Software
Houzz Logo Print
thomis

collar rot

16 years ago

So far I've lost 2 of 4 apple trees on mm111 to collar rot. Today I noticed what appears to be collar rot taking form on the third tree. The trees have trunk protectors so I am convinced that it is not the work of voles.

I have nearly 30 trees on bud 9 and it seems to not affect the bud 9 trees.

Does this look like collar rot to you and does it affect your trees on mm111?

{{gwi:125788}}âÂÂ>

{{gwi:125789}}âÂÂ>

{{gwi:125790}}âÂÂ>

{{gwi:125791}}âÂÂ>

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    Those trees look 100% healthy to me. MM 106 is the root that is supposed to have that problem. I've never lost an apple tree from disease of any kind.

  • 16 years ago

    Those trees look healthy to me. Dig the soil back away from the rootstock to show us better. I planted my HONEY CRISP MM106 leaving 2 inches of exposed rootstock. My soil is really light and sandy though, had they been on heavier soil it would be a loss. The part of the rootstock that is covered below ground on the MM106(for me that is) was showing fisure type scratches...weird. Not collar rot.

    You say you lost these trees?
    MM111 is said to tolerate heavy soils...not sure why, the tree turned purplish leaves fell?

  • 16 years ago

    How do you post pics like this?

  • 16 years ago

    Correct me if I'm wrong but what I do is cultivate by hand using those hand cultivator's to aerate the trees roots around the soil surface of the tree, is this bad, I am cutting some small roots sometimes. Is this necessary or should I just leave the soil surface be like "Thomis" does and leave it to stay hard, I find the trees will drink water and nutrients better.

  • 16 years ago

    Last year I lost a Fuji on M111 due to collar rot, and I don't believe the photo's show collar rot. If the new growth also exhibits signs of what looks like fire blight,
    then you probably have collar rot. The only way to really tell, is to expose the roots.

  • 16 years ago

    This is a pic of the second tree I lost to collar rot. The first pics I posted (above) I believe show the initial stage of collar rot. It is not far advanced but it's what the tree below look like before it turned bad and died.

    {{gwi:125792}}âÂÂ>

  • 16 years ago

    you must have a low spot there, you probably should use that phosphate anti bacterial collar rot disinfectant. I believe it is called R gold something. Do you have clay there?
    is this the asphalt tree sealer tar you put on the tree or is this the infection?

  • 16 years ago

    kokos, I have a sub clay layer in the hardpan. It does inhibit drainage somewhat and I know it promotes such things as collar rot. The black is not asphalt tree sealer.

    The trees on bud 9 are not affected and they are the ones I really care about. If I could do it all over again I would plant all the trees on a trellis using bud 9 rootstock. My trellis grown trees are the healthiest and by far the most attractive.

    Open a flickr or photobucket account kokos, and then email me. I will walk you through the foto posting process.

  • 16 years ago

    There's the problem, there is water there. You know what there is a way to solve this. Hire a bulldozer D8 or D9 with 1 metre long rippers and wreak proper havoc on the earth that has this hardpan. That's what I did!
    The heavier the dozer the better. Only problem is if there's not a lot of work in terms of hours spent they don't come for small jobs.

    Bud 9 is Highly resistant to Collar rot and it is shallow rooted, so you won't have a problem there.

    I'll keep in touch with you, I have some rootstock on MM106 I would like to show you.