Software
Houzz Logo Print
vtandrea

Did I just kill my phal?

19 years ago

I'm fairly new to orchid growing but have had phenomenal success with a dendrobium I bought a couple years ago. A neighbor recently gave me a phalaenopsis because she was moving away. It looked pretty good, but had several wrinkled, very dark green leaves. She had potted it into a plastic pot within her clay pot and there was no drainage! I unpotted it and cut off the decaying roots, then repotted it. Now I've been unsure how much water to give it, as various websites say the wrinkled leaves can be a sign of too much or too little water. Today I noticed another couple wrinkled leaves. On the theory that it's probably going to die anyway, I cut off the wrinkled leaves and applied cinnamon to the edges. I also put it in a bowl of water with 30-10-10 fertilizer at half strength and let it sit for about half an hour. My orchids are in a sunroom with southeastern exposure and I've put the pots on trays with water for humidity. (Not sitting in the water.) Was cutting off the leaves a bad thing to do? Is it a goner?

Comments (2)

  • 19 years ago

    Hi, VTAndrea,

    Hard to tell yet if the Phal will make it. Another time, consider leaving any leaf that's green, unless it has signs of disease. Even wrinkled leaves can help w/ photosynthesis. Good catch on applying cinnamon.

    The wrinkled leaves that showed up after you repotted it could be a reaction to the Phal being either too wet or dry when your neighbor had it - likely too wet, if there was no drainage.

    How did the roots look? Were there a fair number of healthy ones? If so, you've got a better chance of reviving the plant.

    Phals are quite hardy. If you repotted in sphag in a pot w/ extra drainage - more holes in the bottom or slits on the side, it may be fine, but it'll take awhile to know - part of the Zen of orchid growing. If it has a new leaf that keeps growing, that can be a good sign. If the other leaves stay green, even if they wrinkle, that can be a good sign, too.

    If a plant is stressed, you can withhold fertilizer for about a month. Also, you may know to withhold water for a solid week right now so the raw ends of the roots have time to harden over and thus resist disease.

    People have different opinions on the initial amount of light for a newly-potted or stressed plant - well, that's not the only thing. :) I'll leave it to them to advise you on that. For a healthy Phal, though, your SE exposure is terrific, if the Phal is right up next to a window.

    Congrats on success w/ your Den.

    Hang in there, Whitecat8

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with whitecat that overwatering (which rots roots, and hence deprives the plant of water) is the likeliest cause of the wrinkled leaves, given the no drainage. She is giving you good advice.

    As to cutting off wrinkled leaves-- sometimes I cut them off, if they're really bothering me. But mostly I don't.

    Your plant may be a goner, or not, but it's not likely that anything you did is what finished it. That no drainage pot is what did it in.

    Floating it in a fertilizer solution is a good idea, it can absorb some nutrients thru the leaves. I've always found that perks a stressed plant up. If it has any roots at all, even small ones, you can probably save it.

    Repot it into a pot that just fits the roots it has-- if very few roots, then very small pot.

    As for watering-- phals want to be moist, but not wet. Let dry some between waterings, but not completely crispy-dry. When you do water, water thoroughly, but don't water "too often". A good rule of thumb is to heft the pot-- if the pot is light, it needs water. There are other watering methods, see the FAQ for others.

    Use your plantsman's judgment as well-- smaller roots, less water.

    Good luck.

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!