmons tend to be grafted on to native persimmon stock so the roots are not the problem. So if the tree doesn't make it through the winter you will get a big seedling persimmon sprouting from the roots. I have a couple of those right now.

    Asian persimmons are also oddballs in how they overwinter, I have yet to completely figure it out. I think they have problems with drying out, and the point of various freeze/thaw cycles in the spring can cause them to croak. But I would say its worth an experiment with Tanenashi. Some places rate that one in zone 6 I think. There are a few known for being a bit more hardy, and a few known for being a bit less. Hachiya is one of the supposedly less hardy ones, but my tree is still alive after five years, and others have succumbed. If you haven't bought the tree yet I would consider getting a Great Wall, Sheng, or Saijo since they have some of the most proven hardiness.

    Scott

  • 19 years ago

    I'm not sure about Tanenashi, but I planted Saijo (3 gallon potted plant) last fall in zone 6/7, Southwest Virginia. I've seen it listed as 6 or 7 through different nurseries. We didn't have a terrible winter, but did get the brutal Easter freeze just as Saijo was pushing buds. I feared it's doom as the new growth began turning black, but a couple weeks after the weather broke it rebounded and put on some nice growth. I've read that a lot of Kaki's can take low winter temps but that the early or late freezes can do them in.

    I say go for it if you already have it, if not, go with Scott's recommendations. As to planting, you'll probably be fine up against concrete as long as one side has room to spread, they have a nice taproot to sustain em. At worst it might dwarf the tree a bit.

    Good Luck,
    JB

  • 19 years ago

    I've got Tanenashi grafted & growing here, but it's only been through one winter so far.
    As Scott suggested, Saijo, Great Wall, Sheng, Hokkaido and others are proven to survive and fruit in many zone 6 locations.
    I'm of the opinion that high-working(grafting 4-6 ft(or more) above ground) can lend some improved survival for some 'tender' varieties, but then, every once in a while, something odd will happen, and they'll get nuked anyway.

    In my orchard, this spring, almost all my kaki persimmons were still tightly dormant when the Easter Big Freeze struck - it was the grafted American persimmon varieties, well into leafing out at the time, that took the most severe hit, with many frozen back beyond the graft union to ground level.