Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardennatlanta

Help me choose a BIG Tea

16 years ago

I know you're probably tired of hearing about my expanded garden area but I've had a new idea of laying it out that will allow me to put in one more BIG tea.

What do you suggest for the hot humid southeast that has good disease resitance, beautiful bloom, good rebloom and a nice fragrance? --surprisingly fragrance is the least important issue for this spot.

I have Mrs. B.R. Cant already planted somewhere else and I have G. Nabonnand on order. The area could take one more rose that will get to be 9 X 9 or so.

It will be planted near G. Nabonnand and Darlow's Enigma in a large triangle of the three kind of making a huge hedge type idea.

Suggestions, please?

Thanks! Jeff

Comments (25)

  • 16 years ago

    You might consider 'Le Pactole.'
    We find it to be a real honker.

    Jeri

  • 16 years ago

    I second the motion for Le Pactole, a big and gorgeous bloom machine.

  • 16 years ago

    In time, Mons Tillier can grow to be immense.

  • 16 years ago

    Le Pactole and Monsieur Tillier are both splendid choices. Niles Cochet would get real big...but I don't know about your climate. William R. Smith gets very large, and also Baronne Henriette de Snoy. Given the colors of G. Nabonnand and Darlow's Enigma...I think I like Malcolm's idea of Mons. Tillier best....it would give a nice contrast to the pale colors of the other two roses.

  • 16 years ago

    I was going to mention Mons. Tillier, but was off looking it up on HMF, and when I came back here two people who should know have already mentioned it! Help Me Find gives a size that is not really big, but in the Sacramento Cemetery Old Rose Garden it is ENORMOUS - and gorgeous! I saw it for the first time last Fall, and it was covered with healthy foliage from top to bottom, and covered also with blooms that knocked me out. Don't know about blackspot, this is the only plant of MT that I have ever seen, and of course this is California...

    Laura

  • 16 years ago

    Jeff, my MT is almost 2 years old and has been 6' tall for 6 months (and almost 6' wide). Who knows where he will wind up! I was going to suggest Baronne Henriette de Snoy. I have seen a huge one in a nearby garden. It was more like a tree with limbs! Way over my head. My MT isn't that darker color very often - maybe because we have heat for so long, and maybe because he's young, but I'll second MT. He does have a nice even shape.

    Sherry

  • 16 years ago

    You're right, Lagomorphmon, you really have to take those mature growth dimensions in catalogs with a grain of salt -- especially if you garden in zones 7 and above. Perhaps vendors and services like HMF take all zones into consideration & strive to hit a happy medium, who knows? Whatever their rationale, those low-ball figures can sure play havoc with garden design. I've certainly experienced the problem with Teas, but the same has occurred with most other classes as well.

    Gardennatlanta, a lovely Tea that is turning into a whopper for me is 'Mme Berkeley'. She wouldn't provide much contrast to 'G Nabbonand', but she would complement him beautifully, I think.

  • 16 years ago

    Hello Gardennatlanta, I know you are asking for Tea... but how about Mutabilis (China)? The butterfly colored blooms will have a nice contrast with gentle pink pale bloom of G. Nabonnand. I personally do not have one and about ask, but I heard he can glow huge in no time. He will handle our hot and humid climate with ease.

  • 16 years ago

    Jeff, how about Adam. His flowers are so pretty. Randy in Texas grew it and can vouch for it getting huge with luscious blooms.

    Juliet

    Here is a link that might be useful: ADAM

  • 16 years ago

    Windeaux, where is your zone 8 and how big is he for you???

  • 16 years ago

    Ok, let me rephrase the question, can anybody in zone 8 volunteer Mr. T's dimensions? Thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    White Maman Cochet is a great, big tea.
    Jill

  • 16 years ago

    Thus far my biggest and best teas are Mme Lombard and Safrano .

  • 16 years ago

    Would the colors of William Allen Richardson be very off with the rest of the group?

    Last summer when I truly could not do anything at all in the yard and I could barely walk by the end of the season this rose proved to be just amazing: huge, beautiful foliage, the bush always packed with gorgeous huge blooms.

  • 16 years ago

    Lagomorphmom, Sorry I didn't check back here sooner & see your question. Also sorry if my previous post seemed to indicate that I grow 'M. Tillier', because I don't. The only MT I'm familiar with in my neck of the woods is at least as large as my largest Tea, 'Mrs Dudley Cross', who's wider than she is tall, & I'd say she's about 7 ft tall. And to answer your second question, I garden in coastal Carolina where we're experiencing prolonged periods of near-record cold temps. Wondering how this will affect all my roses -- esp the Teas. I'm never concerned about our periodic (but always very brief), spates of freezing weather, but this winter they've gone on for DAYS.

  • 16 years ago

    Have you considered Le Vesuve? I have a huge old one in my garden, and also a baby that is about 5 years old. The baby is at least 6' x 6' by 7' tall, and is still getting bigger. Re cold, the old one has been here for 75 - 100 years, surviving with little or no attention. We are in zone 9, but trust me - in the last 20 years while I have lived here, we have had periods of low temps in the 20s for weeks, snow, etc., and it didn't even die back at all.

    Jackie

  • 16 years ago

    Jeff, in a book by Liz Druitt and G. Michael Shoup ("Landscaping With Antique Roses"), they have selected a limited number of teas to discuss and picture, roses that they especially like. From that select number, they describe only two as being "large bushes." One is Mrs. B. R. Cant. The other is Marie van Houtte, which is pictured (gorgeous and huge!) and mentioned as being similar to Mrs. Dudley Cross, except even larger and really quite vigorous. Not so low in thorns as Mrs. Dudley Cross, but fragrant. Healthy, and often found in older gardens.

    Best wishes,
    Mary

  • 16 years ago

    Jeff, I passed Mrs B R today. (She just had her 3rd birthday this weekend, and she's on Fortuniana roots.) The new shoots coming out of her were scary. None of this thin, fragile stuff, but 1/4" thick stems popping out everywhere. At the time I thought, "Have your fun cuz either the freezes or my pruning will get you soon enough." But now I'm thinking, "I wonder how big she can be." How huge is huge? And when I finally panic at the actuality of huge, will I be able to back up and regroup? Think about it, Jeff? Can you go 10x10? Or bigger?

    Sherry

  • 10 years ago

    Here in coastal SE Virginia Z8A, Monsieur Tillier is big but not QUITE as big as Mrs. BR Cant. 7 feet wide by 8 feet high. He's pretty close to a path so we have to really work to keep him from taking it over...

    And Mrs. BR Cant more like 12 feet wide by 8 feet high.

    I love that you have the space to really that your tea roses do their thing... it's what they want!

  • 10 years ago

    White Maman Cochet CL..I think she aims to take over the world. This is a really old thread but its still a good topic. lol

  • 10 years ago

    I feel I can comment with more experience now, because the gardens here are a lot more established than they were in 2010. Some of the teas here have been well-nigh astounding, and the biggest of them all might not be what people expect. Keep in mind, my climate may be very different from yours, but the two most mammoth teas in this garden are, believe it or not: Rosette Delizy, and Miss Atwood. Of these two, Miss Atwood takes the award.

  • 10 years ago

    Teas can take freezes. What they can't take is 0 degrees or below, I found that out the hard way. My Mrs BR Cant was getting to about 8 feet wide and putting on some serious height before the polar vortex cut it down to the roots.


    I second Marie van Houtte and loved it, it did not survive being dug up. And I think it has a nice contrast to BR.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Great photos on HMF, Jerome! I had no idea Miss Atwood could get THAT big. And that Rosette Delizy is something else. Beautiful!

    MY question would be, what tea (or China, for that matter) DOESN'T get huge? I can still remember in my mind the image of that tiny little Comtesse du Cayla at the SJHRG way back when and thinking, "There's a nice little rose..." :-) She is, in my garden of course, a 9'+ behemoth. Even Mme. Bravy, somewhat modest these past 5 years or so, seems to be getting restless... All the rest --- arrrgh! But, there could be worse afflictions!

  • 10 years ago

    I think it's a question of what teas will tolerate being treated as shrubs and kept smaller than they would like to normally grow and which ones won't. I have learned the hard way here, having ignored advice from veteran rosarians and one year pruning and thinning quite hard. Some took it, others didn't. I can (and need to) prune down Rosette Delizy (again, think hedge, not typical rose thinning) just to keep it in its space. It doesn't seem to mind that much. However, when I pruned and thinned it a few years ago, it pouted for a few seasons.

    Mons. Tillier has not ever recovered from that same prune/thin treatment of a few years ago. I wouldn't say it's in decline...but maybe.

    I don't have Comtesse du Cayla or Mme. Bravy, so don't know.