Software
Houzz Logo Print
gee8ch

Brown Water?

18 years ago

Hello: New to water gardening. Thanks to a generous GW friend I've got my first lotus tuber. Followed Joyce's instructions to a Tee. Have two baby leaves on my lotus. However, the water is dark brown (manure tea?) and I don't think enough sunlight can penetrate to stimulate lotus growth. Is there some way to lighten the water? Is it natural for the water to stay brown? Would something other than the composted manure work as a planting medium so the water would remain clear? Please forgive so many questions. Love the looks of the lotus and really think I'm on my way to an addiction!! Appreciate any and all advice. Gloria

Comments (12)

  • 18 years ago

    How about more info on your pond the lotus are in?

  • 18 years ago

    sounds like tannins leaking out of the compost....
    Lawanna

  • 18 years ago

    just let it sit for a couple days. i have a tub with a lotus in it, it is about 20-22" deep and about two thirds full of manure/loam. it was dirty for about a week or so but it all settled and is now clear, clearish that is, getting a little algae growth. it will clear up.

  • 18 years ago

    My first lotus did (is doing) the same thing. I think it's a compost tea rather than stirred up sediment. It wont settle out but it's not stopping growth either. I carefully bail the water out (to a watering can to put it on something else) every 3 or 4 days and replace with fresh which quickly goes brown. Last time I did it there was lots of new growth under the water that I had no idea about.
    I have no idea how Joyce keeps her water clear but I'm not worried now that I see what going on under the brown water.
    Vanessa

  • 18 years ago

    Ter.Man: I have a 19 gal. round container.
    Vanessa: You've described it exactly. Nothing is stirred up. This is all leaching from the composted manure layer. My lotus has been in the container for over 2 1/2 weeks. All is settled by now. Earlier, I bailed the water out of the container and SLOOOOWLY trickled in fresh water w/o disturbing the bottom layers. The water turned dark brown!Again, it must be steeping the manure. I'm glad to hear that this doesn't worry you, so I'll assume everything is continuing to grow well for you. I guess as a novice, I just needed to hear that this isn't something I screwed up on!! But I sure would like to know how (using composted manure) one can keep the water clear. ;0) Thanks for the encouragement. Gloria

  • 18 years ago

    You must have a lot of manure in there. What you are describing is called compost tea or manure tea and is used as a fertilizer. I hope you have been using it well diluted. Ordinarily discoloration is reduced or eliminated with Activated Charcoal, bagged and placed in a pre filter or just in the water flow. Sandy

  • 18 years ago

    Thought about charcoal, Sandy but there's no moving water. I think Gloria is using the same kind of container. Just a big utility tub. My compost is coming from very organic topsoil rather than Joyce's recommended mixture. I put about an inch and a half of pea gravel on top hoping to separate it from the water enough to keep it clear but that made no difference. I might try coarse sand in the future. It's really so diluted that I don't think it's anything more than just unattractive. But I also figure it's good fertilizer for the land garden which is why I re-use it.
    Gloria, did you put a layer of something over the compost? By the way, I'm a novice too, but I'm glad we can share experiences.
    Vanessa

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Vanessaa: Yes, I put a generous layer of gravel over the manure. But holding it down is not causing the problem of the darkened water. It's def. the composted manure. Over the next few weekends, I'm planning to start all over again, and this time not use the composted manure as a planting meduium. I'm going to use the osmocote and the soil proportions as Joyce says, but I will be using plain old clay soil covered with gravel as my planting layer. I think that should not only result in clearer water, but also better leafing. Please stay in touch on how you do. Gloria

  • 18 years ago

    Gloria,
    Here's a photo of the lotus tub this morning with all it's murky water. Some sun managed to shine through enough to light up an underwater leaf that was pretty close to the surface (and wasn't in evidence a week ago).
    {{gwi:193922}}

    Here's what was going on when I bailed out most of the water - about 3 gal.

    {{gwi:193923}}

    Not in focus but you can see there's really plenty of growth and more coming. I think it looks pretty good!

    Vanessa

  • 18 years ago

    Vanessa: Thanks very much for the pictures ... really helps. Your water is clearer than mine. Even after bailing it out and adding fresh water, my tub looks like your first picture. That's why I'm afraid not enough lite is reaching the tuber. Def. going to scrap the manure and start over again with garden clay soil, a layer of sand, and cover it all with some gravel. Gloria

  • 18 years ago

    Let me know how it works. I plan on repotting this one into a larger container next year and I would sure prefer clearer water!
    Vanessa

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for your help. Hope your lotus does well for you this season. I've just gotten some seeds, so that will be another post!!! lol Warmest regards, Gloria

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio