Software
Houzz Logo Print
carduus

Pawpaw Questions

16 years ago

Hello fruit-types,

I?ve always wanted a fruit tree, but unfortunately, my yard is much too small and shady to support the most common types. In the last couple years, though, I?ve been pondering getting a pawpaw. I have a few questions, though.

First, the shade issue. On the eastern edge of my yard, there are several trees against a five foot picket fence, including a 100+ foot oak, a 30 foot maple, and a few others of 50-100 feet. I?m pondering removing the maple tree, as it?s close enough to the oak that it?s starting to weave into its lowermost branches. It does just fine in the spot for now, probably getting around 5 hours of direct sunlight, and a few hours of extremely dappled sun through the oak. If I put the pawpaw in this spot, however, it will be shaded by the fence until it grows above it and only get about 2 hours of evening sun. Will a pawpaw grow in these conditions long enough to get above the fence and get the additional sunlight?

Second, the space issue. How readily do pawpaws accept grafting? If I got two different varieties, took a scion from both, and attempted to graft each to the other tree, can I be reasonably certain that at least one of the two will take? Will this still work if they?re already grafted to rootstock? What kind of grafting works best for pawpaws? I?m asking because I don?t have room to plant two trees, and am reasonably certain that no one else in my neighborhood has a pawpaw, so I figured grafting an alternate variety would increase pollination. Would this be the case?

Last, pawpaw varieties. Obviously if I want cross-pollination, the two varieties have to bloom at the same time. What?s your favorite pawpaw variety that blooms at the same time as Susquehanna?

Thank you for any help you can provide.

Comments (24)

  • 16 years ago

    >If I put the pawpaw in this spot, however, it will be shaded by the fence until it
    >grows above it and only get about 2 hours of evening sun. Will a pawpaw grow
    >in these conditions long enough to get above the fence and get the additional
    >sunlight?

    Yes. Pawpaws are usually an understory tree, and will grow in the shade, although they will be more productive in the sun. The spot sounds fine.

    I don't know how easy it is to multigraft paw paws, but I've never heard that there are any problems with that, I think it's a good approach. Another option is to plant two close together. They frequently form clumps in nature, due to their suckering tendency. I've seen productive trees planted just a few feet apart.

    Re: cross pollination, the flowers do not open all at once like on an apple or pear tree, it's spread out over a couple weeks. I don't think you have to worry about this being a problem.

    They do vary quite a bit in ripening time, both between varieties and on a single tree (one tree produces ripe fruit over a several day/couple week period). Susquehanna is one of the later ripening ones I think, so you might look for something that ripens early to spread out your harvest. Shenandoah ripens a few weeks before Susquehanna. Catalog descriptions often mention relative ripening times.

    Alex

  • 16 years ago

    Any type of grafting works for pawpaws except t budding. I've used chip budding successfully.

    Here is a link that might be useful: mrtexas

  • 16 years ago

    To me, Susquehana has a strong Pawpaw flavor that I like, however, with 2 cultivars, cumulative yield might be a factor worth considering. Wabash and 10-35 won the taste tests in 08 and 09 at Kentucky State, and they both produce about twice the yield of fruit as a Suaquehana, which was included in the test both years.

    Benny

  • 16 years ago

    At the KSU field day last month, someone asked a similar question. Response:

    Topwork one tree with different varieties if you are comfortable with grafting.

    or

    Plant two trees in the same hole. They will sort of intertwine, with both being productive.

  • 16 years ago

    Marc5,

    I noticed on another thread that you mentioned your having several hundred pawpaw trees. That sounds very interesting. Are you growing them for commercial fruit production or for variety trials or what? Just curious.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for all of your help so far! I've read a bunch on grafting, but haven't managed to do it successfully yet, so maybe this two trees-one hole solution might be best if there aren't any downsides. Bennyl, you talk about increasing yield, but my family can't eat a whole bunch of pawpaws, and there's only so many friends who like the taste. Can they be frozen or otherwise preserved?

  • 16 years ago

    Brandon,
    We've become very fond of pawpaws--a tropical fruit flavor native to the Midwest. They are really quite amazing. We've decided to go all in with pawpaws, after casting about for ideas on how to best put our farm to use. Our goal is a commercial fruit orchard, or "patch" as I prefer to say. Who knows how it will turn out, but it will be a fun ride. I could probably write a small book with what I have learned after only one year. One cold hard fact: raccoons love newly germinated seed.

  • 16 years ago

    Carduus,

    The two-trees, one-hole solution seems to be something that has become more popular in recent years. I guess it's mostly because yards and spaces people have to plant trees are becoming smaller and smaller. Personally, I'm not a big fan of the technique. I think that the potential problems (particularly the instability of the two trees compared to a single-trunked specimen) outweigh the benefits. I think that's also been the general consensus when this was discussed in the forum before.

    I do like the idea of topworking the tree. One option you may have is contacting someone else in your area with grafting experience and have them help you with the graft. I think most gardeners actually enjoy getting to know their fellow local gardeners and sharing the experience. It seems like I am always so busy, but if someone here locally ask me for help with a project that simple (at least time consumption-wise) and I had the knowledge and skill to help (although I've worked quite a bit with pawpaws, I've never actually grafted one), I'd love to lend them a hand.

    Of course the other side to that coin is that if you try it yourself, you will learn something even if you aren't successful the first time. Maybe consider the possibility of failure when you choose the graft location, and just see what happens.

    A third option, which you may have already examined and/or dismissed, is to plant another variety in some other location in your yard. Close proximity does help germination rates, but spacing in an average size yard should be fine.
    _______________________________________

    Marc5,

    I know what you mean. I am particularly attracted to pawpaws also. I really like the taste of the better ones, but I think their "novelty" also attracts me to some degree. If they were as common as apples, I don't know if I would be as found of them or not.

    From what little I've seen, I think a pawpaw orchard just might work. The demand seems high enough (probably largely because of their novelty), that some places are able to get pretty good prices for them, especially if multiple cultivars are offered.

    I hope you are taking good notes. Pawpaw information isn't nearly as readily available as info on more common types of fruit. A pawpaw info website would be really cool.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for the info, Brandon7. I'll put feelers out for people with grafting experience in my area, then. Unfortunately, my 1/3 acre heavily-treed yard just doesn't have the room for another without removing a large tree or placing one smack dab in the middle of my vegetable garden. As is, this spot is 15 feet from a 100+ foot oak, and 20 feet from a 30 foot pine, so it will be fitting quite snugly by the time it reaches full width.

  • 16 years ago

    I've done quite a few pawpaw grafts, and when working with good materials, I've found simple grafting onto two or three year old rootstock to be pretty straightforward with high rates of success. But when you mention topworking, I take it that you have in mind adding additional cultivars onto an established tree, as is easily and not uncommonly done by those grafting apples or pears. This I've found to be much more challenging with pawpaws when following usual grafting practices.

    With some revisions, the idea of planting two trees in a hole may not be a bad idea for pawpaw. The greatest part of their root mass consists of a taproot, and root growth is largely vertical, so there would be less root competition between the two trees than would be the case with species having a more fibrous or shallow root structure. The detrimental effects of shading caused by the close placement would also be less pronounced because of the pawpaw's inate tolerance of shade. I wouldn't advise putting them too close together though, maybe 2.5 or 3 feet apart would work.

  • 16 years ago

    Creekweb, I'm curious about your experience with topworking pawpaws. Have you found it more challenging because of the type of grafts or is there another reason?

    About the taproot...On very young pawpaw seedling, the root mass is mainly concentrated in the tap root. But, the taproot comprises a very minor part of the root system of a mature tree. The root system of larger pawpaw trees is probably somewhat less shallow than the "average" tree, but not by much. About 90% of the rootmass can be found in the top 24" of soil, in most soil types.

    I agree that it would likely be less problematic if you planted the trees about 2.5' to 3' apart as compared to planting more closely, but I'd still personally prefer more traditional spacing with topworking when multiple varieties are needed in very small spaces.

  • 16 years ago

    Brandon7,
    I use the word "challenging" to describe my efforts in topworking pawpaws just because I haven't given up, and I remain optimistic that I will figure out a successful technique, but my experience so far has been that the grafts just don't take - the semi-mature trees I graft onto just reject the scions. This has been discussed on this forum before with experiences shared that larger pawpaw trees will accept grafts if the trees are severely cut back or effectively turned back into large rootstocks; but this is not topworking as I believe the OP envisions. I'd say actually topworking the trees - maintaining the original and adding other varieties - can probably be done with some effort, but this is not a project I would propose for a first time grafter.

    Regarding the taproot, I can say that having transplanted a number of 7-9 foot fruit-bearing aged pawpaws from their beds to their permanent locations that the taproot at this stage of the trees' development is prominent in their root systems within the first 2 feet and beyond. This phase in the tree's development when it becomes established may well be the most critical time for the tree, and I believe this root conformation makes it more amenable to closely spaced plantings than species lacking taproots.

  • 16 years ago

    Creekweb,
    I would be interested in hearing more about your pawpaw transplanting from beds. Moving 7'-9' trees seems remarkable. Bare root or root balls with soil?

    In grafting smaller rootstocks, I have had good luck with cleft grafting. This appears to me to be as good or better a method than budding, but budding is certainly a more efficient use of scionwood which is in short supply. I hope to have more scionwood next year, both for small seedlings and topworking wild patches. I too am searching for the best method for topworking larger trees.

    Brandon, are you familiar with the Kentucky State University pawpaw website? It'a a great resource.

    http://www.pawpaw.kysu.edu/

    There is a yahoo pawpaw group, but you will see more pawpaw-related material here than there.

  • 16 years ago

    I was originally picturing cutting an upper branch of two straight-from-the-nursery 2-4' trees with rootstock already grafted on by the nursery, grafting each branch to the spot where the other branch was taken, and planting whichever tree took the grafting. However, I have no experience in this, so this may be an overly simplistic view.

    Okay, now I'm totally unsure about the viability of the two tree method, especially considering the 100+ foot oak is likely infringing somewhat on the rootspace of this tree, so I don't want to have two mouths to feed in that space.

  • 16 years ago

    marc5,

    I've use parts of the KSU website quite a few times, but wasn't aware of the yahoo group. Thanks, I'll have to check that out.

    Carduus,

    Were you planning on staring with a larger (B&B) pawpaw? If not, maybe you wouldn't have to worry about the difficulty of topworking a larger tree. I'm a little surprised that I missed the pawpaw grafting discussion Creekweb mentioned. I will link it below, in case you or anyone wants to read it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: summer budding of pawpaws

  • 16 years ago

    Marc5,
    Lots of trees and too little time, so the small seedlings I had placed in 2 foot high beds until I got around to planting them in their permanent spots had grown into 7 to 9 foot saplings. These had grown vigorously despite a density of almost 2 trees per square foot within the beds. There is a short interval of time in early spring when the buds just start to swell that I think is best for digging pawpaws. So during that time I began transplanting by digging a trench about 2 feet deep along one side of the beds and then removed trees and roots in blocks of about 5 trees at a time and about 3 feet deep. This is the hardest part of the project as the blocks have to be carefully separated from the rest of the bed keeping root damage to a minimum. Once the blocks were freed, I removed as much of the soil as possible by spraying and soaking in water. At that point the roots of the individual trees could be teased apart pretty easily from one another. I pruned the taproot to about 3 feet and immediately planted each tree in a 3x3 hole dug previously. I have had good results with this method, mostly avoiding the signs of transplantation shock often seen with displaced pawpaws, but it would have been a whole lot easier if I could have planted them in the same spots as little seedlings a few years ago.

  • 16 years ago

    Carduus, the pulp can be frozen, and the Kentucky State website has lots of recipes.
    Benny

  • 16 years ago

    Creekweb,
    Wow, that sounds like a lot of work, but I apppreciate how quickly growing things can get away from you. These "2 foot high beds".....are these raised beds? Have you experimented with tree pots or air-pruning beds?

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, the beds are raised - a good way to quickly dispatch a bunch of pawpaw seedlings - I squeezed nearly 80 seedlings in 40 square feet of beds with good results.
    I do use containers also. I find these to be the best way to give intensive care for pawpaws sent from elsewhere to help mitigate transplantation shock. Maybe sounds like going a little overboard, but I believe a wise approach given how hard it is to get some varieties like some of the Peterson ones. Pawpaws do fine in pots in the short term but very quickly become root bound. Rather than plant the potted pawpaw directly in the ground, in the spring I soak the roots in water and turn it into a bareroot tree. The root bound roots are not lignified and so can be salvaged in this case rather than need to be pruned off.

  • 16 years ago

    Brandon7, I wasn't planning on a large tree, but what do you mean I wouldn't have to worry? As in, it's not possible, or as in, it's easy?

    Bennyl: Thank you.

  • 16 years ago

    I meant it sounds like the problems mentioned are associated with grafting onto more mature/larger trees, so maybe you'd have a better chance starting with smaller trees.

  • 16 years ago

    I put several grafts onto my Pennsylvania Golden and Wilson pawpaws that were 2-3 years in the ground. I only had 2 scion maybe 10" long to work with so I used very small pieces that may not have been perfect fits get as many chances as possible.

    I think I did mostly whip and tongue.

    I believe more than half of the grafts were successful. Typically on apple, pear, plum I get 90+ % but I usually have a lot of scion wood to choose from.

  • 16 years ago

    Does a pawpaw have different nutritional needs than other trees? Is it a high-acid lover, considering it hangs out on forest edges?

  • 16 years ago

    Per KSU pawpaw planting guide:

    http://www.pawpaw.kysu.edu/pawpaw/ppg.htm

    Pawpaws need a pH of 5.5 to 7. I'm thinking about using my old blueberry bed--now vacant due to the effects of phomopsis twig blight--for a pawpaw seedling bed. PH is 5.5, on the low side, but perhaps OK for pawpaws.