Software
Houzz Logo Print
annafl_gw

Goldfish in Florida

19 years ago

We have a 17,000-19,000 gallon pond. It is a year old now and we finally have planted enough waterlilies that will create cover for fish. Because we like the plants, we are thinking goldfish rather than koi. However, my concern is that the goldfish will overpopulate and create a problem. I've seen that others have had this problem, but they have been in cooler climates. I think goldfish are cool water fish. My question is, does anyone know if they will have a tendency to overpopulate in a Florida pond this size? Any experience is welcome! Thank-you.

Anna

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    The population density will be a function of how much food you give them and how much is available naturally. You will get a very large population of goldfish. Introduce some predators that eat small goldfish like sunfish or bream as you folks call them.

  • 19 years ago

    So do most people who have goldfish in a largish pond get overpopulation? Is it more likely to happen in a cool or hot climate?

    Anna

  • 19 years ago

    Anna, it all depends on how much cover there is for baby goldfish. Goldfish will eat their own eggs. They also only spawn when the water is cool (70-85°F).

    Happy ponding,
    Scott

  • 19 years ago

    What if I don't feed them at all? There are a lot of water bugs, tadpoles of all sizes and I'm sure there's stuff in the string algae. Would they be less likely to breed if they had to forage for food?

    I just don't want to be faced with having to get rid of fish or having that be a problem. Right now I am happy with my water garden, but it would be nice to have something new to look at.

    Anna

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Anna
    The main problem I've ever had with keeping any fish was predation ,mainly from water birds. The fancy tailed goldfish don't stanfd a chance lol
    For that reason I keep mainly tropical fish. Swordtails and platies are co;orful, remain small and provide lots of food for wildlife.lol Have never been completely wiped out though.They even survive frosts but there are large die offs.
    Some choices for a large pond susch as yours might be some of the larger cichlids ,like firemouths, Oscars or even some of the Africans. Most of the tetras do well also but are rather plain from the top . but they are fast enough to escape most birds.
    I'm converting my 5x10 pool to temp control as i want to keep angels and discus.Hopefully for the pet market.
    You might also consider some food fish such as Cats or Tilapia. No overpopulation with these lol.
    Must tell you that the orchids you gave me are flowering
    Though the one in the basket has more than the one on the wall. Very nice but they clash with a brilliant red epiphyllum lol. My first daybloomer. Thanks
    gary.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Gary!

    I really do want to at least try goldfish as long as it won't present a big problem. The pond is about 3 1/2 feet at its deepest, so I'm eager to see if the herons won't be able to get them. Also, thanks to you, I now have divided my lilies and soon, there will be enough cover for the fish to hide. Glad to hear you've not had a problem with overpopulation. I may try some swordtails and platies also.

    I'm happy to hear your c. skinneri is blooming. Mine is just about in full bloom and beautiful. I love the bold colors- even when they clash together! I bet its almost vibrant! Don't repot the orchid this year. You'll be impressed how much it grows this year and will put on a terrific show next year.

    Anna

  • 19 years ago

    Anna
    If you get goldfish get the types with the long tails rather than the fantails , Much better swimmers. get some with nice markings ,color, and fins so that if they do over produce you can trade them back to the petshop.I'm sure the size and depth of your pool will make a big difference.
    Green night herons were the worst for me . The goldfish did reproduce but I never got more than 50 total.
    If you get Swordtails or Platies get a light color such as red ,yellow ,albino. Two or three pairs is enough and be sure to get all the same colors as they will cross and quickly revert back to the wild green color.. They will reproduce but remain under 4 inches. so the pool can handle a lot more. and the Herons can eat all they like lol.
    I've had my red velvets since 82 and have yet to run out lol. They are also great at mosquito control.
    The Catt is beautiful. I have the white form also flowering right now along with some Dends and Epidendrums.
    catts are my favorite orchid though.
    This is the first flowering of the red dayblooming Epicactus .Has 6 flowers 10 inches in diameter!!. have kept the night bloomers for many years but this is my first colored day flower. Also got some of those "rat tail " types with the dense spines. No flowers as yet but are growing nicely. Can't resist petting them. lol.feels almost like cat hair.lol.
    Good luck with your goldfish and thanks for the plants gary