Software
Houzz Logo Print
scottfsmith

Plum varieties 2011

15 years ago

Here is how various plums did for me this year. Please add your comments on your plums. I had a great year for the Jap types with good pollination and low curc/moth counts, but too much rot for the Euros which I had a good load on but lost nearly all. I feel like I have done enough rot resistance experiments on them and will be doing a lot more spraying for rot next year.

Spring Satin - did not spray Surround early enough and got heavy curc bites, most dropped. Still have a dozen I will be able to taste. Taste-wise, the soft ones are excellent this year! The plums are also much larger than before, I think my tree was too small to produce good fruits last time. It is similar to Flavor Supreme when soft, needs to get quite soft on the tree to get there. The just-soft ones are also very good but they need to soften a lot to get the top flavor.

Flavor Supreme - set more than usual, a dozen or so on my 10-year old tree, but birds and/or squirrels got many of them. Too bad because its still my best tasting plum overall I would say. RIch, juicy, sweet.

Santa Rosa - Excellent as usual. Got a huge load of them this year, much more than any previous year -- usually I get only a couple dozen on my large tree.

Shiro - I am finally learning how late these guys need to be picked, into the definitely yellow phase, and they are growing on me. Lots of subtle flavors in those late fruits - pineapple, mint, etc.

Sprite - only eating unripe ones, they need to get very dark before ripe, like a cherry. Not much flavor at all in unripe ones. .. squirrels got the few ripe ones.

Weeping Santa Rosa - got a good load of these for the first time. They seem almost identical to SR, more round shape perhaps. No rot in spite of being surrounded by plums prone to rot. Maybe a touch better than Santa Rosa.

Purple Heart - has a wonderful rich flavor not too different than Satsuma. Unfortunately the squirrels also love this one and I have yet to have a fully ripe one.

Wickson - again rotting a lot. WSR right next to it doing much better. Give up on this guy already? Note that unlike some varieties they don't all rot; it seems like half catch the disease and the rest are more resistant somehow. They also get those pitch pockets. Its a good plum with a nice unusual (pineapple-y?) flavor but just doesn't seem worth it.

Satsuma - starting to come in now and excellent of course! Has the texture of a soft turkish delight (the non-nut kind) and a subtle spicy flavor when perfectly ripe -- wonderful! Make sure to leave on a long time, when they are totally dark and the flesh is getting a bit of that jelly-like texture. Too long though and they are mushy and have less flavor. They are still good at all stages and since they are so productive it is handy to be able to pick them over such a long period. Overall this is still my best plum, its super easy, super productive, super reliable, and super tasty!

Ruby Queen - a very nice plum. Has the big advantage of being much later than my other Japanese plums so its worth keeping. Main problem is dropping, it seems to drop right before its ready; this could be due to the immaturity of my tree. Also had many split this year. Flavor reminds me of the Flavor King, sour but sweet and aromatic.

Euro plum

General Hand - very heavy curc problems, lost all. Coes GD grafted onto the same tree got hardly any curc bites, so it shows the curcs preferences.

Rosy Gage - got a big load on these but they are highly prone to rot and I never got to taste a fully ripe one.

French Petite - all rotted sigh. They tried to hold out but it was a bad rot year.

Coes Golden Drop - this guy seems far less rot prone than the rest of the Euros. Maybe its the one to keep. Ripened on vacation so didn't get any, sigh.

Middleburg - a late plum which is wonderfully rich and plummy tasting. As good as the best Euros I have had.

Pozecaga (sic) - had a couple which may not have been completely ripe; reminded me of Fellenburg.

Scott

Comments (14)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Scott:

    Do you consider Flavor Supreme to be better than Flavor King? I would say my best plum/pluot are Flavor King and Flavor Finale. But quality varies a lot for these fruits. Finale needs about 24-26 brix to equal King at 18-20 brix.

    Flavor Supreme varies a lot. The high brix firm ones are very good. In CA they can go bad in hot weather. For me it's all about water.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Scott, it is interesting that you aren't trying any E plums that are less prone to rotting. I know you enjoy growing rare varieties known for amazing flavor but you've found that J. plums from your trees are a completely different experience when allowed to ripen fully and same is true of many E types.

    For instance in my orchard Oullins is often touted as being an exceptionally good plum with a wonderful and unusual flavor but a truly ripe Valor which is often not rated that highly is as good to me- with a wonderful balance of sweet and tart and very high brix in general. I think the flavor is more interesting than any J. plum.

    The Oullins is highly prone to cracking and rot but the Valor is usually much less so- although this year it did suffer greatly from very excessive warm rain late.

    Warm weather and rain do much more harm to E. plums as they ripen than cool wet conditions, I think, so you might have luck with the later Euro varieties of which Coe's is a member according to Raintree. I'm surprised that you aren't picking it now judging from their description of late Oct for it.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hman, let me know of some Euro rot-resistant varieties and I will try them out. I thought all the Euros were bad for rot so I never looked for resistant ones. Valor sounds very interesting to me. Its too bad the new Rosy Gage is so bad, I guess Cornell could not make Gages any less rot prone.

    I don't know where my Coes went, they disappeared on my vacation in August. But looking at past notes their harvest date was late August for me. So it sounds like Raintree has that date wrong.

    Fruitnut, I have not had good samples on my Flavor King, it rots every year (this year included). My Flavor Supremes are always excellent if I get them at the right ripeness.

    Scott

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Love these discussions of "best varieties". Cause we all want 2 things: best fruit and how to succeed growing them.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know Flavor King has it's problems with rot and cracking in a humid climate. I've had neither problem the last 6-7 years. What stands out for me about this variety is above all else the flavor. By far the best of any plum/pluot I've eaten.

    The flavor is so good that it doesn't need to be grown at a water deficit to be superb. So I'm getting big fruit and superb eating at a higher water level than any other pluot. It seems to me that this is a potential advantage in a humid climate.

    I like most of the pluot best at brix levels of 24-32. On most I can get at least some mid 20s each year. With Flavor King high teens is all that is needed to have superb fruit.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Fascinating that you are able to grow Flavor Supreme in the East. It blooms very, very early for me in the lower Central Valley of California. I had better than usual set this year, but the fruit were not good due to hot weather during ripening. Even in good years, the quality is best for me if I pick them just as they start to ripen.

    Spring Satin is described as "33% sugar" by some vendors. The originator called it "Tart until ripe" or something like that. What is your assessment of its sweetness?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I would agree that Spring Satin is very sweet, its even sweeter than my Flavor Supremes. It also tastes in that same general category.

    I can grow Flavor Supreme in the east but I don't recommend it, it doesn't pollinate well at all.

    Scott

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I will dig up this thread from the dead to post my own 2011 Plum experiences...

    Green Gage - Turned out to be a red/purple plum with yellow flesh (Oops!)... Tart skin, meat is sweet with a decidedly Pear flavor. I will let it go through 2012 to see how it does... Does this sound like a Santa Rosa?

    Italian Prune Plum - Total bust! Dry, mealy, and bitter. I am giving it 1 more year... I really think it's too hot and the summer is too long here - it drops all it's leaves in Early August from the heat (not good!) and then tries to leaf back out in late September.... If it's not good this year - it's getting dug up. Anyone want an Italian Prune Plum to try out? It's still dormant... Pay shipping and it's yours!

    Red leaf American plum - As usual, a reliable performer for Jelly.... These are very bitter until 100% completely ripe - and then, they have a very high sugar and are very tart... I like eating them ripe, but I love them in Jelly....

    From the sound of it - I really need a Damson plum and a Shiro and maybe a Satsuma!

    I so want to try out a European plum, but I really believe it's probably too hot and the summers are too long for them here...

    Thanks

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Euro plums will ripen off the tree, which is an advantage in the rot wars.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Climate wise I'm probably halfway between Scott and John, so both of your recommendations are very interesting to me. The nearest fruit extension agent recommended European plums to me here because he said that our late spring frosts are really hard on plums and that European plums don't bloom quite as early. I'm not going to be spraying, though, so Scott's comments about the Europeans being more susceptible to rot along with the comments about Satsuma plum being super easy, super productive, and super reliable have me wondering if I got it all backwards. I'm also wondering about pollination. Is it true that Europeans are completely self-fertile? I have a damson next to an 'autumn sweet' and then I've got a 'yellow egg' a couple hundred feet away with a big barn in between. Will damsons or chickasaws or apricots pollinate European or Japanese plums?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes - it's true that the European plums bloom out quite late... That Italian Prune doesn't do anything till past Easter... It's still sitting there, sleeping away... Buds haven't even started swelling yet. But.. It will kick off probably somewhere around June 1st...

    Like I said - if you want it, you are welcome to it... I live down by Clemson if you need an excuse for a short road trip...

    Thanks

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Stanley, I know, is completely self-fertile.

    I wouldn't try growing plums without spraying. Curculio is just too much of a problem, and Japanese beetles if you have them. And if any sound fruits are left on the tree by August, you need to worry about rot.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Scott, I thought you were growing LaCrescent. Descriptions in this forum left me coveting it.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Murky, I was (past tense) growing it. I had problems of rot, splitting and mealiness so I took it out a few years ago. Note that I was never 100% sure it was La Crescent, it was a plum I found growing in my parents backyard that was planted in the early 20th century. It completely matched every description I could find of La Crescent so I assumed that is what it was.

    Scott