Software
Houzz Logo Print
justme2_gw

Help with using bagged soil products.

17 years ago

I am building four tall raised beds and will need approximately 100 cu.ft. of organic soil. I must use bagged soil products (because of my bad back I must limit twisting, so shoveling a large amount of soil is out of the question). Could someone give me some advice on what I should use? My plan is to fill the beds with Sta-Green Flower and Vegetable Planting Mix. Do I need to mix this with anything?

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago

    As a rule purchasing any soil is a waste of your money. What is in this "soil" that makes it sell for almost $3.50 per cubic foot? Adding lots of organic matter, much of which you can obtain at little cost, would be much better.

  • 17 years ago

    As a rule purchasing any soil is a waste of your money.

    This is entirely just a matter of opinion. There are countless times when importing soil makes very good sense and is the most practical solution. And too, raised bed gardening is much more akin to container gardening than inground gardening and so one is dealing with far different soil and drainage requirements that a potting soil or planting mix will better address.

    I was not able to pull up the product label, but if you are assured that it is organic in origin (no added synthetic ferts), then go for it. It may be appropriate to include some bagged compost as well, but I'd keep the percentage of that low, generally no more than 25% of the total mix.

    Bulk soil products will always be less expensive than their bagged counterparts. I would investigate what options you have in this regard as the cost of 100cf of bagged soil will be high. Perhaps you could enlist some help to move a bulk soil delivery if you choose this route. It's pretty much a one time shot to fill new raised beds, so maybe family or friends could help out and give your bad back a reprieve :-)

  • 17 years ago

    100 cubic feet of this stuff at 2 cubic feet per bag means around 50 bags at about $6.50 per, or $325.00 for that soil. That is very expensive soil and not worth that. Good soil can be made by the gardener simply by taking the miceral soil they have and adding organic matter to it, and usually for considerably less expense then purchasing an unknown soil.

  • 17 years ago

    kimmsr, you need to spend some time visiting the Container Gardening forum :-) Planting in raised beds is far more closely related to planting in containers than it is to planting in the ground and because of that, special attention should be paid to soil quality. Drainage/water retention and aeration are key, qualities that cannot be adequately met long term with plain ole garden soil and OM.

    And you are totally overlooking the OP's physical limitations, which makes moving garden soil around impractical and purchasing a high grade of bagged potting soil or planting mix very practical, if somewhat expensive. Every gardening situation is unique and issuing blanket declarations that purchasing or importing a quality soil mix is unnecessary and a waste of money is of no benefit.

  • 17 years ago

    I have built eaised beds here and found they are prtty much a large waste of time and energy because a raised bed drains even more quickly here than my native sand, and moving that many bags of "soil" will be harder on someones back, because of the handling, than having a truckload, ot three, delivered and shoveling that where it needs to be.
    I find that handling 2 cubic foot bags of anything harder on my back than shoveling anything into my wheelbarrow and wheeling that where it needs to be, or possibly into the larger cart that can be pulled by the tractor. Picking up bags of anything at the store and loading them onto a cart to get them to my vehicle, picking them from that cart and putting them into my vehicle, unloading them at home and getting them to where they need to be means picking up those bags many times, often requiring movement with your back that is not good for that back.
    Having a truckload of soil, mulch, or whatever dropped on my property as near where it will be used as possible, and then shoveling that into the barrow, wheeling that where it is needed and dumping it and sreading it has always been less strain on my back than handling bags.