Software
Houzz Logo Print
boulder345

algicide vs. pond critters

19 years ago

We have a new pond. Living in Boulder, Colorado, it gets a lot of sunlight. Algae is a problem. Our landscaper has put in an algicide a few times and it has worked quite well. However, now I have begun to build the ecosystem. First, I put in some water lilies, water iris, frog spit (very disappointing) and finally duck weed. The plants have tolerated the algicide quite well.

Last weekend, I put in 4 dozen fathead minnows. The theory is that they will help to control the mosquito problem. In 2 - 3 weeks, I am planning to stock it with fingerling bass and bluegills.

I have heard that fish will tolerate an algicide, but crustaceans will not. I was planning to put in 10 - 20 crayfish.

Can anyone offer any insight about this?

Comments (3)

  • 19 years ago

    An algicide is a quick temporary fix. I never use it since chemicals aren't a good solution in the long run.

    Fathead minnows are good to keep the mosquitos in check. I use them in my ponds and bog gardens in southern Colorado.

    Fathead minnow breed and multiply really fast. So they will provide food for the bluegills and bass.

    These type fish do not show up well in the water anyway due to their darker colors so why worry about algae. Nature will eventually balance it out, but it will never be completely clear like a mountain stream.

    If your want clear water you need a good biofilter.

    Some waterweeds would also help and provide the fish something to hide in. Go to one of the local lakes and gets some from there. That is what I did and they worked much better than those from the pet store.

    Your bluegills will grow fairly fast and get much larger than in the local lakes. I feed mine regular goldfish floating pellets which they eat well.

    So it sounds like you are on the way. Just stop using those algicides.

    How large is your pond? Since you are stocking with game fish I am assuming it is large?

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the advice. What is a bio filter?

    I actually have a stream with a series of 4 small pools and 2 waterfalls. There is a large (relatively) pond at the bottom. The stream section is about 50 ft long, ~3 ft wide and the pond is about 10 ft x 15 ft. Total vertical drop is about 8 ft - about 1/2 of that is in 2 waterfalls. Max pond depth is about 3 1/2 ft. The average for the stream is probably about 4 - 6 inches.

    There are sections in the stream where the water runs over boulders and the water is too shallow for any aquatic life to go there to attack the algae. Some algae is OK, but I don't really want bright green rocks in those shallow sections. My wife would prefer the mountain stream look (not realizing that there is a lot of algae growing in those mountain streams).

    I thought that I would go to Boulder Creek and collect some nymphs to introduce. I know that I got a few bugs when I collected duckweed last weekend. Even before I introduced wild stuff, some insects had already taken up residence.

  • 19 years ago

    As already advised, algaecide is a short term fix and won't solve anything in the long run. If you keep using it-it will effect your plants and any wildlife and fish.

    Wanting perfectly clean rocks is going to be a lesson in futility.

    A biofilter will help with water quality but not necessarily with algae. Some algae is normal in all ponds.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Skippy Filter