Software
Houzz Logo Print
harvestmann

How to plant a tree

15 years ago

http://cmg.colostate.edu/gardennotes/633.pdf

I found this while looking for information about the need to remove wire baskets when transplanting large nursery trees. There are some things here that contradict the accepted methods of planting 20 years ago when I was a hort student- some of which is methodology I already figured out but some that contradicts how I've been planting stock.

I thought it might be of interest to anyone who sometimes transplants trees and might be a starting point for a discussion on the subject. It is the first I've read of how adding amendments to back fill can be useful with specific guidelines, and seems to be an evolution from and even a contradiction of Carl Whitcomb's original research on the subject. I probably point this out because this is one area where the proscribed methodology is close to my current technique.

There's a lot of concern about girdling roots which don't seem to be a big problem with the fruit trees I manage- maybe because fruit trees are usually planted with the graft union as a guideline and it is never buried.

It is also recommended that trees be planted so the graft unions always be facing north for reasons I don't understand. I always plant trees so the part of the tree with best branch development faces north.

Anyway, I hope some of you enjoy this.

Comments (11)

  • 15 years ago

    Very good information.

  • 15 years ago

    Interesting!

    Here is a link that might be useful: How to plant a tree

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks Fruitnut, someday I have to have my wife show me how to make a link. Others who come to this thread will think that it's another article though.

    Have any of you ever lost a fruit tree to girdling roots? I suggested that fruit trees aren't planted too deep because the graft union would make it easy to avoid but that was careless of me based on early morning brain freeze- I've seen plenty of fruit trees planted too deep but never seen any die as a result.

  • 15 years ago

    Harvestman,

    I have never had it happen or even seen it happen.....I did notice in the article a couple things I have been doing that is apparently wrong lol.

  • 15 years ago

    I've never lost a fruit tree to circling roots. In fact I've lost very few to anything. But my soil has always been at least moderately well draining. In the article they keep talking about poor oxygen levels in the soil outside the planting hole. That is probably a key factor.

    I usually haven't needed to stake bare root trees. But cutting them back hard really helps in that regard.

  • 15 years ago

    The only thing I can make out in regards to the "dogleg to the north" thing is the idea that the more horizontal surface of the bend would receive a more intense winter sun...but that seems pretty thin.

    Never seen encircling roots on apple, and I have intentionally planted a number of trees deep to get them to partially self root. To be fair I have only pulled roots from a few of these at a later date. but i do dig down to the flare each year inspecting for borers.
    I have seen it several times with honey locust landscaping.

  • 15 years ago

    I've seen very damaging girdling roots on improperly planted maples- that is planted too deep- but this article indicates that crabapples are also prone to having this problem and that would suggest that apples would also be. I have seen old apple trees with girdling roots but these trees had already made it for over 100 years and I suspect that the roots simply graft to the trunk they press against. It is common to see this grafting process on formerly rubbing branches that merged tissue.

    The other two points in this article I found interesting and maybe a bit dubious was the idea that trees shouldn't be mulched over the root ball after transplanting because the mulch could divert water from that root ball. Also of interest is the proscribed shape of the planting hole. The shape of the planting hole suggested immediately slopes upward beyond the root ball to encourage lower roots to go to shallow and more oxygen rich soil. It would seem that this might discourage anchorage- particularly in compacted soils.

  • 15 years ago

    I always mulch right over the root ball with wood chips. Never have seen a problem with over 50 trees. I really don't waste much time planting trees anymore. Just dig the hole, drop the tree in and push the soil back up around the rootball (if container grown). Bare root take a little more time to try to keep the tree high enough. I know I've planted trees too deep in the past and have also planted trees so shallow that the roots are exposed on top. In both cases I really haven't had any issues. I think this sandbox I grow in might help when it comes to drainage. I also know that mulch around the trees supercharge them vs letting grass grow around the trunk. In my opinion, that is the most important thing when planting trees (mulch) or at least it is in my sandy soil.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks harvestman,this information changes how I will plant from here on out.Brady

  • 15 years ago

    It is true that cardboard or matted leaves will divert water, and shredded wood might when it is fresh. But wood chips let it through reliably.

  • 15 years ago

    In the many years in wholesale ornamental nursery sales we never recommended taking the wirebaskets off, especially if using a skidsteer with forks to place tree in hole. For starters, it's not necessary. Besides that, sometimes the original media may be disturbed as the basket is removed that might not be visible behind the burlap. I've seen instances where nursery men attempt it, and large chunks fall off, taking the burlap off with it and most of the rootball. I can't imagine it as it maintains the integrity of the ball and minimizes root damage. Air pockets are more likely to form. I only untie the basket and tuck the burlap and extra wire under the soil. But what do I know...
    Noogy