Software
Houzz Logo Print
gandle

Guess I got told.

20 years ago

Been taking care and planting neighbors flower

box, about 12'by 2'. She is a widow and semi-invalid and really can't do it herself. Decided to work in some compost and blood meal, bonemeal,alfalfa meal and soy bean meal.

She opened the window above the flower box and said, "I sure hope you aren't putting that horrible rotten smelly stuff in there". I confessed I was and she said, "I wish you wouldn't use that nasty stuff on my property, if you want fertilizer use something clean like Miracle Gro".

I feel sorry for the woman, she can't get around very well but that kind of gets to me. Been taking care of this for 5 years since her husband died and do it with no charge to her. Even buy quite a bit of the flowers myself. Now I don't know what to do.

Comments (18)

  • 20 years ago

    I would roll my eyes in private and continue doing what I was doing -- planting her flower boxes and using organic amendments (although I would probably avoid the stinkiest like fish/kelp meal). She's just being a cranky old lady and I'm sure she'd much rather be able to tend her flowers herself and is a little frustrated as a result. I'd view the outburst as just that -- an outburst -- and I wouldn't take it personally. And if she asks what you're using, I'd lie. Sometimes what you don't know won't hurt you.

  • 20 years ago

    Yeah... I think that Mary is probably right, but my BF thinks the same way.... as if not using Miracle Gro is un-American... he miracle gro's HIS plants and I compost mine... and we do fine that way. I thought that it was something from being born in the 50's.

  • 20 years ago

    I think you have to do what SHE wants..it's HER flower box! And if you cannot do that without feeling it's a problem for you then I don't think you should do this for her ..ask someone else to do it who will not mind doing it her way. I bet the local community center would have people who would volunteer . (I myself do volunteer gardening work for some seniors in my city so I know there are people doing this - and Yes I have learned to do things the way they want..it's not how I would do things but it's not my yard and I know the Earth understands...they are not of bad intent or willfully negligent, they just have their own thoughts on things that they have spent decades solidifying .)

    It's nice to be progressive and it's nice to be nice too - but I have learned that we also all need to learn how to honor people's wishes. Put yourself in her shoes in a different way than you obviously have so far.

    I can totally see how the smell would be traveling up on the warm breezes and she might not like it! I think she has a *sensitive* nose, like me, and doesn't want to SMELL her fertilizer. Yes, it could BE this simple. I leaned my lesson about putting fish fertilizer on my indoor plants myself.

    I don't think that is crazy at all...and if you roll your eyes and continue what you are doing (as Mary suggests) , then you are not really honoring her path - which I think takes away the good karma of planting for her..and then some.

  • 20 years ago

    just lie to her and keep doing what you're doing.

    she's crazy. just like most who don't do it organic ;)

  • 20 years ago

    I can feel your pain, her response does seem very ungrateful.

    At the same time some people have really sensitive noses and evidently she is one of them.

    Maybe you could look at it as a challenge and care for her plants organically, using only non 'smelly' ingredients.

    Alternately you get get an empty bottle of Miracle Grow from someone and fill it up with organic goodness and let her see you use it. Hehehe, that would be evil. ;-)

  • 20 years ago

    Leave out all the this meal and that meal and just use compost. Compost doesn't smell and is packed with nutrients, so why do you need all that other stuff anyway? I don't think you need to use Miracle Grow, I certainly wouldn't. Just don't use things that smell, and she should be fine with it. If the flowers are a little smaller, who really cares? Mine do great without any such purchased products.

    It is one thing to do things somebody else's way if it is your job. If you are volunteering like this for a neighbor, you should do it your way as much as possible while taking her opinions into account, too, in other words, Diplomacy! Organic gardening is enough of a religion (and the one true religion :-) ) that I don't think you need to convert for her.

    Marcia

  • 20 years ago

    Captain Compost once advised someone on this forum to sprinkle sugar in their houseplant pots after fertilizing with fish emulsion because her family was complaining about the smell. She tried it and it worked. I'm not sure of the amount used. Maybe CC will check in here and post. I'm thinking this could work for the outdoor planters as well.

  • 20 years ago

    If all she said was don't use the stinky stuff then I agree to just use compost and nothing else. That way you don't have to use MiracleGro or tell a lie. Think how sad it would be if she didn't have someone to do this for her. I think you are doing a great thing gandle.....what goes around comes around......be just and have mercy.
    Kiki

  • 20 years ago

    I feel that using Miracle gro in a container is not nearly as bad as using it in the ground. In a container, it will not leach away into the groundwater, waterways, and contribute to algal blooms --- One of the biggest environmental problems with chemical fertilizers. Container plants won't do that - it's all contained.

    Some miracle gro products may contain organic fertilizers as well, which she may be satisfied with.

    Some fertilizers (like Doctor Earth) are a consumer product (thus "American"), non-smelly, 100% organic, and may be a happy compromise for you.

  • 20 years ago

    Since you are doing this out of the kindness of your heart, don't compromise your values by using MG.
    I agree that leaving out the stinkier supplements is the best strategy.
    And, I'm sorry she hurt your feelings!

  • 20 years ago

    I have used Miracle Gro before on our hanging baskets at work. I work in a small environmental lab. Just for fun we caught the water that was coming out the bottom of the baskets. What we found was the water that comes out the bottom is just nearly as concentrated as the fert solution that was poured in the top. Keep in mind these are "peat" baskets.
    Gandle, I think it is a good thing that you are helping the elderly lady. Keep up the good work.

  • 20 years ago

    "I feel that using Miracle gro in a container is not nearly as bad as using it in the ground. In a container, it will not leach away into the groundwater, waterways"

    Um, yes it will. Where do you think all the extra water goes when you water the plant and it runs out the bottom holes of the pot?

    I have a dwarf peach tree in a container on my porch. I feed it regularly. Directly below that part of the porch is a rosebush planted in the ground; it gets the runoff water from the peach tree tub and boy howdy, that's the happiest rose you ever saw. I use organic fertilizers but the principle's the same; extra fertilizer goes where extra water does.

    Kristin

  • 20 years ago

    Here in southern California, container plants have trays underneath them to catch the excess water. The water is then absorbed back into the pot.

    I've never (*never*) had a problem with fertilizer spilling onto the ground from a container plant.

    Perhaps in Washington, it being a wet state especially coastally, it is hard to keep plants from being so wet that any extra water spills out. I don't know, not having lived there. That is certainly not a problem here in southern CA, and container plants rarely if ever spill over.

    You're right though - if you aren't able to keep the water from getting into the ground, then you need to take that into account. I've not had that problem personally.

    Best regards, from one gardener and plant lover to another,
    Patty

  • 20 years ago

    Huh. I didn't think of that. I suppose how wet the climate is does make a big difference.

    I would be afraid of root rot if I left excess water in saucers under my plants, except maybe in the very hottest couple months of summer.

    Do you never have to flush out any of the "salts buildup" I hear about, then?

    Kristin

  • 20 years ago

    I've never had to. I've not worried about salts. If they are a problem, they are one that I am blissfully unaware of!

    I associate salt/soil here, with the fact that our area used to be underwater (millions of years ago.) I *believe* that there may be more salt in some soil here, than is optimal, but I don't really know.

    The soil is really alkaline, however, and that may relate back to historic conditions of salinity (I'm not sure.) The pH is above 8 (!) and so many gardening concerns revolve around reducing that.

    Back to the original problem --- i wonder if the woman would feel better if she saw the amendments coming out of a store-bought package. Maybe gandle could recycle some bags into compost-carriers - and get around her concerns that way.

  • 20 years ago

    Since I already had the amendments in the soil I couldn't very well take them out. There shouldn't be much if any odor in the amounts I used. And since she rarely comes outside and her windows are shut practically all the time with the air conditioner running I can't see any problem. She did call and thank me and gave a short lecture on more modern ways of fertilizing. She said "you are acting like a farmer of 60 years ago with no modern fertilizers to use". Just ignored the lecture. And by the way, she is only 76 and I am over 80.

  • 20 years ago

    gandle, I think it is wonderful that you are helping her. Dont take it to personally, some people are just so set in their ways they just cant understand why others dont do it the same.

    I really dont know what to tell you as I have never been in that situation. If your concerned about ground contamination from MG, maybe you could try those spikes that are supposed to slowly release. Just a thought.

    And remember, you are doing a great thing no matter what her reactions to how you do it are.

    Carey

  • 20 years ago

    "No good deed...goes unpunished"

    Henry Luce/Murphy's Law