Software
Houzz Logo Print
shellva

approaching someone about cuttings..

18 years ago

I pass a run down trailer on my way to work. I'm still trying to figure out if someone lives there, I think it's inhabited. Anyway, in the yard is a beautiful but neglected rose. It's probably 6 or so feet wide and just as tall. Beautiful dark pink flowers cover this bush in spring and in fall.

I would love to ask the owners for some cuttings. Has anyone here ever approached someone to ask to make cuttings?

And when would be the best time to take those cuttings? I've never propagated a rose before. Should the plant be budding out, just blooming, spent blooms?

I'm not too worried about the paticulars of how to take rose cuttings and what to do with them...just the timing.

Thanks everyone for your help.

Michelle

Comments (15)

  • 18 years ago

    Good question. There is a house near me where someone planted several roses. I hate to walk by and see them uncared for. I have wanted to ask them for cuttings and this spring, I plan to. Are you brave enough to approach the residents?

    Carla

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, I think I am brave enough to approach. I'm wondering if I should go bearing gifts. If it would be okay to wait until summer to take cuttings, I could always show up at their door with some tomatoes and other veggies from my garden.

    I feel kind of funny just going up and asking to take cuttings without offering them something in return. Hard cash isn't really an option at this point in time though.

    Michelle

  • 18 years ago

    Just ask! Most people are pleased to give cuttings. Just rave a little how you have admired it from a distance. In spring, bring a bouquet of roses from your garden or some veggies.
    Jim

    PS-Most people would be flattered.Years ago, people paid me the compliment by just slowing down as they drove by to better gaze at my front bed of zinnias.

  • 18 years ago

    I've stopped and asked lots of times. Especially in the run down yards, because I like to see a rose that will live through neglect. I have never had a person look at me weird or tell me it was OK just to be nice. There are 2 groups of people; those that don't really even know the rose is there, and those that are flattered that you think their rose is pretty enough to try to reproduce. I've offered cuttings in return to the people who did care, but they've never wanted them.

    Your tag says you are from Camden. Is that Camden Arkansas? I was just there last Wednesday.

    Carrie - from Texarkana

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, Yes! Chat them up. Tell them how much you have enjoyed looking at their rose-ask for the history..take pictures! People are flattered even when they dont know a thing-then casually ask-would you mind if I took some cuttings(suckers) so I could try to id it(if unknown) or add to my collection-it is so beautiful. I have never ever had anyone say no. It is never a good idea to take without asking. You could get into the most terrible trouble. The best time to take cuttings from a repeating rose is after the first bloom-take pencil sized cuttings from a cane that has spent blooms-go to the progagation forum for details. Be sure to get bits with leaf buds! It is possible to root the old floral sprays but they will have no buds.

    patricia

  • 18 years ago

    By all means, bear gifts. Then you have all the bases covered. For all the gardeners who are willing to give away cuttings, there are a few that are Lola's advocates: "Never give anything away that you can sell." Some folks just can't make themselves give anything away. So take a little plant you've started or something to exchange, especially if it looks like they aren't gardeners.

  • 18 years ago

    Depending on the state of decrepitude of the trailer, you might want to check with the registrar of deeds (at your county courthouse) to see who owns the land. If their address is the same as the trailer, then you'll know you are dealing with the owner who may be able to tell you history.
    If it's renter occupied, you should send the owner a letter asking permission, first, and once that's in hand, then ask the renter.
    If the place smells 'chemical-ly', stay away. No rose is worth an accidental encounter with a meth lab.

  • 18 years ago

    I have one of my rose garden out in the front yard literally next to the sidewalk. People are always giving me compliments on the roses as they pass by. I know if someone asked me for cuttings I would gladly share and even make sure they were all correctly labeled.

  • 18 years ago

    Years ago I admired a huge once blooming rose down the street from one of my best friends. It covered the fence on a side yard and was simply huge. I knocked on the door and asked for a cutting and was rudely told no. I didnt know the name of the rose, but kept searching until I ID'ed it. It was Vielchenblau. Easily ordered and obtainable. I now have it growing in my yard. But.....this episode started my interest in old garden roses, and I am, today, a proud addict with lots growing, and lots on order for the spring! I guess the moral is, if at first you dont succeed......
    Judith

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your input. I'll wait till warmer weather and approach the home with gifts of some sorts. I know I would be flattered if someone asked about my roses.

    I agree with Carrie, any rose that is thriving on neglect needs to somehow get into my yard. And no Carrie, I'm in Camden, NC. I did live in Memphis for 4 years about 4 years ago. That's as close to Camden, AR as I've ever been. Feel free to stop on by though should you ever make it out to Camden, NC:)

    Judith, I have Vielchenblau. I'd have let you take cuttings:)

    Thanks again everyone. I'll report back when I get the nerve to go knocking.

    Michelle

  • 18 years ago

    I've stopped at houses to ask questions about plants. I've never asked for a cutting, but the people were so flatter I would think they would of said yes. That's why I'm so shocked at Judith's experience!
    My Leontine Gervais rambler always get lots of compliments. One of my neighbors asked for a cutting. I told her any time she wanted to take some she was welcome to. Well, a few people on GW wanted some too so I decided to rooted a few. They all rooted so I gave one to my neighbor saving her the trouble of rooting it herself.

    I have very good luck with rooting roses after the June(probably earlier down where you are)bloom. I don't do anything fancy. I pretty much stick the cuttings, like 4 or 5(not all of them always take,) in gallon pots after dipping them in rooting hormone. Oh I do scrape off some of the outer layer of the cane at the bottom and use a pencil to start the hole so not all the rooting hormone wipes off before the canes get stuck in the pot. I keep them moist and put them where they get morning sun only. Once new growth starts, I water them just like any other potted plant. When I know they have some nice roots, I separate them into individual pots. Once they fill those pots with roots, I plant them or give them away.
    Remy

  • 18 years ago

    i think the approach would mean everything. I had a guy stop here and ask what i was going to do with my apples. I told him i only had one, but he informed me in years past that the tree's had been loaded. Bad approach. But I let a farmer use my machine shed to store his equipment because he offered to rent it, although i refuse to accept payment.
    I'd just ask them what the name of the rose was and that you've searched and searched and haven't seen one like it and you just have to have one.

  • 18 years ago

    Here in Italy I've encountered people who were wonderfully generous, and people who were misers. The misers turned me down even though I was offering a trade, and I can only think that such an irrational attitude had to be based on a suspicion that anything another person wanted had to be more valuable than they had ever realized, and they would surely lose on a trade proposed by a stranger. The generous people offered me cuttings of everything in the yard. It's so easy to spread happiness when you have a garden.

    Melissa

  • 18 years ago

    I would think to go when you see them in bloom. Start a conversation with them, telling them how beautiful the rose looks; then mention that you'd love cuttings when the blooms are spent.

  • 18 years ago

    Isn't it funny how many different responses to a simple request you might get?

    Several years ago when first bitten by the rose rustling and collecting bug, I became very brazen. I was always taught, "seek and ye shall find, knock and the door shall be opened, ask and it shall be given".... so I just walked up to the door, knocked, smiled, small talk about the yard and the roses, informed them that I was just starting out in gardening, and wondered if they could tell me which ones were easiest to grow, what did they do to care for them, ... and if the offer was not forthcoming from the lady of the house first, I would eventually ask if I could cut a tiny piece to try to root. If you are a talkative sort, this is easy enough. If you are shy, take a bold friend with you that can help with the social awkwardness. And of course there is personal security, safety in numbers. As Ann mentioned, no rose is worth an accidental encounter with crime.

    It helps your cause to come bearing gifts. Some folks would be wary of accepting food, from a stranger, so I would just make it a plant, some seeds, or just a small token that would be a friendly gesture between gardeners.

    Try to have fun with it. You might meet an old coot with no sense of fun or sharing, but you might meet a new friend.

    ~Allison